Abstract:Based on 15 Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP) phase 3 (CMIP3) and 32 CMIP phase 5 (CMIP5) models, a detailed diagnosis was carried out to understand what compose the biases in simulation of the Indian Ocean basin mode (IOBM) and its capacitor effect. Cloud-radiation-SST (CRS) feedback and wind-evaporation-SST (WES) feedback are the two major atmospheric processes for SST changes. Most CMIP models simulate a stronger CRS feedback and a weaker WES feedback. During boreal fall of the El Niño/Southern Oscillation developing year and the following spring, there are weak biases of suppressed rainfall anomalies over the Maritime Continent and anomalous anticyclone over South Indian Ocean. Most CMIP models simulate reasonable short wave radiation (SWR) and weaker latent heat flux (LHF) anomalies. This leads to a weak bias of atmospheric processes. During winter, however, the rainfall anomalies are stronger due to west bias, and the anomalous anticyclone is comparable to observations. As such, most models simulate stronger SWR and reasonable LHF anomalies, leading to a strong bias of atmospheric processes. The thermocline feedback is stronger in most models. Though there is a deep bias of climatology thermocline, most models capture reasonable sea surface height-induced SST anomalies. Therefore, the effect of oceanic processes offset the weak bias of atmospheric processes in spring, and the tropical Indian Ocean warming persists into summer. However, anomalous northwest Pacific (NWP) anticyclone is weaker due to weak and west bias of the capacitor effect. The unrealistic western Pacific SST anomalies in models favor the westward extension of Rossby wave from the Pacific, weakening the effect of Kelvin wave from the Indian Ocean. Moreover, the western Pacific warming forces the NWP anticyclone move farther north than observations, suggesting a major forcing from the Pacific. Compared to CMIP3, CMIP5 models simulate the feedbacks more realistically and display less diversity. Thus, the overall performance of CMIP5 models is better than that of CMIP3 models.

Do CMIP5 models show El Niño diversity

A study of climate model responses of the western Pacific subtropical high to El Niño diversity

Do CMIP6 models capture the observed anomalous asymmetric Hadley circulation during historical El Niño decaying stage

Future impacts of two types of El Niño on East Asian rainfall based on CMIP5 model projections

Diverse Relationship Between ENSO and the Northwest Pacific Summer Climate among CMIP5 Models: Dependence on the ENSO Decay Pace

Over-projected Pacific warming and extreme El Niño frequency due to CMIP5 common biases

Sources of Inter‐Model Diversity in the Strength of the Relationship Between the Indian Summer Monsoon Rainfall and El Niño‐Southern Oscillation

Relationships between the Hadley circulation and tropical sea surface temperature with different meridional structures simulated in CMIP6 models

Origins of biases in CMIP5 models simulating northwest Pacific summertime atmospheric circulation anomalies during the decaying phase of ENSO

Projected Changes to Characteristics of El Niño‐Southern Oscillation, Indian Ocean Dipole, and Southern Annular Mode Events in the CMIP6 Models

Patterns of Tropical Pacific Convection Anomalies and Associated Extratropical Wave Trains in AMIP5

ENSO Diversity in a Tropical Stochastic Skeleton Model for the MJO, El Niño, and Dynamic Walker Circulation

The role of zonal advective feedback in depicting the deficiency of ENSO’s diversity in CESM2

Diversity of the Pacific–Japan Pattern among CMIP5 Models: Role of SST Anomalies and Atmospheric Mean Flow

The dominant North Pacific atmospheric circulation patterns and their relations to Pacific SSTs: historical simulations and future projections in the IPCC AR6 models

Contrasting transition complexity between El Niño and La Niña: Observations and CMIP5/6 models

On the relationship between ENSO diversity and the ENSO atmospheric teleconnection to high‐latitudes

A Study of Biases in Simulation of the Indian Ocean Basin Mode and Its Capacitor Effect in CMIP3/CMIP5 Models

CMIP6 Models Underestimate ENSO Teleconnections in the Southern Hemisphere

Comparison of past and future simulations of ENSO in CMIP5/PMIP3 and CMIP6/PMIP4 models

Linking the tropical Indian Ocean basin mode to the central-Pacific type of ENSO: Observations and CMIP5 reproduction