Abstract:Introduction: High sugar intake is associated with many chronic diseases. However, non-caloric sweeteners (NCSs) might fail to successfully replace sucrose due to the mismatch between their rewarding sweet taste and lack of caloric content. The natural NCS erythritol has been proposed as a sugar substitute due to its satiating properties despite being non-caloric. We aimed to compare brain responses to erythritol vs. sucrose and the artificial NCS sucralose in a priori taste, homeostatic, and reward brain regions of interest (ROIs). Methods: We performed a within-subject, single-blind, counterbalanced fMRI study in 30 healthy men (mean ± SEM age:24.3 ± 0.8 years, BMI:22.3 ± 0.3 kg/m2). Before scanning, we individually matched the concentrations of both NCSs to the perceived sweetness intensity of a 10% sucrose solution. During scanning, participants received 1 mL sips of the individually titrated equisweet solutions of sucrose, erythritol, and sucralose, as well as water. After each sip, they rated subjective sweetness liking. Results: Liking ratings were significantly higher for sucrose and sucralose vs. erythritol (both pHolm = 0.0037); water ratings were neutral. General Linear Model (GLM) analyses of brain blood oxygen level-depended (BOLD) responses at qFDR<0.05 showed no differences between any of the sweeteners in a priori ROIs, but distinct differences were found between the individual sweeteners and water. These results were confirmed by Bayesian GLM and machine learning-based models. However, several brain response patterns mediating the differences in liking ratings between the sweeteners were found in whole-brain multivariate mediation analyses. Both subjective and neural responses showed large inter-subject variability. Conclusion: We found lower liking ratings in response to oral administration of erythritol vs. sucrose and sucralose, but no differences in neural responses between any of the sweeteners in a priori ROIs. However, differences in liking ratings between erythritol vs. sucrose or sucralose are mediated by multiple whole-brain response patterns.

Sensitivity to Sweetness Correlates to Elevated Reward Brain Responses to Sweet and High-Fat Food Odors in Young Healthy Volunteers

Differences in brain responses between lean and obese women to a sweetened drink

Increased Brain Reward Responsivity to Food‐Related Odors in Obesity

Hunger and BMI modulate neural responses to sweet stimuli: fMRI meta-analysis

Salivary Leptin and TAS1R2/TAS1R3 Polymorphisms Are Related to Sweet Taste Sensitivity and Carbohydrate Intake from a Buffet Meal in Healthy Young Adults.

Higher sensitivity to sweet and salty taste in obese compared to lean individuals

Food-Related Odors Activate Dopaminergic Brain Areas.

Brain Responses to Food Odors Associated With BMI Change at 2-Year Follow-Up

Neural responses to oral administration of erythritol vs. sucrose and sucralose explain differences in subjective liking ratings

Nutritive/non-nutritive sweeteners and high fat diet contribute to dysregulation of sweet taste receptors and metabolic derangements in oral, intestinal and central nervous tissues

Association of Salty and Sweet Taste Recognition with Food Reward and Subjective Control of Eating Behavior

Good taste or gut feeling? A new method in rats shows oro‐sensory stimulation and gastric distention generate distinct and overlapping brain activation patterns

How the Brain Represents the Reward Value of Fat in the Mouth.

Processing of Sweet, Astringent and Pungent Oral Stimuli in the Human Brain

Sucrose activates human taste pathways differently from artificial sweetener

Love at first taste: Activation in reward-related brain regions during single-trial naturalistic appetitive conditioning in humans

Modulation of sweet preference by the actual and anticipated consequences of eating

Enhanced Affective Brain Representations of Chocolate in Cravers Vs. Non-Cravers

The sweet taste signalling pathways in the oral cavity and the gastrointestinal tract affect human appetite and food intake: a review

Prefrontal-Limbic Circuitry is Associated with Reward Sensitivity in Nonhuman Primates

The Role of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Sensory Factors in Sweetness Perception of Food and Beverages: A Review