MG Plus : Towards Efficient Context Inconsistency Detection by Minimized Link Generation
Chuyang Chen,Huiyan Wang,Lingyu Zhang,Chang Xu,Ping Yu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/stvr.1899
2024-01-01
Abstract:Self-adaptive applications are becoming increasingly attractive, with the ability to smartly understand their runtime environments (or contexts) and deliver adaptive services, for example, location-aware navigation or resource-sensitive suggestions. However, due to inherent noises in the process of sensing and interpreting environmental information, there is a growing demand for guarding the consistency of collected contexts to avoid application misbehaviour and, at the same time, minimize extra costs. Existing work attempted to achieve this by speeding up the kernel constraint checking module inside the consistency guarding process. Most of these efforts were spent on reusing previous checking results or parallelizing the checking process, but they all leave one central step of constraint checking, that is, link generation, untouched. In this step, the checking engine provides reasons to explain the violation of constraints under check. It occupies a substantial part of the total time cost. Focusing on this key link generation step, we proposed MG, which deploys a rigourous analysis to automatically identify and avoid redundancy in the link generation without harming any correctness of the checking results. MG has been proven sound (always guaranteeing correctness) and complete (entirely removing redundancy). Moreover, based on our observation that MG's redundancy elimination also assists another core step of constraint checking to reduce unnecessary computation further, we additionally enhance MG with an escape-condition optimization to escape unnecessary evaluation of truth values to further improve the efficiency of constraint checking in an aspect other than link generation. We call it MG+ for distinguishing. Our experiments with synthesized and real-world consistency constraints reported that, compared with existing work, MG eliminates all link redundancy (83% to 0%), and based on it, MG+ further reduces significant truth value calculations (e.g., 49.74% reduction when combined with ECC and Con-C). Generally, MG brought 14x$$ \times $$-500x$$ \times $$ speed-ups in link generation, and MG+ further made 1.2x$$ \times $$-1.9x$$ \times $$ speed-ups in truth value evaluation. Altogether, MG reduced the total constraint checking time up to 45.4%, and MG+ reduced it up to 61.0%. MG can automatically identify and avoid all redundant link generation in the constraint checking process. MG's link elimination is both sound and complete, and this enables its high speed-ups in the link generation step (14-500x). MG+ reduces redundant truth value over MG, and this leads to an additional efficiency gain (1.2-1.9x). Both MG and MG+ show high checking efficiency (45.4% and 61.0% time reduction) to the whole checking process without harming any checking correctness.image