Abstract:Deep learning-based models for predicting blood glucose levels in diabetic patients can facilitate proactive measures to prevent critical events and are essential for closed-loop control therapy systems. However, selecting appropriate models from the literature may not always yield conclusive results, as the choice could be influenced by biases or misleading evaluations stemming from different methodologies, datasets, and preprocessing techniques. This study aims to compare and comprehensively analyze the performance of various deep learning models across diverse datasets to assess their applicability and generalizability across a broader spectrum of scenarios. Commonly used deep learning models for blood glucose level forecasting, such as feed-forward neural network, convolutional neural network, long short-term memory network (LSTM), temporal convolutional neural network, and self-attention network (SAN), are considered in this study. To evaluate the generalization capabilities of each model, four datasets of varying sizes, encompassing samples from different age groups and conditions, are utilized. Performance metrics include Root Mean Square Error (RMSE), Mean Absolute Difference (MAD), and Coefficient of Determination (CoD) for analytical asssessment, Clarke Error Grid (CEG) for clinical assessments, Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) test for statistical analysis, and generalization ability evaluations to obtain both coarse and granular insights. The experimental findings indicate that the LSTM model demonstrates superior performance with the lowest root mean square error and highest generalization capability among all other models, closely followed by SAN. The ability of LSTM and SAN to capture long-term dependencies in blood glucose data and their correlations with various influencing factors and events contribute to their enhanced performance. Despite the lower predictive performance, the FFN was able to capture patterns and trends in the data, suggesting its applicability in forecasting future direction. Moreover, this study helps in identifying the optimal model based on specific objectives, whether prioritizing generalization or accuracy.

A Novel RNN-Based Blood Glucose Prediction Approach Using Population and Individual Characteristics

Clu-RNN: A New RNN Based Approach to Diabetic Blood Glucose Prediction

Blood Glucose Prediction with Variance Estimation Using Recurrent Neural Networks

Blood Glucose Monitoring Using Non-Invasive Features of Wearable Devices and Machine Learning

A Novel Hybrid Deep Learning Model for Blood Glucose Prediction with Extended Prediction Horizons in Type-1 Diabetic Patients

A Hybrid Deep Learning Model for the Blood Glucose Prediction

Dynamic Partitioning of Graphs Based on Multivariate Blood Glucose Data—A Graph Neural Network Model for Diabetes Prediction

Optimization and Evaluation of an Intelligent Short-Term Blood Glucose Prediction Model Based on Noninvasive Monitoring and Deep Learning Techniques

Intelligent Ensemble Deep Learning System for Blood Glucose Prediction Using Genetic Algorithms

Utilizing deep neural network for web-based blood glucose level prediction system

Machine learning-based prediction of diabetic patients using blood routine data

Implementation of five machine learning methods to predict the 52-week blood glucose level in patients with type 2 diabetes

Long-term Prediction of Blood Glucose Levels in Type 1 Diabetes Using a CNN-LSTM-Based Deep Neural Network

Blood Glucose Prediction Based on Empirical Mode Decomposition and GA-BP Neural Network

Deep learning and regression approaches to forecasting blood glucose levels for type 1 diabetes

Benchmarking Machine Learning Algorithms on Blood Glucose Prediction for Type I Diabetes in Comparison With Classical Time-Series Models

Deep transfer learning: a novel glucose prediction framework for new subjects with type 2 diabetes

Convolutional Recurrent Neural Networks for Glucose Prediction

Deep learning for blood glucose level prediction: How well do models generalize across different data sets?

A Deep Transfer Learning Model for Personalized Blood Glucose Prediction

Prediction of Diabetes Progress Based on Machine Learning Approach