Primary School Students' Representation of Fractions in Non-symbolic Materials
Xin Ziqiang,Li Dan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.16719/j.cnki.1671-6981.2013.02.001
2013-01-01
Abstract:How do people represent fractions? Do they represent the real value of a fraction by accessing the magnitude of the whole numbers composing the fraction(componential) or directly represent the magnitude of whole fraction itself(holistic) ? Some researchers argued that,in the symbolic fraction comparison tasks,individuals may not directly access the magnitude of the whole fraction,but they process the magnitude of the components and estimate their ratio.However,other studies on symbolic fraction tasks suggested that people's fraction representation can be either holistic or componential.We propose,from an evolutionary perspective,that magnitude representation may be divided into two systems;physical representation system and symbolic representation system.Compared to the symbolic system,the physical representation system appears earlier,by which people can simulate or represent magnitudes more directly,and avoid some possible interferences of symbolic representation system.Therefore,it is necessary to return to this early magnitude representation system to investigate the representation mode of fractions. Considering the importance of fraction knowledge in the elementary mathematical education,the current study aimed to explore the fraction representation mode of students in primary schools by using non-symbolic fraction materials,which is based on the physical magnitude representation system.This study sampled 117 third through sixth-grade students in an ordinary primary school,whose parents are on the medium level of socioeconomic status.We tested their performance in fraction comparison tasks and recorded the reaction time to examine the distance effect and the effect of the spatial numerical association of response codes(SNARC),which are based on the assumption of mental number line. Results of ANOVA and regression analysis showed that;(1) with grade difference,subjects'reaction time in the fraction comparison tasks significantly reduced(F(3,110) = 28.50,p <.05,17 =.44),their reaction times were 1060.60ms,968.05ms, 813.44ms,and 724.47ms in each grade.(2) In each grade,there was a significant distance effect between the magnitude of the target fraction and the magnitude of the reference fraction,which were presented in the form of pictures(the R square were.91,.89,.94 and.91 respectively,ps <.05),and the distance effect size remained stable among four grades.Whereas the distance effect between the shadow area of the target fraction and the reference fraction in each grade was not significant(the R square were.09,.00,.01 and .08 respectively,the p values were.39,.88,.77 and.80 respectively).(3) In each grade,there was a significant SNARC effect when the magnitude of the target fraction was compared to the magnitude of the reference fraction(the F values were 15.36,22.44, 43.17 and 162.08 respectively,ps <.05,η~2 were.66,.74,.84 and.95 respectively).Results of the simple effect test argued that the response of left hand was faster to smaller fractions,and the response of right hand was faster to larger fractions. Therefore,we can conclude that;(1) when comparing the fractions in a non-symbolic form,third to sixth-graders'fraction representation are holistic and the efficiency of their representation significantly improves with grade.(2 ) Third-graders have been able to represent the magnitude of whole fraction on the mental number line,of which the smaller fractions are represented on the left and the larger fractions on the right.This study enhances our understanding about peoples representation of fractions in non-symbolic fraction materials (pictures),and suggests educators consider the necessity to change the fraction teaching methods.For instance,teachers can teach fraction knowledge in a non-symbolic form in earlier ages,maybe together with the whole number knowledge,which would assist students to construct fraction knowledge on the basis of their relevant daily life experience and avoid the interferences of whole number symbols.