Abstract:Boreal winter 2020/2021 was characterised by a negative North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) pressure pattern, yet the signals from the ensemble mean of many seasonal forecast systems were for a positive NAO. In this letter we focus on the GloSea5 seasonal forecast system and investigate if there is any evidence for forecast error, or whether the discrepancy was more likely due to unpredictable natural variability. Boreal winter (December–February) 2020/2021 in the North Atlantic/European region was characterised by a negative North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) index. Although this was captured within the ensemble spread of predictions from the Met Office Global Seasonal forecast system (GloSea5), with 17% of ensemble members predicting an NAO less than zero, the forecast ensemble mean was shifted towards a positive NAO phase. The observed monthly NAO anomalies were particularly negative in January and February, following an early January sudden stratospheric warming (SSW), and a prolonged period of Phase 6 or 7 of the Madden Julian Oscillation (MJO) in late January/early February. In contrast, predictions showed the expected teleconnection from the observed La Niña, with a positive NAO signal resulting from a weakening of the Aleutian Low leading to a reduction in tropospheric wave activity, an increase in polar vortex strength and a reduced chance of an SSW. Forecasts initialised later in the winter season successfully predicted the negative NAO in January and February once the SSW and MJO were within the medium range timescale. GloSea5 likely over‐predicted the strength of the La Niña which we estimate caused a small negative bias in the SSW probability. However, this error is smaller than the uncertainty in SSW probability from the finite forecast ensemble size, emphasising the need for large forecast ensembles. This case study also demonstrates the advantage of continuously updated lagged ensemble forecasts over a 'burst' ensemble started on a fixed date, since a change in forecast signal due to events within the season can be detected early and promptly communicated to users.

Why is the North Atlantic Oscillation More Predictable in December?

Interdecadal Change in the Northern Hemisphere Seasonal Climate Prediction Skill: Part I. the Leading Forced Mode of Atmospheric Circulation

Interdecadal Change in the Northern Hemisphere Seasonal Climate Prediction Skill: Part II. Predictability and Prediction Skill

Comparison of the Life Cycles of the NAO Using Different Definitions

Snow Cover on the Tibetan Plateau and Lake Baikal Intensifies the Winter North Atlantic Oscillation

The Effect of the Arctic Oscillation on the Predictability of Mid-High Latitude Circulation in December

A Robust Empirical Seasonal Prediction of Winter Nao and Surface Climate

Causal oceanic feedbacks onto the winter NAO

Conditional impact of boreal autumn North Atlantic SST anomaly on winter tropospheric Asian polar vortex

Predictability of European winter 2020/2021: Influence of a mid‐winter sudden stratospheric warming

Jet Latitude Regimes and the Predictability of the North Atlantic Oscillation

Tropical and stratospheric influences on winter atmospheric circulation patterns in the North Atlantic sector

The changing relationship between the December North Atlantic Oscillation and the following February East Asian trough before and after the late 1980s

The Role of Extratropical Air–Sea Interaction in the Autumn Subseasonal Variability of the North Atlantic Oscillation

Different prediction skill for the East Asian winter monsoon in the early and late winter season

Predictability of Indian Ocean precipitation and its North Atlantic teleconnections during early winter

Predictable Patterns of Wintertime Surface Air Temperature in Northern Hemisphere and Their Predictability Sources in the SEAS5

A modelling study of the impact of tropical SSTs on the variability and predictable components of seasonal atmospheric circulation in the North Atlantic–European region

Process Evaluation of Subseasonal North Atlantic Oscillation Prediction in the ECMWF Ensemble Forecast System

Assessment of responses of North Atlantic winter sea surface temperature to the North Atlantic Oscillation on an interannual scale in 13 CMIP5 models

NAO Seasonal Forecast Using a Multivariate Air–Sea Coupled Deep Learning Model Combined with Causal Discovery