Investigation of modulated electron radiation therapy for breast cancer
M Ding,C.C Ma,J Li,S.W McNeeley,L Chen,R.A Price,E Fourkal,L Qin,P Anderson,G Freedman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0360-3016(02)03336-9
2002-01-01
Abstract:Purpose/Objective: Modulated electron radiation therapy (MERT) is a new electron modality for the treatment of superficial targets. In MERT, dose conformity in the beam direction can be achieved by energy modulation, while lateral uniformity can be optimized by intensity modulation via a variable collimator. The effect of breathing motion is usually considered by applying a 1-2 cm margin around the target in conventional photon treatments for breast cancer. In MERT, the effect is somewhat lessened as the beams maintain an acute angle of incidence relative to the chest wall motion due to breathing. In this work we investigate MERT treatment planning based on Monte Carlo simulation and the effect of breathing motion on MERT beam delivery for breast cancer.Materials/Methods: A Monte Carlo based treatment planning system for modulated electron radiation therapy (MERT) has been created. This new technique utilizes an electron multileaf collimator (eMLC) to deliver non-uniform intensity distributions at 6 nominal energies (6, 9, 12, 15, 18, 21 MeV beams from a Simens PRIMUS linear accelerator). A patient geometry at any time during a breathing cycle is reconstructed using the CT data taken at the inspiration and expiration phases and the chest wall motion measured using an optical motion detector. Accurate correlation between the voxels in the inspiration (or expiration) geometry and the voxels in the reconstructed geometry at any point of the breathing cycle is established so that the dose to a voxel (or an organ) can be accumulated accurately during a treatment. Dose calculation is performed using the modified EGS4 user code MCDOSE for MERT planning, which includes pre-optimization electron beamlets simulation, electron MLC simulation, and post optimization dose calculations. MCDOSE phantom files for different phases of the breathing cycle are generated by an in-house program. Three dimensional (3D) dose data are obtained for each possible patient geometry in a breathing cycle. The final dose distribution is reconstructed from these 3D dose data.Results: In modulated electron radiation therapy for breast cancer, the target coverage depends not only on the tumor location and shape, but also on the electron energy. MERT provides better or similar target dose (prescribed to 50 Gy) coverage compared with conventional wedged tangential photon beams. However, MERT could significantly reduce the maximum dose to the lung (by up to 20 Gy) and to the heart (by up to 35 Gy) compared to conventional tangential wedged photon beams. The target dose coverage for an en-face beam arrangement will vary by about 2.5% for a 1-cm chest wall movement, and the critical structure dose remains the same during respiration.Conclusions: Because of its superior capabilities to achieve dose conformity both laterally and in the depth direction, MERT can be developed into a useful modality for superficial targets. The fact that MERT is minimally affected by breathing motion shows that MERT will be especially useful for the treatment of breast cancer. Purpose/Objective: Modulated electron radiation therapy (MERT) is a new electron modality for the treatment of superficial targets. In MERT, dose conformity in the beam direction can be achieved by energy modulation, while lateral uniformity can be optimized by intensity modulation via a variable collimator. The effect of breathing motion is usually considered by applying a 1-2 cm margin around the target in conventional photon treatments for breast cancer. In MERT, the effect is somewhat lessened as the beams maintain an acute angle of incidence relative to the chest wall motion due to breathing. In this work we investigate MERT treatment planning based on Monte Carlo simulation and the effect of breathing motion on MERT beam delivery for breast cancer. Materials/Methods: A Monte Carlo based treatment planning system for modulated electron radiation therapy (MERT) has been created. This new technique utilizes an electron multileaf collimator (eMLC) to deliver non-uniform intensity distributions at 6 nominal energies (6, 9, 12, 15, 18, 21 MeV beams from a Simens PRIMUS linear accelerator). A patient geometry at any time during a breathing cycle is reconstructed using the CT data taken at the inspiration and expiration phases and the chest wall motion measured using an optical motion detector. Accurate correlation between the voxels in the inspiration (or expiration) geometry and the voxels in the reconstructed geometry at any point of the breathing cycle is established so that the dose to a voxel (or an organ) can be accumulated accurately during a treatment. Dose calculation is performed using the modified EGS4 user code MCDOSE for MERT planning, which includes pre-optimization electron beamlets simulation, electron MLC simulation, and post optimization dose calculations. MCDOSE phantom files for different phases of the breathing cycle are generated by an in-house program. Three dimensional (3D) dose data are obtained for each possible patient geometry in a breathing cycle. The final dose distribution is reconstructed from these 3D dose data. Results: In modulated electron radiation therapy for breast cancer, the target coverage depends not only on the tumor location and shape, but also on the electron energy. MERT provides better or similar target dose (prescribed to 50 Gy) coverage compared with conventional wedged tangential photon beams. However, MERT could significantly reduce the maximum dose to the lung (by up to 20 Gy) and to the heart (by up to 35 Gy) compared to conventional tangential wedged photon beams. The target dose coverage for an en-face beam arrangement will vary by about 2.5% for a 1-cm chest wall movement, and the critical structure dose remains the same during respiration. Conclusions: Because of its superior capabilities to achieve dose conformity both laterally and in the depth direction, MERT can be developed into a useful modality for superficial targets. The fact that MERT is minimally affected by breathing motion shows that MERT will be especially useful for the treatment of breast cancer.