Abstract:The normative realm involves deontic notions such as obligation or permission, as well as information about relevant actions and states of the world. This mixture is not static, given once and for all. Both information and normative evaluation available to agents are subject to changes with various triggers, such as learning new facts or accepting new laws. This paper explores models for this setting in terms of dynamic logics for information-driven agency. Our paradigm will be dynamic-epistemic logics for knowledge and belief, and their current extensions to the statics and dynamics of agents' preferences. Here the link with deontics is that moral reasoning may be viewed as involving preferences of the acting agent as well as moral authorities such as lawgivers, one's conscience, or yet others. In doing so we discuss a large number of themes: primitive 'betterness' order versus reason-based preferences (employing a model of 'priority graphs'), the entanglement of preference and informational attitudes such as belief, interactive social agents, and scenarios with long-term patterns emerging over time. Specific deontic issues considered include paradoxes of deontic reasoning, acts of changing obligations, and changing norm systems. We conclude with some further directions, as well as a series of pointers to related work, including different paradigms for looking at these same phenomena.

From Classical to Non-monotonic Deontic Logic Using ASPIC$$^+$$

Defeasible deontic logic: arguing about permission and obligation

Non-monotonic Reasoning and Argumentation System

Prioritized Norms in Formal Argumentation

Modeling Non-Monotonic Properties under Propositional Argumentation

Argumentation-Based Non-Monotonic Reasoning of Agents

Problems of Inconsistency and Argumentation Logics

Dealing with Generic Contrariness in Structured Argumentation

Proof Theory and Decision Procedures for Deontic STIT Logics

A Modal Nonmonotonic Logic

Explaining Non-monotonic Normative Reasoning using Argumentation Theory with Deontic Logic

Monotonic Opaqueness in Deontic Contexts

Deontic Logic And Preference Change

Deontic Reasoning

Value-based Practical Reasoning: Modal Logic + Argumentation

Explicit non-normal modal logic

Positive Logic with Adjoint Modalities: Proof Theory, Semantics and Reasoning about Information

An Argumentation Framework for Non-monotonic Reasoning in Description Logic

Priority Structures in Deontic Logic

A Neutral Temporal Deontic STIT Logic

Prioritised Default Logic as Argumentation with Partial Order Default Priorities