Abstract:Understanding and improving the robustness of networks has significant applications in various areas, such as bioinformatics, transportation, critical infrastructures, and social networks. Recently, there has been a large amount of work on network dismantling, which focuses on removing an optimal set of nodes to break the network into small components with sub-extensive sizes. However, in our experiments, we found these state-of-the-art methods, although seemingly different, utilize the same refinement technique, namely reinsertion, to improve the performance. Despite being mentioned with understatement, the technique essentially plays the key role in the final performance. Without reinsertion, the current best method would deteriorate worse than the simplest heuristic ones; while with reinsertion, even the random removal strategy achieves on par with the best results. As a consequence, we, for the first time, systematically revisit the power of reinsertion in network dismantling problems. We re-implemented and compared 10 heuristic and approximate competing methods on both synthetic networks generated by four classical network models, and 18 real-world networks which cover seven different domains with varying scales. The comprehensive ablation results show that: i) HBA (High Betweenness Adaption, no reinsertion) is the most effective network dismantling strategy, however, it can only be applicable in small scale networks; ii) HDA (High Degree Adaption, with reinsertion) achieves the best balance between effectiveness and efficiency; iii) The reinsertion techniques help improve the performance for most current methods; iv) The one, which adds back the node based on that it joins the clusters minimizing the multiply of both numbers and sizes, is the most effective reinsertion strategy for most methods. Our results can be a survey reference to help further understand the current methods and thereafter design the better ones.

Efficient Network Dismantling Via Node Explosive Percolation*

Dismantling Networks by Skeleton Extraction and Greedy Tree Breaking

Optimal Dismantling of Interdependent Networks Based on Inverse Explosive Percolation

A Neighborhood Link Sensitive Dismantling Method for Social Networks

A New Centrality Measure Based on Neighbor Loop Structure for Network Dismantling

Embedding-aided network dismantling

Neural Extraction of Multiscale Essential Structure for Network Dismantling

A Novel Learning-Based Approach for Efficient Dismantling of Networks

Efficient network dismantling through genetic algorithms

Lower Bound of Network Dismantling Problem.

Cost-constrained network dismantling using quadratic evolutionary algorithm for interdependent networks

A Comparative Analysis of Approaches to Network-Dismantling.

Effective Optimal Dismantling Strategy for Interdependent Networks Based on Residual Theory

Network higher-order structure dismantling

Dismantling Complex Networks by a Neural Model Trained from Tiny Networks

Encoding Node Diffusion Competence and Role Significance for Network Dismantling

An Efficient Method to Collapse the Spatial Networks

Revisiting the Power of Reinsertion for Optimal Targets of Network Attack.

Evaluate Node Importance by Decomposing Network with a Recursive Percolation Process

ESND: An Embedding-based Framework for Signed Network Dismantling

Assessing Edge-Coupled Interdependent Network Disintegration Via Rank Aggregation and Elite Enumeration