Abstract:Anatomical distance has been widely used to predict functional connectivity because of the potential relationship between structural connectivity and functional connectivity. The basic implicit assumption of this method is "distance penalization." But studies have shown that one-parameter model (anatomical distance) cannot account for the small-worldness, modularity, and degree distribution of normal human brain functional networks. Two local information indices-common neighbor (CN) and preferential attachment index (PA), are introduced into the prediction model as another parameter to emulate many key topological of brain functional networks in the previous study. In addition to these two indices, many other local information indices can be chosen for investigation. Different indices evaluate local similarity from different perspectives. Currently, we still have no idea about how to select local information indices to achieve higher predicted accuracy of functional connectivity. Here, seven local information indices are chosen, including CN, hub depressed index (HDI), hub promoted index (HPI), Leicht-Holme-Newman index (LHN-I), Sørensen index (SI), PA, and resource allocation index (RA). Statistical analyses were performed on eight network topological properties to evaluate the predictions. Analysis shows that different prediction models have different performances in terms of simulating topological properties and most of the predicted network properties are close to the real data. There are four topological properties whose average relative error is less than 5%, including characteristic path length, clustering coefficient, global efficiency, and local efficiency. CN model shows the most accurate predictions. Statistical analysis reveals that five properties within the CN-predicted network do not differ significantly from the real data (P > 0.05, false-discovery rate method corrected for seven comparisons). PA model shows the worst prediction performance which was first applied in models of growth networks. Our results suggest that PA is not suitable for predicting connectivity in a small-world network. Furthermore, in order to evaluate the predictions rapidly, prediction power was proposed as an evaluation metric. The current study compares the predictions of functional connectivity with seven local information indices and provides a reference of method selection for construction of prediction models.

Method of brain functional network modeling based on nodes similarity

Research on Method of Brain Functional Network Modeling Based on Common Neighbor with different node scales

Research on Modeling Approach of Brain Function Network Based on Anatomical Distance

Comparison and Research on Connection Methods of Functional Brain Network Based on Node Properties in Network

Comparison of Local Information Indices Applied in Resting State Functional Brain Network Connectivity Prediction

Link Prediction in Brain Networks with Epilepsy Disease

Link Prediction in Brain Networks Based on a Hierarchical Random Graph Model

Construction Method and Application of Brain Functional Network Based on Link Prediction

A Comparative Study Of Theoretical Graph Models For Characterizing Structural Networks Of Human Brain

Functional Connectivity Network Estimation with an Inter-Similarity Prior for Mild Cognitive Impairment Classification

Assessing Graph Models For Description Of Brain Networks

Modelling and Analysis of Brain Functional Network

Research on Modeling of Brain Function Network in Major Depressive Disorder

Link prediction of brain networks based on hierarchical random graph model

The Intrinsic Similarity of Topological Structure in Biological Neural Networks.

Method of Functional Brain Network Modeling with Group Similarity Constraint for Mild Cognitive Impairment Classification

A New Method for Automatically Modelling Brain Functional Networks.

Exploration of the Brain Network Connection Modes Based on Resting State fMRI Data

Brain Functional Networks Analysis and Comparison

Local Structure Similarity Algorithm for Link Prediction

A study of brain-like neural network model