Abstract:<p>Extensive research has been conducted on e-tourism spanning a wide range of concepts, challenges and concerns discussed in tourism recommender systems (TRS). Smart tourism can be considered a logical progression from e-tourism laid with the extensive adoption of information and communication technologies and connecting the physical and digital worlds by taking advantage of 12 'smart key concepts' such as privacy protection, Internet of Things and augmented reality, among others. Consequently, several disparate types of research have existed in various classes of TRS that have accomplished smart key concepts where others have failed. However, such piecemeal development is insufficient for a pragmatic smart tourism solution. Accordingly, the current study complements the academic literature with a systematic review that covers all main aspects of the e-tourism management system applied to the smart tourism concepts over the last eight years of publication. This study also provides a state-of-the-art e-tourism data management classification taxonomy based on smart concepts and reviews works in different fields against that classification. To this end, we reviewed the ScienceDirect, IEEE Xplore and Web of Science databases. A total of 1240 papers were collected from 2013 to 2020. The retrieved articles were filtered according to the defined inclusion criteria. Finally, 65 articles were selected and classified into two categories. The first category includes smart-based TRS that accounts for 87.70% (n = 57/65) and classified into four approaches: collaborative filtering, content model, context model and hybrid model. The second category includes tourism marketing that accounts for 12.30% (n = 8/65). This multi-field systematic review has exposed new research opportunities, motivations, recommendations and challenges and limitations that need attention for the synergistic smart integration of interdisciplinary studies. The reliability and acceptability of smart-based TRS approach from the implemented 12 smart key concepts show a significant difference. Analysis shows that the content model-based approach has a highly important effect on smart e-tourism, i.e., applying numerous smart key concepts in higher mean (40.2%). Results of several past studies that used a content model-based approach were nearly perceived as smart e-tourism. The smartly achieved key concepts for hybrid and context-based approaches have approximate means of (37.9%) and 36.6%, respectively, thereby confirming results. The results of tourism marketing and collaborative filtering approaches are worse than the previously reported results, achieving means of (33.3%) and (30.3%), respectively. This study is a useful guide for researchers and practitioners in providing avenues and valuable information for future research. This study is also expected to address the ambiguity of e-tourism and smart tourism trends.</p>

Review on Tourism Recommendation System

Tourism recommendation system based on data mining

Intelligent recommendation model of tourist places based on collaborative filtering and user preferences

A Package Generation And Recommendation Framework Based On Travelogues

A novel recommendation system for the personalized smart tourism route: Design and implementation

A Systematic Survey of Tourism Recommender System Techniques and Challenges

Development of Ecological Health Tourism Products under the Background of Internet+

Tourist Routs Recommendation Based on Latent Dirichlet Allocation Model.

A Tourism Recommendation Algorithm Based on Fuzzy Clustering

Intelligent tourism recommender systems: A survey

TRS – A Rule Based Personalized Tourism Recommender System

Personalized Recommendation of Rural Tourism Based on Traffic Classification and User Data Analysis

Cross-Domain Recommendation Method in Tourism

A comprehensive review of mobile technology use in hospitality and tourism

WDTourism: A Personalized Tourism Recommendation System Based on Semantic Web

Tourism Recommendation System based in user's profile and functionality levels

A Comprehensive Survey on Travel Recommender Systems

Recommending POIs for Tourists by User Behavior Modeling and Pseudo-Rating

Research on Content-based Recommendations Model Based on User Specific Features for Scenic Spot

The Recommendation Method for Hotel Selection Under Traveller Preference Characteristics: A Cloud-Based Multi-Criteria Group Decision Support Model

How smart is e-tourism? A systematic review of smart tourism recommendation system applying data management