A Challenging Transition: Factors Influencing the Effort-Reward Imbalance and Coping Strategies of Beginning Teachers in China
Xintong Jiang,Runkai Jiao,Di Lu,Feifei Li,Hang Yin,Xiaoqing Lin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/prbm.s419822
IF: 3.974
2023-07-19
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Xintong Jiang, 1 Runkai Jiao, 1 Di Lu, 2 Feifei Li, 3 Hang Yin, 1 Xiaoqing Lin 1 1 School of Psychology, Northeast Normal University, Changchun, People's Republic of China; 2 Medical Humanities Sciences, China Medical University, Shenyang, People's Republic of China; 3 College of Education, Wenzhou University, Wenzhou, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Runkai Jiao, School of Psychology, Northeast Normal University, 5268 Renmin Street, Changchun, 130024, Jilin Province, People's Republic of China, Email Purpose: The initial phase can be difficult for teachers: beginning teachers are more likely to experience effort–reward imbalance (ERI) and its harmful effects. To reduce this risk, this study analyzed the factors that impact ERI among beginning teachers in China and investigated the coping strategies they use. Methods: The study used qualitative research methods to conduct semi-structured interviews with 20 beginning teachers. Each participant was interviewed for at least 40 minutes via an online platform. Results: The qualitative results showed that ERI among beginning teachers is influenced by the interaction of internal and external factors. The typical factors identified were organizational justice, leadership style, work motivation, and personality type. Beginning teachers in the Chinese context demonstrated a proactive attitude towards challenging situations and chose moderate approaches to cope with ERI. The effectiveness of these strategies varied due to individual differences and contextual factors. Conclusion: Overall, the findings emphasized the importance of addressing the challenges of beginning teachers to promote their well-being and improve the quality of education. Reducing the ERI of beginning teachers relies on a tripartite effort between society, schools and teachers themselves. Keywords: beginning teachers, coping strategies, effort–reward imbalance, external factors, internal factors For beginning teachers, who have recently transitioned from students to educators, it is crucial to be prepared in advance, both professionally and psychologically, to handle potential challenges. Studies from various nations and regions have confirmed the difficulties beginning teachers face, including emotional exhaustion, 1 prolonged exposure to stressful situations, 2 lack of opportunities, 3 and difficulties managing students. 4 Beginning teachers in China encounter these challenges as well. Moreover, the high social expectations placed on every teacher, influenced by Confucian culture, can add additional pressure. 5 Numerous young people are drawn to teaching because of its high social status and their own enthusiasm for education. However, for many beginning teachers, the gap between their expectations and the reality of the job can lead to an imbalance between their efforts and rewards. 6 Consequently, this study aims to examine the factors that contribute to effort–reward imbalance (ERI) among beginning teachers in China, as well as to identify coping strategies that can help prevent this imbalance and reduce work-related stress. The ERI model is a valuable predictor of stress at work. 7 It has three primary components: effort (time, energy, physical exertion, and responsibilities of the position), reward (money, respect, and career advancement), and over-commitment (emotional dedication to work). A lack of reciprocity between effort and reward (ie, high effort and low reward) at the workplace can result in unfavourable feelings and continuous neuroendocrine system changes, eventually influencing health. 8 Since the teaching profession requires a high level of intrinsic motivation, 6 over-commitment is commonly observed. This can exacerbate the impact of ERI on job-related stress. However, teachers' success is generally judged based on student achievements, which are not immediately visible because they rely heavily on students' motivation and ability to learn. 9 This means it is difficult for the leaders, colleagues, and parents who evaluate teachers to see their accomplishments directly. 10 Teachers struggle to be rewarded for their efforts, creating a chronic imbalance. 11,12 Due to the short time in the profession, beginning teachers have more difficulty gaining recognition for their work. Their enthusiasm can be easily affected by their poor teaching skills and lower learning motivation. 13 Thus, they are more likely to face ERI than experienced teachers. The identity change from pre-service to beginning teacher requires teachers to develop their motivation by navigating between co -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary