Babies in occiput posterior position are significantly more likely to require an emergency cesarean birth compared with babies in occiput transverse position in the second stage of labor: A prospective observational study
Nicola Tempest,Steven Lane,Dharani Hapangama,UK Audit Ressearch Trainee Collaborative in Obstetrics, Gynecology (UK-ARCOG),Wattar Bassel,Tamblyn Jennifer,Parry-Smith William,Prior Matthew,Chandrasekaran Dhivya,Bansali Shailly Sahu,Boregowda Geethanjali,Dave Fulva,Guiver Julie,Gupta Mohita,Iyasere Cecilia,Jones Kate,Karanam Vijaya,Player Jessica,Bhatt Daxina,Boyes Zoe,Carpenter Ciara,Clarke Helen,Corr Trent,Dauleh Sarah,Egan Jemma,George Smitha,Harris Phillipa,Kerr Robbie,Ramachandran Nira,Ramage Jennifer,Tildesley Rachel,Paterson Kirsty,Akhter Ferdousi,McDougall Anna,Ojukwu Obi,Tvarozkova Katarina,Ramshaw Nicola,Creed Michelle,Danby Kate,Fisher Amy,Grainger Rosie,Hardy Dorota,Lovell Rebecca,McCormick Aiste,Pearce Melissa,Stelling Heidi,Thompson Ruth,Williams Simon,Wonnacott Alison,Yorke Jemma,Kamran Atiyah,Fernandes Jandy,Zafrani Lamia,Conacher Angus,Tannous Dina,Tracey Susan,Manning Louisa,Bain Alex,Braschi Jessica,Dehnel Alexandra,Okano Sayaka,Rayner Eleanor,Day Fiona,Abdou Alaa,Channing Sarah,Hayward Samantha,Ingamells Sarah,O'Sullivan Marie,Jones Samantha,Day Tipswalo,Haque Noreen,Jilani Kiran,Jones Angharad,Pilkington Lisa,Roberts Ruth,Stone Cath,Thomas Caryl,Davey Mark,Berry Janet,Mukherjee Srabini,Nightingale Gemma,Perumalla Margaret,Johnston Catherine,Smyth Sarah,Smotra Grisham,Subba Kamana,Ghosh Mausumi,Gulati Nidhi,Merzougui Sarra,Miti Chimwemwe,Mohamed Mohammad,Nicholson Yulia,Raghavan Radhae,Seetharaman Priyadharshini,Smyth Camille,Stevenson Helen,Syeda Nasreen,Tan Alex,Veal Laura,Zahid Rabia,Madari Sheethal,McCormack Claire,Barlow Catriona,Beatty Laura,D'Sa Anusha,Hendry Fiona,Martin Iain,McAlpine-Scott Victoria,Short Daniel,Dalton John,Cartland Sarah,Doxford-Hook Elizabeth,Kakara Sudeepthi,Pettinger Tom,Scott Malcolm,Tibbott James
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/aogs.13765
Abstract:Introduction: Malposition complicates 2-13% of births at delivery, leading to increased obstetric interventions (cesarean section and instrumental delivery) and higher rates of adverse fetal and maternal outcomes. Limited data are available regarding the likely rates of obstetric intervention and subsequent neonatal and maternal outcomes of births with babies in persistent occiput posterior position vs those in persistent occiput transverse position. The UK Audit and Research trainee Collaborative in Obstetrics and Gynecology (UK-ARCOG) network set out to collect data prospectively at delivery on final mode of delivery and immediate outcomes. Material and methods: The UK-ARCOG network collected data on all births with malposition of the fetal head complicating the second stage of labor (n = 838) (occiput posterior/occiput transverse) requiring rotational vaginal operative birth or emergency cesarean to expedite delivery across 66 participating UK National Health Service maternity units over a 1-month period. The outcomes considered were the need for emergency cesarean section without a trial of instrumental delivery, success of the first method of delivery employed in achieving a vaginal delivery and neonatal/maternal outcomes. Results: Obstetricians regarded assistance with an operative vaginal delivery method to be unsafe in 15% of babies in occiput posterior position and 6.1% of babies in occiput transverse position, and they were delivered by primary emergency cesarean section. When vaginal delivery was deemed safe (defined as attempted assisted vaginal rotational delivery), the first instrument attempted was successful in 74.4% of occiput posterior babies and 79.3% of occiput transverse babies. Conclusions: Our data facilitates decision making by obstetricians to increase safety of assisted rotational operative delivery of a malpositioned baby at initial assessment and in counseling women. Until data from a well-designed randomized controlled trial of instrumental delivery vs emergency cesarean section are available, this manuscript provides contemporaneous national data from a high resource setting within a structured training program, to assist the selection of an appropriate instrument/method for the delivery of a malpositioned baby.