The Economic Potential of Agrivoltaic Systems in Apple Cultivation—A Hungarian Case Study

Aidana Chalgynbayeva,Péter Balogh,László Szőllősi,Zoltán Gabnai,Ferenc Apáti,Marianna Sipos,Attila Bai
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16062325
IF: 3.9
2024-03-12
Sustainability
Abstract:Agrivoltaic systems (AVS) allow the simultaneous use of land—as a limited resource—for crop production and electricity generation. This paper introduces the development prospects of AVS in Hungary with insights into international trends. The most important part is a complex economic analysis and a unit cost analysis of a 38 MWp capacity AVS, considering the most typical basic data in electricity and apple production. The applied risk analysis is based on a Monte Carlo simulation, the distribution function, and probabilities. To introduce the economic facet of the competitiveness of AVS, a comparative analysis was carried out between AVS, ground-mounted photovoltaic (GM-PV) systems, and conventional apple production systems (ConAPS). In the most probable scenario, the AVS was financially attractive (NPV = 70 million EUR under 30 years). Our correlation analysis shows that feed-in tariff (FIT) price and the role of financing are considered the dominant economic factors. A favorable FIT price enhances the profitability of AVS; however, it makes GM-PV systems more profitable compared to AVS, so it negatively affects the competitiveness of AVS systems. AVS operations result in a more balanced unit cost of apples and of electricity compared to the independent operation of GM-PV systems and of ConAPS; in addition, it allows for land saving and more intensive land use.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the economic potential of applying Agrivoltaic Systems (AVS) in apple cultivation, especially in the specific case study in Hungary. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Economic Feasibility Analysis**: Through detailed economic analysis, evaluate the economic benefits of the AVS system, including unit cost analysis and risk analysis. The paper uses methods such as Monte Carlo simulation, distribution functions and probability to assess risks. 2. **Comparative Analysis**: Compare the AVS system with Ground - Mounted Photovoltaic (GM - PV) and Conventional Apple Production Systems (ConAPS) to evaluate the competitiveness of the AVS system. 3. **Influencing Factor Analysis**: Explore the key factors that affect the economy of the AVS system, especially the role of Feed - in Tariff (FIT) prices and financing. The paper points out that higher FIT prices can enhance the profitability of the AVS system, but will also make the GM - PV system more competitive, thus having a negative impact on the competitiveness of the AVS system. 4. **Comprehensive Benefit Evaluation**: Evaluate the comprehensive benefits of the AVS system in terms of land use efficiency, energy production and agricultural output. The paper emphasizes that the AVS system can achieve a more balanced unit cost of apples and electricity, while saving land resources and increasing land use efficiency. Through these analyses, the paper aims to provide decision - support for investors, helping them understand the economic value and potential challenges of investing in the AVS system in apple cultivation.