Abstract:Problem definition: A significant percentage of online consumers place consecutive orders within a short duration. To reduce the total order arrangement cost, an online retailer may consolidate consecutive orders from the same consumer. We investigate how long the retailer should hold the consumer’s orders before sending them to a third-party logistics provider (3PL) for processing. In this order-holding problem, we optimize the holding time to balance the total order arrangement cost and the potential delay in delivery. Methodology/results: We model the order-holding problem as a Markov decision process. We show that the optimal order-holding decisions follow a threshold-type policy that is straightforward to implement: Hold any pending orders if the holding time is within a threshold or send them to the 3PL otherwise. Whenever the consumer places a new order, the holding time is reset, and the threshold is updated based on a cumulative set of the past consecutive orders in the consumer’s shopping journey. Using a consumer’s sequential decision model, we personalize the threshold by finding its closed-form expression in the consumer’s order features. We determine the model’s coefficients and evaluate the threshold-type policy using the data of the 2020 MSOM Data Driven Research Challenge. Extensive numerical experiments suggest that the personalized threshold-type policy outperforms two commonly used benchmarks by having fewer order arrangements or shorter holding times. Furthermore, personalizing the order-holding decisions is significantly more valuable for “enterprise” customers. Managerial implications: Our research suggests a higher threshold for consumers who are more likely to place consecutive orders within a short duration. The consumers’ demographic information has a significant effect on the threshold. Specifically, the threshold is higher for “plus” consumers, female consumers, and consumers in the age group of 16–25 years. The threshold for tier 1 cities is lower than that for tier 2 to tier 4 cities but higher than that for tier 5 cities. History: This paper has been accepted for the Manufacturing & Service Operations Management Data Driven Challenge. Funding: This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China [Grants 71931009, 72201237, and 72231009], the Research Grants Council of Hong Kong [Grants 15501920 and 15501221], the Singapore Ministry of Education Academic Research Fund [Tier 1, Grant RG17/21; Tier 2, Grant MOE2019-T2-1-045], the Association of South-East Asian Nations Business Research Initiative Grant [Grant G17C20421], and the Neptune Orient Lines [Fellowship NOL21RP04]. Supplemental Material: The online appendices are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/msom.2023.1201 .

Ordering Problem with Known Capacity in Smart Factory.

Analysis of batch ordering inventory models with setup cost and capacity constraint

The capacity matching problem of the third-party shared manufacturing platform with capacity time windows and order splitting

Outsourcing Decision and Order Policy with Forecast Updating under Capacity Reservation Contract

Optimal Control of A Capacitated Inventory System with Multiple Demand Classes

A dynamic model and an algorithm for short-term supply chain scheduling in the smart factory industry 4.0

Integrated production planning and warehouse storage assignment problem: An IoT assisted case

The Internet of Things enabled manufacturing enterprise information system design and shop floor dynamic scheduling optimisation

Integrated scheduling of production and material delivery for the intelligent manufacturing system

Production Line Capacity Planning Concerning Uncertain Demands for a Class of Manufacturing Systems with Multiple Products

The Study of Supply Problem with Finite Resource Capacity

Spatial and temporal optimization for smart warehouses with fast turnover

Distributionally robust optimization for a capacity-sharing supply chain network design problem

Spatial–temporal out-of-order execution for advanced planning and scheduling in cyber-physical factories

On the stochastic inventory problem under order capacity constraints

An order insertion scheduling model of logistics service supply chain considering capacity and time factors.

Coordination of a Supply Chain with One-Manufacturer and Two-Retailers under Demand Promotion and Disruption Management Decisions

Managing the Personalized Order-Holding Problem in Online Retailing

Online Food Delivery to Minimize Maximum Flow Time

Study on Multi-Objective Optimization of Logistics Distribution Paths in Smart Manufacturing Workshops Based on Time Tolerance and Low Carbon Emissions

Ordering Decisions with an Unreliable Supplier under the Carbon Cap-and-Trade System