Genomic Diagnosis of Rare Pediatric Disease in the United Kingdom and Ireland
Caroline F Wright,Patrick Campbell,Ruth Y Eberhardt,Stuart Aitken,Daniel Perrett,Simon Brent,Petr Danecek,Eugene J Gardner,V Kartik Chundru,Sarah J Lindsay,Katrina Andrews,Juliet Hampstead,Joanna Kaplanis,Kaitlin E Samocha,Anna Middleton,Julia Foreman,Rachel J Hobson,Michael J Parker,Hilary C Martin,David R FitzPatrick,Matthew E Hurles,Helen V Firth,DDD Study,Nadia Akawi,Saeed Al-Turki,Kirsty Ambridge,Jana Awada,Daniel Barrett,Jeffrey Barrett,Tanya Bayzetinova,A Paul Bevan,Eugene Bragin,Nigel Carter,Eleni Chatzimichali,Stephen Clayton,Panayiotis Constantinou,Manuel Corpas,Fiona Cunningham,Erwan Delage,Ruth Eberhardt,Helen Firth,Tomas Fitzgerald,David FitzPatrick,Giuseppe Gallone,Eugene Gardner,Sebastian Gerety,Susan Gribble,Rachel Hobson,Sarah Hunt,Matthew Hurles,Benjamin Hutton,Philip Jones,Wendy Jones,Rosemary Kelsell,Daniel King,Netra Krishnappa,Sarah Lindsay,Jenny Lord,Thomas Marchant,Hilary Martin,Jeremy McRae,Ray Miller,Kate Morley,Matthew Neville,Mari Niemi,Michael Parker,Elena Prigmore,Elizabeth Radford,Diana Rajan,Kaitlin Samocha,Hassan Shakeel,Patrick Short,Alejandro Sifrim,G Jawahar Swaminathan,Anja Thormann,Adrian Tivey,Margriete van Kogelenberg,Parthiban Vijayarangakannan,Nicola Whiffin,Emilie Wigdor,Caroline Wright,Moira Blyth,John Dean,Zosia Miedzybrodzka,Lisa Kier Robertson,Alison Ross,Tabib Dabir,Deirdre Donnelly,Vivienne McConnell,Alex McGee,Shane McKee,Patrick Morrison,Gillian Rea,Fiona Stewart,Helen Kate Brittain,Louise Brueton,Trevor Cole,Nicola Cooper,Helen Cox,Farah Fanani,Alison Foster,Rebecca Igbokwe,Lily Islam,Joanna Jarvis,Esther Kinning,Derek Lim,Jenny Morton,Swati Naik,Mary O'Driscoll,Kai-Ren Ong,Deborah Osio,Corrina Powell,Nicola Ragge,Suresh Somarathi,Hannah Titheradge,Julie Vogt,Denise Williams,Ana Beleza,Lucy Bownass,Simon Bodek,Alan Donaldson,Karen Low,Ruth Newbury-Ecob,Andrew Norman,Ingrid Scurr,Sarah Smithson,Madeleine Tooley,Ruth Armstrong,Kate Baker,Jenny Carmichael,Simon Holden,Sarju Mehta,Soo-Mi Park,Joan Paterson,Lucy Raymond,Evan Reid,Richard Sandford,Marc Tischkowitz,Geoff Woods,Ayesha Ahmed,Angus Clarke,Hector Conti,Andrew Fry,Jennifer Gardner,Vani Jain,Arveen Kamath,Oliver Murch,Caroline Pottinger,Annie Procter,Julian Sampson,Francis Sansbury,Ian Tully,Vinod Varghese,Lisa Bradley,Andrew Green,Sally Ann Lynch,Jonathan Berg,David Goudie,Catherine McWilliam,Andrew Jackson,Wayne Lam,Anne Lampe,Michael Yates,Emma Baple,Carole Brewer,Bruce Castle,Ruth Cleaver,Emma Kivuva,Henrietta Lefroy,Julia Rankin,Charles Shaw-Smith,Peter Turnpenny,Claire Turner,Anna Znaczko,Rosemarie Davidson,Carol Gardiner,Mark Hamilton,Shelagh Joss,Cheryl Longman,Ruth McGowan,Victoria Murday,Daniela Pilz,Edward Tobias,John Tolmie,Margo Whiteford,Christopher Bennett,Jennifer Campbell,Angus Dobbie,Verity Harthill,Emma Hobson,Rosalyn Jewell,Alison Kraus,Katrina Prescott,Eamonn Sheridan,Jenny Thomson,Pradeep Vasudevan,Jennifer Hague,Natalie Canham,Ian Ellis,Lynn Greenhalgh,Jenny Higgs,Emma McCann,Victoria Mckay,Astrid Astrid,Tazeen Ashraf,Angela Barnicoat,Maria Bitner-Glindicz,Emma Clement,Francesca Faravelli,Jane Hurst,Eleanor Hay,V K Ajith Kumar,Melissa Lees,Alison Male,Elisabeth Rosser,Mina Ryten,Richard Scott,Shereen Tadros,Emma Wakeling,Louise Wilson,Fiona Connell,Frances Flinter,Muriel Holder,Melita Irving,Louise Izatt,Dragana Josifova,Shehla Mohammed,Leema Robert,Deborah Ruddy,Birgitta Bernhard,Angela Brady,Virginia Clowes,Jan Cobben,Alice Gardham,Neeti Ghali,Susan Holder,Rita Ibitoye,Jessica Anne Radley,Frances Elmslie,Tessa Homfray,Nayana Lahiri,Sahar Mansour,Meriel McEntagart,Anand Saggar,Kate Tatton-Brown,Siddharth Banka,Catherine Breen,Tracy Briggs,Emma Burkitt-Wright,Kate Chandler,Jill Clayton-Smith,Charu Deshpande,Dian Donnai,Sofia Douzgou,Elizabeth Jones,Bronwyn Kerr,Kay Metcalfe,Audrey Smith,Helen Stuart,Marta Bertoli,John Burn,Richard Fisher,Alex Henderson,Tara Montgomery,Ruth Richardson,Miranda Splitt,Volker Straub,Michael Wright,Laura Yates,Abhijit Dixit,Jacqueline Eason,Rachel Harrison,Gabriella Jones,Nora Shannon,Ajoy Sarkar,Claire Searle,Mohnish Suri,Edward Blair,Deirdre Cilliers,Andrew Douglas,Richard Gibbons,Usha Kini,Victoria Nesbit,Andrea Nemeth,Joanna Poulton,Susan Price,Debbie Shears,Helen Stewart,Andrew Wilkie,Meena Balasubramanian,Diana Johnson,Oliver Quarrell,Alison Stewart,Diana Baralle,Nicola Foulds,Victoria Harrison,David Hunt,Daniela Iancu,Mira Kharbanda,Katherine Lachlan,Catherine Mercer,Lucy Side,Karen Temple,Diana Wellesley
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa2209046
2023-04-27
Abstract:Background: Pediatric disorders include a range of highly penetrant, genetically heterogeneous conditions amenable to genomewide diagnostic approaches. Finding a molecular diagnosis is challenging but can have profound lifelong benefits. Methods: We conducted a large-scale sequencing study involving more than 13,500 families with probands with severe, probably monogenic, difficult-to-diagnose developmental disorders from 24 regional genetics services in the United Kingdom and Ireland. Standardized phenotypic data were collected, and exome sequencing and microarray analyses were performed to investigate novel genetic causes. We developed an iterative variant analysis pipeline and reported candidate variants to clinical teams for validation and diagnostic interpretation to inform communication with families. Multiple regression analyses were performed to evaluate factors affecting the probability of diagnosis. Results: A total of 13,449 probands were included in the analyses. On average, we reported 1.0 candidate variant per parent-offspring trio and 2.5 variants per singleton proband. Using clinical and computational approaches to variant classification, we made a diagnosis in approximately 41% of probands (5502 of 13,449). Of 3599 probands in trios who received a diagnosis by clinical assertion, approximately 76% had a pathogenic de novo variant. Another 22% of probands (2997 of 13,449) had variants of uncertain significance in genes that were strongly linked to monogenic developmental disorders. Recruitment in a parent-offspring trio had the largest effect on the probability of diagnosis (odds ratio, 4.70; 95% confidence interval [CI], 4.16 to 5.31). Probands were less likely to receive a diagnosis if they were born extremely prematurely (i.e., 22 to 27 weeks' gestation; odds ratio, 0.39; 95% CI, 0.22 to 0.68), had in utero exposure to antiepileptic medications (odds ratio, 0.44; 95% CI, 0.29 to 0.67), had mothers with diabetes (odds ratio, 0.52; 95% CI, 0.41 to 0.67), or were of African ancestry (odds ratio, 0.51; 95% CI, 0.31 to 0.78). Conclusions: Among probands with severe, probably monogenic, difficult-to-diagnose developmental disorders, multimodal analysis of genomewide data had good diagnostic power, even after previous attempts at diagnosis. (Funded by the Health Innovation Challenge Fund and Wellcome Sanger Institute.).