U-Shaped Conformity in Online Social Networks.

Monic Sun,Xiaoquan (Michael) Zhang,Feng Zhu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1287/mksc.2018.1133

2018-01-01

Abstract:Conformity toward the majority choice among a user’s friends on a social-networking site first decreases and then increases with the adoption rate of that choice.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Nonconformity in Online Social Networks

Monic Sun,Xiaoquan Zhang,Feng Zhu

2016-01-01

Abstract:We study how users trade off their needs to belong and to be different in online social networks through a field experiment that minimizes informational social influence, homophily, and identity signaling to out-group members. On a large social-networking site we find that the likelihood of adoption may in fact decrease when the option becomes more popular among a participant’s friends – a finding that contrasts sharply with previous studies of normative social influences in offline settings. Nudging users to conform by reminding them of the saliency of their choices among their friends could further decrease their likelihood to conform unless the adoption rate exceeds a certain threshold. On average, male, older, and less established, newly-registered members on the networking site are more likely to conform to their friends’ choices. We replicate the experiment in a setting that accommodates observational learning and find that the user characteristics that lead to increased nonconformity remain significant. Overall, the results suggest that there may exist important boundary conditions for behavioral convergence in online social networks and marketers may benefit from customizing their social advertising strategies based on the relative strength of normative social influence and user characteristics.
The Lonely Consumer: Loner or Conformer?

Jing Wang,Rui (Juliet) Zhu,Baba Shiv

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/661552

2012-01-01

Abstract:Despite the popularity of social networks and technologies that intend to enhance social interaction, more Americans feel lonely now than before. This research examines how loneliness affects consumers' responses to consensus-related social cues in marketing contexts. Results from three studies show that lonely consumers prefer minority-endorsed products, whereas nonlonely consumers prefer majority-endorsed products. However, this pattern occurs only when consumers' product preferences are kept private. When product preferences are subject to public scrutiny, lonely consumers shift their preferences to majority-endorsed products. Results also reveal the underlying mechanisms. Minority-endorsed products fit better with the feelings of loneliness, and this fit mediates the effect of loneliness and endorsement type (i.e., majority vs. minority endorsement) on product evaluations in private consumption contexts. Yet, when their preferences are subject to public scrutiny, lonely consumers are concerned about being negatively evaluated by others, and this concern causes them to conform to the majority.
Confluence: conformity influence in large social networks.

Jie Tang,Sen Wu,Jimeng Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/2487575.2487691

2013-01-01

Abstract:ABSTRACTConformity is a type of social influence involving a change in opinion or behavior in order to fit in with a group. Employing several social networks as the source for our experimental data, we study how the effect of conformity plays a role in changing users' online behavior. We formally define several major types of conformity in individual, peer, and group levels. We propose Confluence model to formalize the effects of social conformity into a probabilistic model. Confluence can distinguish and quantify the effects of the different types of conformities. To scale up to large social networks, we propose a distributed learning method that can construct the Confluence model efficiently with near-linear speedup. Our experimental results on four different types of large social networks, i.e., Flickr, Gowalla, Weibo and Co-Author, verify the existence of the conformity phenomena. Leveraging the conformity information, Confluence can accurately predict actions of users. Our experiments show that Confluence significantly improves the prediction accuracy by up to 5-10% compared with several alternative methods.
Confluence: Conformity Influence In Networks

Jie Tang,Sen Wu,Jimeng Sun

2013-01-01

Abstract:conformity is a type of social influence involving a change in opinion or behavior in. order to fit in with a group. Employing several social networks as the source for our experimental data, we study how the effect of conformity plays a role in changing users' online behavior We formally define several major types of conformity in individual. peer, and group levels. We propose Confluence model to formalize the effects of social conformity into a probabilistic model, Confluence can distinguish and quantify the effects of the different types of conformities. To scale up to large social net works, we propose a distributed learning method that can construct the Confluence model efficiently with near-linear speedup. Our experimental results on four different types of large social networks, i,e,. Flickr, Gowalla, Weibo and Co-Author, verify the existence of the conformity phenomena. Leveraging the conformity information. Confluence can accurately predict actions of users. Om- experiments show that Confluence significantly improves the prediction accuracy by up to 5-111)5k compared with several alternative methods.
To Belong or to Be Different? Evidence from a Large-Scale Field Experiment in China

monic sun,xiaoquan zhang,feng zhu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2164387

2012-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We examined whether people conform to or diverge from the most popular choice among their friends by conducting a large-scale field experiment on a leading social-networking site in China. Our setting allowed us to minimize confounding effects such as pre-existing taste similarities between a subject and her friends, the need to create a social identity, and the possibility of learning by observing friends’ choices. Surprisingly, we found that subjects were more likely to diverge from the popular choice among their friends as the popularity of that choice increased. The effect was more pronounced when they were reminded that their choices were visible to their friends. These results suggest that even members of a collectivist culture have a dominating need to be different.
Role-Aware Conformity Modeling and Analysis in Social Networks.

Jing Zhang,Jie Tang,Honglei Zhuang,Cane Wing-Ki Leung,Juanzi Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1609/aaai.v28i1.8835

2014-01-01

Abstract:Conformity influence is the inclination of a person to be influenced by others. In this paper, we study how the conformity tendency of a person changes with her role, as defined by her structural properties in a social network. We first formalize conformity influence using a utility function based on the conformity theory from social psychology, and then propose a probabilistic graphical model, referred to as Role-Conformity Model (RCM), for modeling the role-aware conformity influence between users by incorporating the utility function. We apply the proposed RCM to several academic research networks, and discover that people with higher degree and lower clustering coefficient are more likely to conform to others. We also evaluate RCM through the task of word usage prediction in academic publications, and show significant improvements over baseline models.
Conformity-aware adoption maximization in competitive social networks

Yonggang Liu,Yikun Hu,Siyang Yu,Xu Zhou,Keqin Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neucom.2023.127224

IF: 6

2024-01-05

Neurocomputing

Abstract:Influence maximization (IM) problem is an extensively studied problem in social networks. It aims to find a small set of users in the social network to initiate the diffusion process and maximize the expected influence spread. Existing works on conformity-aware IM focus on the interaction between influence and conformity in a single-influence setting and ignore the role of conformity in a competitive and multiple-influence setting. This paper proposes a conformity-aware independent cascade (C-IC) model that considers the competition among multiple influences as well as the role of conformity in a user's decision-making. It is proved that the adoption of an influence under the C-IC model is monotone and submodular. Meanwhile, we formulate two adoption maximization (AM) problems, O-AM and S-AM, which are both NP-hard. Because estimating the adoption through diffusion simulations is very time-consuming, we propose a reverse adoption estimation (RAE) method based on a reverse multiple influence sampling (RMIS) technology for the C-IC model and integrate it into the D-SSA-fix (Nguyenet al., 2018) framework, DSSA for short, to compute a solution with approximation guarantee. To further boost the performance, we present a fast one-hop adoption estimation (OAE) method and develop a heuristic algorithm based on OAE, called GOAE. Extensive experiments on eight real-world social networks show that C-IC model is superior to a non-conformity diffusion model and RAE+DSSA and GOAE are efficient and effective. In most case, GOAE finds comparable solutions to RAE+DSSA and CELF with less time and memory overhead. GOAE is five to six orders of magnitude faster than CELF and RAE+DSSA is up to three orders of magnitude faster than CELF on NetHEPT. GOAE runs up to four to five orders of magnitude faster than RAE+DSSA with at most two orders of magnitude less memory usage. GOAE is more scalable than RAE+DSSA in terms of the number of seeds and the size of the social network.

computer science, artificial intelligence
An Empirical Study on Factors Affecting the Conformity Behavior of Online Shoppers

Liu Jiang,Zhu Qinghua,Wu Kewen,Zhao Yuxiang

2012-01-01

Abstract:Based on the introduction of concept and characteristics of conformity behavior,as well as the literature review on some relevant theories and publications of social psychology field,the paper proposes several potential factors that may affect the conformity behavior of online shoppers,and builds a conceptual model with some relevant hypotheses put forward.The empirical data are collected by questionnaire survey.Specifically,it employs SPSS 17.0 to make descriptive statistical analysis on the sample data,and structural equation model is constructed by applying Lisrel 8.70 to verify the hypotheses and estimate the variables' impact on the conformity behavior of online shoppers.The finding shows that the conformity behavior of online shoppers is affected by the attitude and habit of online shoppers.Furthermore,the paper may yield some implications for the developers,managers,and policy-makers of e-commerce.
Social Learning in Networks of Friends Versus Strangers

Jurui Zhang,Yong Liu,Yubo Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1287/mksc.2015.0902

2014-01-01

Abstract:Networks and the embedded relationships are critical determinants of how people communicate and form beliefs. The explosion of social media has significantly increased the scope and impact of social learning among consumers. This paper studies observational learning in networks of friends versus strangers. A consumer decides whether to adopt a product after receiving a private signal about product quality and observing the actions of others. The preference for the product has greater heterogeneity in the stranger-network than in the friend-network. We show that when the network is small, observing friends' actions helps the consumer make more accurate inferences about quality. As the network grows, however, the stranger-network becomes more effective. Underlying these results are two competing effects of network heterogeneity on social learning. These are the individual preference effect, which allows one to make a better quality judgment when the preference element of past actions is more certain, and the social conforming effect, wherein private signals are underused in quality judgment as people follow others' actions. We find cascading is more likely to occur in the friend-network than in the stranger-network. For a high-quality firm, the stranger-network generates greater sales than the friend-network when the network size is sufficiently large or the private signal is sufficiently accurate. We also examine the existence of experts and firms using advertising to influence consumers. Finally, we show how networks that are highly homogeneous or heterogeneous could impede observational learning.
Emergence of Scale-Free Leadership Structure in Social Recommender Systems

Tao Zhou,Matus Medo,Giulio Cimini,Zi-Ke Zhang,Yi-Cheng Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0020648

IF: 3.7

2011-01-01

PLoS ONE

Abstract:The study of the organization of social networks is important for the understanding of opinion formation, rumor spreading, and the emergence of trends and fashion. This paper reports empirical analysis of networks extracted from four leading sites with social functionality (Delicious, Flickr, Twitter and YouTube) and shows that they all display a scale-free leadership structure. To reproduce this feature, we propose an adaptive network model driven by social recommending. Artificial agent-based simulations of this model highlight a “good get richer” mechanism where users with broad interests and good judgments are likely to become popular leaders for the others. Simulations also indicate that the studied social recommendation mechanism can gradually improve the user experience by adapting to tastes of its users. Finally we outline implications for real online resource-sharing systems.
Product Adoption in Online Social Network.

Yunjie (Calvin) Xu,Cheng Zhang,Ling Xue,Lay Lan Yeo

2008-01-01

Abstract:In product-oriented online social networks, members post product reviews as well as maintaining a list of friends. How to measure the influence a member receives from her friends? This study compares four models to measure the influence based on different theories which make various assumptions of member behavior in a social network. An empirical study was conducted based on 2324 social network members of a cosmetic website. We found the influence from a member's ego- centric network is best measured by a model that incorporates both the frequency and valence of interactions among members.
Online Communities and Social Network Structure

Yanhao Wei,Wensi Zhang,Sha Yang,Xi Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3420525

2019-01-01

Abstract:This paper aims to understand the effects of online communities on the network structure and their marketing implications. To account for the fact that communities are not formed exogenously, we model and estimate how they co-evolve with the friendship network. We control for unobserved heterogeneity and homophily by modeling individuals’ latent positions and similarities. Using data from a worldwide Massively Multiplayer Online (MMO) Game, we find that individuals’ friendship formation decision and community membership decision reinforce each other. Moreover, model simulation reveals that, under some circumstances, online communities may promote not only within-community ties but also cross-community ties. Here, one important moderating factor is the community stickiness, which is captured by the positive effects of an individual’s number of friends in a community on her probability of staying in that community (instead of switching to a different community). As shown by our simulated diffusion exercises, only a moderately sticky community system promotes cross-community ties and consequently improves information reach. This insight helps social platforms manage online communities more effectively to improve the marketing value of social networks.
A Review of Online Social Conformity: Outcomes and Determinants

Senuri Wijenayake Jorge Goncalves a RMIT University,Melbourne,Australiab The University of Melbourne,Melbourne,AustraliaSenuri Wijenayake received a PhD in Computer Science Engineering from the University of Melbourne in 2022. She is currently a Lecturer in the School of Computing Technologies at RMIT University. Her research in Human-Computer Interaction explores how design influences user behaviour on online platforms,affecting positive and negative interactions.Jorge Goncalves received a PhD degree in computer science and engineering from the University of Oulu,in 2015. He is currently an Associate Professor with the School of Computing and Information Systems,University of Melbourne. His research interests include ubiquitous computing,human-computer interaction,crowdsourcing,human-centred AI,and social computing.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10447318.2024.2424385

IF: 4.92

2024-11-09

International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction

Abstract:Social conformity occurs when individuals forego their personal judgements to agree with opposing judgements of a group majority. While conformity was initially observed and investigated in physical groups, recently there has been an increasing interest to understand dynamics of this phenomenon in online group settings. This survey summarises 36 years of social conformity literature (1988–2023) and reviews its occurrences, positive and negative outcomes, and contextual and personal determinants in online groups. By doing so, we identify gaps in the conformity literature that require further investigation, discuss common challenges and inform the design of future online conformity studies.

computer science, cybernetics,ergonomics
Conformity out of Diversity: Dynamics of Information Needs and Social Influence of Tags in Exploratory Information Search.

Ruogu Kang,Thomas Kannampallil,Jibo He,Wai-Tat Fu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-02812-0_19

2009-01-01

Abstract:We studied the dynamic effects of information needs and social influence of tags in an exploratory search task. Although initially differences in information needs led to diversity in tag choices, this diversity disappeared as participants collaboratively tagged the same set of resources. Our findings are in general consistent with the notion that people conform to the collective interpretation of contents in an information system. In addition, our results showed that conformity does not only arise out of imitation of behavior, but also from the same underlying semantic interpretation or knowledge structures of users as they engage in informal collaboration through the social tagging system. Implications for design of social information system are discussed.
Social selection and peer influence in an online social network

Kevin Lewis,Marco Gonzalez,Jason Kaufman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1109739109

2012-01-03

Abstract:Disentangling the effects of selection and influence is one of social science's greatest unsolved puzzles: Do people befriend others who are similar to them, or do they become more similar to their friends over time? Recent advances in stochastic actor-based modeling, combined with self-reported data on a popular online social network site, allow us to address this question with a greater degree of precision than has heretofore been possible. Using data on the Facebook activity of a cohort of college students over 4 years, we find that students who share certain tastes in music and in movies, but not in books, are significantly likely to befriend one another. Meanwhile, we find little evidence for the diffusion of tastes among Facebook friends-except for tastes in classical/jazz music. These findings shed light on the mechanisms responsible for observed network homogeneity; provide a statistically rigorous assessment of the coevolution of cultural tastes and social relationships; and suggest important qualifications to our understanding of both homophily and contagion as generic social processes.
Controlling Complex Networks with Conformity Behavior

Xu-Wen Wang,Sen Nie,Wen-Xu Wang,Bing-Hong Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1209/0295-5075/111/68004

2015-01-01

Abstract:Controlling complex networks accompanied by common conformity behavior is a fundamental problem in social and physical science. Conformity behavior that individuals tend to follow the majority in their neighborhood is common in human society and animal communities. Despite recent progress in understanding controllability of complex networks, the existent controllability theories cannot be directly applied to networks associated with conformity. Here we propose a simple model to incorporate conformity-based decision making into the evolution of a network system, which allows us to employ the exact controllability theory to explore the controllability of such systems. We offer rigorous theoretical results of controllability for representative regular networks. We also explore real networks in different fields and some typical model networks, finding some interesting results that are different from the predictions of structural and exact controllability theory in the absence of conformity. We finally present an example of steering a real social network to some target states to further validate our controllability theory and tools. Our work offers a more realistic understanding of network controllability with conformity behavior and can have potential applications in networked evolutionary games, opinion dynamics and many other complex networked systems.
Product adoption in online social network | L'adoption de produit dans les réseaux sociaux en ligne

Yunjie Xu,Cheng Zhang,Ling Xue,Lay lan Yeo

2008-01-01

Abstract:In product-oriented online social networks, members post product reviews as well as maintaining a list of friends. How to measure the influence a member receives from her friends? This study compares four models to measure the influence based on different theories which make various assumptions of member behavior in a social network. An empirical study was conducted based on 2324 social network members of a cosmetic website. We found the influence from a member's egocentric network is best measured by a model that incorporates both the frequency and valence of interactions among members.
The Majority Illusion in Social Networks

Kristina Lerman,Xiaoran Yan,Xin-Zeng Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0147617

2015-06-10

Abstract:Social behaviors are often contagious, spreading through a population as individuals imitate the decisions and choices of others. A variety of global phenomena, from innovation adoption to the emergence of social norms and political movements, arise as a result of people following a simple local rule, such as copy what others are doing. However, individuals often lack global knowledge of the behaviors of others and must estimate them from the observations of their friends' behaviors. In some cases, the structure of the underlying social network can dramatically skew an individual's local observations, making a behavior appear far more common locally than it is globally. We trace the origins of this phenomenon, which we call "the majority illusion," to the friendship paradox in social networks. As a result of this paradox, a behavior that is globally rare may be systematically overrepresented in the local neighborhoods of many people, i.e., among their friends. Thus, the "majority illusion" may facilitate the spread of social contagions in networks and also explain why systematic biases in social perceptions, for example, of risky behavior, arise. Using synthetic and real-world networks, we explore how the "majority illusion" depends on network structure and develop a statistical model to calculate its magnitude in a network.

Social and Information Networks,Computers and Society,Physics and Society
To Switch or Not To Switch: Understanding Social Influence in Recommender Systems

Haiyi Zhu,Bernardo A. Huberman,Yarun Luon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1108.5147

2011-08-29

Abstract:We designed and ran an experiment to test how often people's choices are reversed by others' recommendations when facing different levels of confirmation and conformity pressures. In our experiment participants were first asked to provide their preferences between pairs of items. They were then asked to make second choices about the same pairs with knowledge of others' preferences. Our results show that others people's opinions significantly sway people's own choices. The influence is stronger when people are required to make their second decision sometime later (22.4%) than immediately (14.1%). Moreover, people are most likely to reverse their choices when facing a moderate number of opposing opinions. Finally, the time people spend making the first decision significantly predicts whether they will reverse their decisions later on, while demographics such as age and gender do not. These results have implications for consumer behavior research as well as online marketing strategies.

Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction,Social and Information Networks,Physics and Society
ACCF: Learning Attentional Conformity for Collaborative Filtering

Bin Liang,Chaofeng Sha,Dong Wu,Bo Xu,Yanghua Xiao,Wei Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/access.2019.2921853

IF: 3.9

2019-01-01

IEEE Access

Abstract:In recent years, Collaborative Filtering (CF) methods have yielded immense success on recommender systems. They mainly use the similarity between users and items, or the interactions between users and items to predict the unknown ratings. However, the social conformity phenomenon received little notice, which means: 1) individuals in a social network can have multiple characteristics and hence tend to belong to multiple overlapping groups or communities and 2) when confronted with conformity pressure, people often adjust their responses to conform to others' opinions to obtain social approval and belonging in the community. In this paper, we propose a new collaborative filtering-based recommendation framework, called ACCF, which explicitly exploits social conformity of users. We incorporate such social conformity phenomenon into the latent factor model, using a weighted average of community preference profiles as the adjusting factor, and learn the weight of each community's influence through an attention network. Compared with the seven state-of-the-art methods on three real-world datasets, our method achieves the best performance.

U-Shaped Conformity in Online Social Networks.

Nonconformity in Online Social Networks

The Lonely Consumer: Loner or Conformer?

Confluence: conformity influence in large social networks.

Confluence: Conformity Influence In Networks

To Belong or to Be Different? Evidence from a Large-Scale Field Experiment in China

Role-Aware Conformity Modeling and Analysis in Social Networks.

Conformity-aware adoption maximization in competitive social networks

An Empirical Study on Factors Affecting the Conformity Behavior of Online Shoppers

Social Learning in Networks of Friends Versus Strangers

Emergence of Scale-Free Leadership Structure in Social Recommender Systems

Product Adoption in Online Social Network.

Online Communities and Social Network Structure

A Review of Online Social Conformity: Outcomes and Determinants

Conformity out of Diversity: Dynamics of Information Needs and Social Influence of Tags in Exploratory Information Search.

Social selection and peer influence in an online social network

Controlling Complex Networks with Conformity Behavior

Product adoption in online social network | L'adoption de produit dans les réseaux sociaux en ligne

The Majority Illusion in Social Networks

To Switch or Not To Switch: Understanding Social Influence in Recommender Systems

ACCF: Learning Attentional Conformity for Collaborative Filtering