Abstract:Although items exhibiting topology are ubiquitous in everyday life, the realization of topology at the nanoscale level relies on innovative synthetic strategies. A molecular weaving strategy, recently reported in Nature Chemistry and Nature by Leigh and co-workers, has outlined the precise synthesis of a molecular 74 knot and a two-dimensional molecular fabric. These breakthroughs hard on the heels of each other open up a new route for incorporating predictable, well-defined topologies into molecular architectures. They will fuel the exploitation of advanced materials with topology-related properties. Although items exhibiting topology are ubiquitous in everyday life, the realization of topology at the nanoscale level relies on innovative synthetic strategies. A molecular weaving strategy, recently reported in Nature Chemistry and Nature by Leigh and co-workers, has outlined the precise synthesis of a molecular 74 knot and a two-dimensional molecular fabric. These breakthroughs hard on the heels of each other open up a new route for incorporating predictable, well-defined topologies into molecular architectures. They will fuel the exploitation of advanced materials with topology-related properties. Weaving, a time-honored skill born out of the united wisdom of humanity, has impacted profoundly many civilizations and supported our everyday lives from time immemorial. By guiding one-dimensional (1D) directional strands—such as fibers and ropes—over and under each other to form two-dimensional (2D) interlaced grids, a large variety of woven products have been created. Examples run the gamut from textiles, baskets, and fishing nets to traditional Chinese knots and Celtic laces. During the weaving process, interwoven topologies are introduced into the materials, giving rise not only to aesthetically pleasing fabrics, but also to excellent macroscopic properties in terms of strength, resilience, and porosity. The incorporation of topologies into nanoscale systems holds promise for endowing the resulting molecular materials with (1) properties analogous to those that have already been discovered in the making of textiles and (2) unprecedented features beyond what the macroscopic weaving can bring about. Stimulated by this prospect, chemists and materials scientists are searching for efficient methods to weave linear molecules with zig-zag conformations. Although the interpenetration1Batten S.R. Robson R. Interpenetrating nets: Ordered, periodic entanglement.Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 1998; 37: 1460-1494Crossref PubMed Scopus (4069) Google Scholar of flexible molecular networks has been discovered serendipitously in a variety of crystal structures—e.g., inorganic salts, metal coordination networks, and porous polymers—the rational design and synthesis of interwoven structures have not been feasible until recently, and coincidentally with when molecular nanotopology2Stoddart J.F. Dawning of the age of molecular nanotopology.Nano Lett. 2020; 20: 5597-5600Crossref PubMed Scopus (24) Google Scholar,3Guo Q.-H. Jiao Y. Feng Y. Stoddart J.F. The rise and promise of molecular nanotopology.CCS Chem. 2021; 3: 1542-1572Crossref Scopus (22) Google Scholar started to be recognized as a discipline in its own right. Thanks to the advent of the mechanical bond in chemistry, the emergence of mechanically interlocked molecules,4Stoddart J.F. Mechanically interlocked molecules (MIMs)—Molecular shuttles, switches, and machines (Nobel lecture).Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2017; 56: 11094-11125Crossref PubMed Scopus (477) Google Scholar and a growing awareness of chemical topology,5Forgan R.S. Sauvage J.-P. Stoddart J.F. Chemical topology: Complex molecular knots, links, and entanglements.Chem. Rev. 2011; 111: 5434-5464Crossref PubMed Scopus (596) Google Scholar the past decade has witnessed2Stoddart J.F. Dawning of the age of molecular nanotopology.Nano Lett. 2020; 20: 5597-5600Crossref PubMed Scopus (24) Google Scholar,3Guo Q.-H. Jiao Y. Feng Y. Stoddart J.F. The rise and promise of molecular nanotopology.CCS Chem. 2021; 3: 1542-1572Crossref Scopus (22) Google Scholar the rise and promise of molecular nanotopology. One of the increasingly vibrant research activities in this field lies in the synthesis of interwoven extended networks. For example, Yaghi et al.6Liu Y. Ma Y. Zhao Y. Sun X. Gándara F. Furukawa H. Liu Z. Zhu H. Zhu C. Suenaga K. et al.Weaving of organic threads into a crystalline covalent organic framework.Science. 2016; 351: 365-369Crossref PubMed Scopus (294) Google Scholar reported the construction of an interwoven covalent organic framework by combining Sauvage's seminal work7Dietrich-Buchecker C.O. Sauvage J.P. Kintzinger J.P. Une nouvelle famille de molecules: Les metallo-catenanes.Tetrahedron Lett. 1983; 24: 5095-5098Crossref Scopus (552) Google Scholar on the Cu(I)-templated synthesis of bis-phenanthroline [2]catenates with reticular chemistry.8Yaghi O.M. Kalmutzki M.J. Diercks C.S. Introduction to Reticular Chemistry: Metal-Organic Frameworks and Covalent Organic Frameworks. Wiley, Weinheim2019Crossref Scopus (252) Google Scholar Another major contribution was made by Wennemers and co-workers,9Lewandowska U. Zajaczkowski W. Corra S. Tanabe J. Borrmann R. Benetti E.M. Stappert S. Watanabe K. Ochs N.A.K. Schaeublin R. et al.A triaxial supramolecular weave.Nat. Chem. 2017; 9: 1068-1072Crossref PubMed Google Scholar who invoked a supramolecular weaving strategy to produce a triaxial interwoven assembly that is held together by noncovalent bonding interactions. Despite the recent progress in the construction of interwoven structures within extended frameworks,7Dietrich-Buchecker C.O. Sauvage J.P. Kintzinger J.P. Une nouvelle famille de molecules: Les metallo-catenanes.Tetrahedron Lett. 1983; 24: 5095-5098Crossref Scopus (552) Google Scholar supramolecular assemblies,9Lewandowska U. Zajaczkowski W. Corra S. Tanabe J. Borrmann R. Benetti E.M. Stappert S. Watanabe K. Ochs N.A.K. Schaeublin R. et al.A triaxial supramolecular weave.Nat. Chem. 2017; 9: 1068-1072Crossref PubMed Google Scholar and polymer networks,10Li G. Wang L. Wu L. Guo Z. Zhao J. Liu Y. Bai R. Yan X. Woven polymer networks via the topological transformation of a [2]catenane.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2020; 142: 14343-14349Crossref PubMed Scopus (15) Google Scholar it remains a grand challenge to develop practical weaving strategies for the synthesis of discrete small molecules with well-defined topologies. Recently, Leigh and his co-workers11Leigh D.A. Danon J.J. Fielden S.D.P. Lemonnier J.-F. Whitehead G.F.S. Woltering S.L. A molecular endless (74) knot.Nat. Chem. 2021; 13: 117-122Crossref PubMed Scopus (29) Google Scholar proposed and executed a new weaving protocol in their precise synthesis of a molecular endless knot, a feat in topology that had not been accomplished previously by chemists. The synthesis of molecular knots usually involves a two-step procedure in which the pre-assembly of building blocks is a prerequisite for the generation of the desired topologies following subsequent ring-closing reactions. In contrast to previous molecular knots that have resulted mainly from linear/circular helicates, the appropriate precursor for a seven-crossing (74 in Alexander–Briggs notation) molecular endless knot is a [3 × 3] interwoven grid. One of the major difficulties faced during its formation is the excessive strain generated during the weaving process. This energetically unfavorable obstacle can be minimized through the exquisite structural design (Figure 1) of the ligand, e.g., strand 1, featuring the use of thiazolo[5,4-d]thiazole (TTZ) units to adopt zig-zag coordination geometries. Specifically, strand 1 contains three tridentate coordination sites for octahedral Fe(II) ions, in which one is able to form an inner site by the combination of two TTZ units and a 4-dimethylaminopyridine group, while the other two form outer sites with each composed of TTZ, benzimidazole, and pyridine units. Furthermore, the medium-length, alkene-terminated chains of 1 are not only short enough to guarantee intragrid—rather than intergrid—olefin metathesis, but also sufficiently long to avoid the generation of additional strain during the ring closure. The last all-important piece of the puzzle in the construction (Figure 2) of the [3 × 3] interwoven grid is the templation by tetrafluoroborate (BF4−) anions. Upon the addition of Fe(BF4)2 into a solution of 1, the targeted grid [Fe916](BF4)18 was formed quantitatively, as probed by variable temperature and diffusion-ordered 1H NMR spectroscopy and verified by X-ray crystallography. It is worth noting that four BF4− anions are accommodated in the square cavities formed between the "weft" and "warp" strands within the grid. All the B–F bonds in each BF4− anion point in the direction of Fe(II) ions located at the corners of squares, and all the fluorine atoms are engaged in close contacts with the centers of the electron-deficient thiazole rings. This well-ordered arrangement (Figure 2) confers stabilization upon the interwoven assembly as a result of synergistic charge–dipole and anion–π interactions. When subjected to microwave irradiation at 110°C in the presence of the second-generation Hoveyda–Grubbs catalyst and subsequent demetallation with competing ligands, the [Fe916](BF4)18 grid was transformed into the molecular 74 knot 3, accompanied by the macrocycle 4 and the Solomon link 5 as byproducts. The targeted product 3 was isolated from the other cyclic molecules by gel permeation chromatography and then identified by the combined use of electrospray ionization mass spectrometry and 1H NMR spectroscopy. The 7% overall yield of 3 is not unreasonable, given the fact that the connections between adjacent strand ends of the [Fe916](BF4)18 grid proceed by different possible pathways, only one of which leads to the formation of 3. This limited selectivity is an obstacle that needs to be overcome when it comes to weaving larger (e.g., [5 × 5] or [7 × 7]) grids using longer strands. This piece of research represents the first implementation of a weaving strategy in the precise synthesis of molecular knots. The resulting 74 knot is the basic motif of the smallest Chinese knot and Celtic lace. Shortly afterward, Leigh et al.12August D.P. Dryfe R.A.W. Haigh S.J. Kent P.R.C. Leigh D.A. Lemonnier J.-F. Li Z. Muryn C.A. Palmer L.I. Song Y. et al.Self-assembly of a layered two-dimensional molecularly woven fabric.Nature. 2020; 588: 429-435Crossref PubMed Scopus (26) Google Scholar implemented a similar strategy to construct a 2D molecular fabric (Figure 1) through the intergrid connections between pre-assembled [3 × 3] interwoven grids. The oxidation of thiols to disulfides was chosen as an appropriate crosslinking reaction, on account of (1) its effectiveness in the condensed matter and (2) the fact that the only reagent and waste product of this transformation—i.e., O2 and H2O, respectively—can both diffuse through the solid material. To this end, a thiol-terminated strand 2, bearing the same coordination sites as strand 1, was used (Figure 1) as the building block, which was treated with Fe(BF4)2 to form a "woven tile," namely [Fe926](BF4)18. When exposed to air, the slow precipitation of [Fe926](BF4)18 from solution and the oxidative transformation from thiol groups to disulfide bonds induced the connections between adjacent woven grids, leading to the slow formation, over the course of 3 days, of solid films and microcrystalline particles on the surface of the reaction vessel. These solid products were treated with KCN solution to remove the ion templates, and thereafter washed with different solvents, affording a wholly organic molecular fabric 6. Both scanning electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy showed the 2D sheet morphology of 6 with dimensions of up to a few hundreds of micrometers in length and width, but only around four nanometers thick. The long-range order of this molecularly woven material was confirmed by X-ray scattering analyses and the phenomenon of birefringence. Compared with a non-woven linear polymer constructed from the same building block, the woven molecular fabric 6 showed enhanced mechanical strength as a result of the topologically constrained alignment of the polymer chains. Moreover, taking advantage of the nanogaps between the strands in this molecular fabric, the authors demonstrated the ability of 6 to act as a net. Following its deposition onto a polymer-supported membrane, the molecular fabric was capable of slowing down the passage of ions in a size-selective manner, suggesting its potential application in nanofiltration and in biomimetic ion channels. In contrast with previous synthetic methods6Liu Y. Ma Y. Zhao Y. Sun X. Gándara F. Furukawa H. Liu Z. Zhu H. Zhu C. Suenaga K. et al.Weaving of organic threads into a crystalline covalent organic framework.Science. 2016; 351: 365-369Crossref PubMed Scopus (294) Google Scholar,10Li G. Wang L. Wu L. Guo Z. Zhao J. Liu Y. Bai R. Yan X. Woven polymer networks via the topological transformation of a [2]catenane.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2020; 142: 14343-14349Crossref PubMed Scopus (15) Google Scholar used for generating entanglements in reticular networks, in Leigh's approach, the molecular fabric is formed by the tessellation and extension of pre-woven molecular grids, a process that has advantages when it comes to controlling the cross sequence and orientation of strands in the resulting material. This new strategy, based on the rational design of molecular building blocks, can improve the predictability and precision during the incorporation of topologies into molecular architectures. There is a lot of room remaining to be explored in the realm2Stoddart J.F. Dawning of the age of molecular nanotopology.Nano Lett. 2020; 20: 5597-5600Crossref PubMed Scopus (24) Google Scholar,3Guo Q.-H. Jiao Y. Feng Y. Stoddart J.F. The rise and promise of molecular nanotopology.CCS Chem. 2021; 3: 1542-1572Crossref Scopus (22) Google Scholar of molecular nanotopology, as exemplified by the fact that only a very few of the six billion prime knots defined by mathematicians have been synthesized by chemists to date. It is of paramount importance to enrich the synthetic toolkit for introducing more complexity into the topologies of molecules. The recent breakthroughs11Leigh D.A. Danon J.J. Fielden S.D.P. Lemonnier J.-F. Whitehead G.F.S. Woltering S.L. A molecular endless (74) knot.Nat. Chem. 2021; 13: 117-122Crossref PubMed Scopus (29) Google Scholar,12August D.P. Dryfe R.A.W. Haigh S.J. Kent P.R.C. Leigh D.A. Lemonnier J.-F. Li Z. Muryn C.A. Palmer L.I. Song Y. et al.Self-assembly of a layered two-dimensional molecularly woven fabric.Nature. 2020; 588: 429-435Crossref PubMed Scopus (26) Google Scholar made by Leigh's team represent strategic innovations in the precise construction of molecular knots and mechanically interlocked materials. We are optimistic that the weaving strategy—as the previous twisting, folding, and threading strategies have done before—will expand the reach of molecular nanotopology, lay the foundation for the establishment of topology-property relationships, and forge the state-of-the-art applications of topological molecules as real materials. Our foray into the galaxy of molecular nanotopology has only just begun.

Assembly of a Porous Supramolecular Polyknot from Rigid Trigonal Prismatic Building Blocks.

Coordination-driven Self-Assembly of a Molecular Figure-Eight Knot and Other Topologically Complex Architectures

Template-Free Self-Assembly of Molecular Trefoil Knots and Double Trefoil Knots Featuring Cp*Rh Building Blocks.

The Topological Transformation of 41 Knot to 41 2 Link Through Supramolecular Fusion

Stereoselective synthesis of a composite knot with nine crossings.

An Unusual 3d Coordination Polymer Assembled Through Parallel Interpenetrating and Polycatenating of (6,3) Nets

The Topological Transformation of 41 Knot to 412 Link through Supramolecular Fusion

Design of and Stability Studies on Trefoil Knots Featuring RhCp* Building Blocks

The codriven assembly of molecular metalla-links ([Formula: see text], [Formula: see text]) and metalla-knots ([Formula: see text], [Formula: see text]) via coordination and noncovalent interactions.

A Template-Free Strategy for the Synthesis of Highly Stable Trefoil Knots

A molecular endless (74) knot

Coordination-driven Self-Assembly of a Molecular 818 Knot and Molecular Borromean Rings

Self‐Assembly of an Interlaced Triple‐Stranded Molecular Braid with an Unprecedented Topology Through Hydrogen‐Bonding Interactions

The Codriven Assembly of Molecular Metalla-Links (613, 623) and Metalla-Knots (41, 31) Via Coordination and Noncovalent Interactions

A Programmed Hydrogen Bonding Array Self-Assembles into a Polymeric Zipper-Like Architecture

Weaving on the Molecular Scale

Same Knot, Longer Rope: Altering Ligand Geometry Provides Control over Nuclearity in Self-Assembled Trefoil Knots.

Self-Assembly of Molecular Figure-Eight Knots Induced by Quadruple Stacking Interactions.

Construction of a Molecular Prime Link by Interlocking Two Trefoil Knots

Knotting matters: orderly molecular entanglements

The Codriven Assembly of Molecular Metalla- Links (631,632) and Metalla- Knots (41,31) Via Coordination and Noncovalent Interactions