Abstract:Cyclic peptides have emerged as a highly promising class of therapeutic molecules owing to their favorable pharmacokinetic properties, including stability and permeability. Currently, many clinically approved cyclic peptides are derived from natural products or their derivatives, and the development of molecular docking techniques for cyclic peptide discovery holds great promise for expanding the applications and potential of this class of molecules. Given the availability of numerous docking programs, there is a pressing need for a systematic evaluation of their performance, specifically on protein-cyclic peptide systems. In this study, we constructed an extensive benchmark data set called CPSet, consisting of 493 protein-cyclic peptide complexes. Based on this data set, we conducted a comprehensive evaluation of 10 docking programs, including Rosetta, AutoDock CrankPep, and eight protein-small molecule docking programs (i.e., AutoDock, AudoDock Vina, Glide, GOLD, LeDock, rDock, MOE, and Surflex). The evaluation encompassed the assessment of the sampling power, docking power, and scoring power of these programs. The results revealed that all of the tested protein-small molecule docking programs successfully sampled the binding conformations when using the crystal conformations as the initial structures. Among them, rDock exhibited outstanding performance, achieving a remarkable 94.3% top-100 sampling success rate. However, few programs achieved successful predictions of the binding conformations using tLEaP-generated conformations as the initial structures. Within this scheme, AutoDock CrankPep yielded the highest top-100 sampling success rate of 29.6%. Rosetta's scoring function outperformed the others in selecting optimal conformations, resulting in an impressive top-1 docking success rate of 87.6%. Nevertheless, all the tested scoring functions displayed limited performance in predicting binding affinity, with MOE@Affinity dG exhibiting the highest Pearson's correlation coefficient of 0.378. It is therefore suggested to use an appropriate combination of different docking programs for given tasks in real applications. We expect that this work will offer valuable insights into selecting the appropriate docking programs for protein-cyclic peptide complexes.

CoDockPP: a Multistage Approach for Global and Site-specific Protein-protein Docking.

Protein-Protein Docking with Binding Site Patch Prediction and Network-Based Terms Enhanced Combinatorial Scoring

Sdock: A Global Protein-Protein Docking Program Using Stepwise Force-Field Potentials

SOFTDOCK application to protein-protein interaction benchmark and CAPRI.

A filter enhanced sampling and combinatorial scoring study for protein docking in CAPRI

FitDock: protein–ligand docking by template fitting

Comprehensive Evaluation of Fourteen Docking Programs on Protein-Peptide Complexes

Progress in the Scoring Functions of Protein-Protein Docking

Biologically enhanced sampling geometric docking and backbone flexibility treatment with multiconformational superposition

Recent advances on protein-protein docking.

DeltaDock: A Unified Framework for Accurate, Efficient, and Physically Reliable Molecular Docking

Docking Challenge: Protein Sampling and Molecular Docking Performance

ColabDock: Inverting AlphaFold Structure Prediction Model for Protein-Protein Docking with Experimental Restraints

Inclusion of Desolvation Energy into Protein–Protein Docking through Atomic Contact Potentials

PSI-DOCK: Towards Highly Efficient and Accurate Flexible Ligand Docking.

A holistic molecular docking approach for predicting protein-protein complex structure

Comprehensive Evaluation of 10 Docking Programs on a Diverse Set of Protein-Cyclic Peptide Complexes.

COACH-D: improved protein-ligand binding sites prediction with refined ligand-binding poses through molecular docking

Towards protein-protein docking with significant structural changes using CABS-dock

A Graph-Based Approach for Protein-Protein Docking

ApoDock: Ligand-Conditioned Sidechain Packing for Flexible Molecular Docking