Momentum informed muon scattering tomography for monitoring spent nuclear fuels in dry storage cask

JungHyun Bae,Rose Montgomery,Stylianos Chatzidakis
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-57105-y
IF: 4.6
2024-03-21
Scientific Reports
Abstract:Development of an effective monitoring method for spent nuclear fuel (SNF) in a dry storage cask (DSC) is important to meet the increasing demand for dry storage investigations. The DSC investigation should provide information about the quantity of stored SNF, and quality assurance of materials should be possible without opening the cask. However, traditional nondestructive examination (NDE) methods such as x-rays are difficult to deploy for DSC investigation because a typical DSC is intentionally designed to shield against radiation. To address this challenge, cosmic ray muons (CRMs) are used as an alternative NDE radiation probe because they can easily penetrate an entire DSC system; however, a wide application of muons is often hindered due to the naturally low CRM flux (~10 4 muons/m 2 /min). This paper introduces a newly proposed imaging algorithm, momentum-informed muon scattering tomography (MMST) , and presents how a limitation of the current muon scattering tomography technique has been addressed by measuring muon momentum. To demonstrate its functionality, a commercial DSC with 24 pressurized light water reactor fuel assemblies (FAs) and the MMST system were designed in GEANT4. Three noticeable improvements were observed for MMST system as a DSC investigation tool: (1) a signal stabilization, (2) an enhanced capability to differentiate various materials, and (3) statistically increased precision to identify and locate missing FAs. The results show that MMST improves the investigation accuracy from 79 to 98% when one FA is missing and 51% to 88% when one-half FA is missing. The advancement of the NDE technique using CRM for DSC verification is expected to resolve long-standing problems in increasing demand for DSC inspections and nuclear security.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of monitoring spent nuclear fuel (SNF) in dry storage casks (DSC). Specifically: 1. **Need for Non-Destructive Testing Methods**: With the increasing demand for the inspection of dry storage casks, there is a need for an effective method to monitor the spent fuel in these casks. This method should be able to provide information about the quantity of stored spent fuel and ensure the quality of the material without opening the cask. 2. **Limitations of Traditional Methods**: Traditional non-destructive testing methods (such as X-rays) are difficult to apply to the inspection of dry storage casks because these casks are designed to shield radiation. 3. **Application of Cosmic Ray Muons**: To overcome this challenge, the paper proposes using cosmic ray muons (CRMs) as an alternative non-destructive testing method. Although muons can penetrate the entire dry storage cask system, the natural muon flux is relatively low (about 10^4 muons/m²/min), which limits its application. 4. **Improved Imaging Algorithm**: The paper introduces a new imaging algorithm—Momentum-Informed Muon Scattering Tomography (MMST). By measuring the momentum of muons, it addresses the limitations of existing muon scattering tomography techniques. 5. **Performance Enhancements**: When using the MMST system for dry storage cask inspection, three significant improvements were observed: - Signal stabilization - Enhanced ability to distinguish different materials - Statistically improved accuracy in identifying and locating missing fuel assemblies In summary, the paper aims to improve the non-destructive testing accuracy of spent nuclear fuel in dry storage casks by developing a new imaging algorithm, MMST, thereby addressing the limitations of traditional methods in practical applications.