Rigidity in mechanical biological networks

M. Lisa Manning

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2024.07.014

IF: 9.2

2024-10-22

Current Biology

Abstract:In this review, Lisa Manning distills recent theoretical work identifying the mechanisms that drive rigidity transitions in mechanical networks, so that biologists can look for these mechanisms in specific in vivo or in vitro systems.

cell biology,biochemistry & molecular biology,biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

A geometrically controlled rigidity transition in a model for confluent 3D tissues

Matthias Merkel,M Lisa Manning

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/aaaa13

2018-02-15

New Journal of Physics

Abstract:The origin of rigidity in disordered materials is an outstanding open problem in statistical physics. Previously, a class of 2D cellular models has been shown to undergo a rigidity transition controlled by a mechanical parameter that specifies cell shapes. Here, we generalize this model to 3D and find a rigidity transition that is similarly controlled by the preferred surface area S0: the model is solid-like below a dimensionless surface area of s 0 ≡ S 0 / V ¯ 2 / 3 ≈ 5.413 with V ¯ being the average cell volume, and fluid-like above this value. We demonstrate that, unlike jamming in soft spheres, residual stresses are necessary to create rigidity. These stresses occur precisely when cells are unable to obtain their desired geometry, and we conjecture that there is a well-defined minimal surface area possible for disordered cellular structures. We show that the behavior of this minimal surface induces a linear scaling of the shear modulus with the control parameter at the transition point, which is different from the scaling observed in particulate matter. The existence of such a minimal surface may be relevant for biological tissues and foams, and helps explain why cell shapes are a good structural order parameter for rigidity transitions in biological tissues.

physics, multidisciplinary
Mechanics of biological networks: from the cell cytoskeleton to connective tissue

Robyn H. Pritchard,Yan Yan Shery Huang,Eugene M. Terentjev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/c3sm52769g

IF: 4.046

2014-01-01

Soft Matter

Abstract:From the cell cytoskeleton to connective tissues, fibrous networks are ubiquitous in metazoan life as the key promoters of mechanical strength, support and integrity. In recent decades, the application of physics to biological systems has made substantial strides in elucidating the striking mechanical phenomena observed in such networks, explaining strain stiffening, power law rheology and cytoskeletal fluidisation - all key to the biological function of individual cells and tissues. In this review we focus on the current progress in the field, with a primer into the basic physics of individual filaments and the networks they form. This is followed by a discussion of biological networks in the context of a broad spread of recent in vitro and in vivo experiments.

polymer science,chemistry, physical,materials science, multidisciplinary,physics
Energetic rigidity I: A unifying theory of mechanical stability

Ojan Khatib Damavandi,Varda F. Hagh,Christian D. Santangelo,M. Lisa Manning

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2102.11310

2021-07-09

Abstract:Rigidity regulates the integrity and function of many physical and biological systems. This is the first of two papers on the origin of rigidity, wherein we propose that "energetic rigidity," in which all non-trivial deformations raise the energy of a structure, is a more useful notion of rigidity in practice than two more commonly used rigidity tests: Maxwell-Calladine constraint counting (first-order rigidity) and second-order rigidity. We find that constraint counting robustly predicts energetic rigidity only when the system has no states of self stress. When the system has states of self stress, we show that second-order rigidity can imply energetic rigidity in systems that are not considered rigid based on constraint counting, and is even more reliable than shear modulus. We also show that there may be systems for which neither first nor second-order rigidity imply energetic rigidity. The formalism of energetic rigidity unifies our understanding of mechanical stability and also suggests new avenues for material design.

Soft Condensed Matter,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Materials Science,Biological Physics
Rigidity of Epithelial Tissues as a Double Optimization Problem

Sadjad Arzash,Indrajit Tah,Andrea J. Liu,M. Lisa Manning

2024-07-16

Abstract:How do cells tune emergent properties at the scale of tissues? One class of such emergent behaviors are rigidity transitions, in which a tissue changes from a solid-like to a fluid-like state or vice versa. Here, we introduce a new way that cells can tune rigidity using "adaptive degrees of freedom." We study rigidity in vertex models, using the elastic energy as a cost function and the cell stiffnesses, target shapes, and target areas as sets of adaptive degrees of freedom that can be introduced to minimize the cost function. We show that the rigidity transition is unaffected when cell stiffnesses are treated as adaptive degrees of freedom. When preferred shapes or areas are treated as adaptive degrees of freedom, however, induced spatial correlations in target cell shapes or areas shift the rigidity transition. These observations suggest that tissues can tune properties at the cell-scale to obtain desired tissue-scale behaviors.

Soft Condensed Matter,Biological Physics,Tissues and Organs
The stiffness of living tissues and its implications for tissue engineering

Carlos F. Guimarães,Luca Gasperini,Alexandra P. Marques,Rui L. Reis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41578-019-0169-1

IF: 83.5

2020-02-21

Nature Reviews Materials

Abstract:The past 20 years have witnessed ever-growing evidence that the mechanical properties of biological tissues, from nanoscale to macroscale dimensions, are fundamental for cellular behaviour and consequent tissue functionality. This knowledge, combined with previously known biochemical cues, has greatly advanced the field of biomaterial development, tissue engineering and regenerative medicine. It is now established that approaches to engineer biological tissues must integrate and approximate the mechanics, both static and dynamic, of native tissues. Nevertheless, the literature on the mechanical properties of biological tissues differs greatly in methodology, and the available data are widely dispersed. This Review gathers together the most important data on the stiffness of living tissues and discusses the intricacies of tissue stiffness from a materials perspective, highlighting the main challenges associated with engineering lifelike tissues and proposing a unified view of this as yet unreported topic. Emerging advances that might pave the way for the next decade's take on bioengineered tissue stiffness are also presented, and differences and similarities between tissues in health and disease are discussed, along with various techniques for characterizing tissue stiffness at various dimensions from individual cells to organs.

materials science, multidisciplinary,nanoscience & nanotechnology
Rigidity transitions in anisotropic networks happen in multiple steps

William Y. Wang,Stephen J. Thornton,Bulbul Chakraborty,Anna Barth,Navneet Singh,Japheth Omonira,Jonathan A. Michel,Moumita Das,James P. Sethna,Itai Cohen

2024-09-13

Abstract:We study how the rigidity transition in a triangular lattice changes as a function of anisotropy by preferentially filling bonds on the lattice in one direction. We discover that the onset of rigidity in anisotropic spring networks arises in at least two steps, reminiscent of the two-step melting transition in two dimensional crystals. In particular, our simulations demonstrate that the percolation of stress-supporting bonds happens at different critical volume fractions along different directions. By examining each independent component of the elasticity tensor, we determine universal exponents and develop universal scaling functions to analyze isotropic rigidity percolation as a multicritical point. We expect that these results will be important for elucidating the underlying mechanical phase transitions governing the properties of biological materials ranging from the cytoskeletons of cells to the extracellular networks of tissues such as tendon where the networks are often preferentially aligned.

Soft Condensed Matter,Statistical Mechanics
How does the extracellular matrix affect the rigidity of an embedded spheroid?

Amanda Parker,M. Cristina Marchetti,M. Lisa Manning,J. M. Schwarz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2006.16203

2020-06-30

Abstract:Cellularized tissue and polymer networks can both transition from floppy to rigid as a function of their control parameters, and, yet, the two systems often mechanically interact, which may affect their respective rigidities. To study this interaction, we consider a vertex model with interfacial tension (a spheroid) embedded in a spring network in two dimensions. We identify two regimes with different global spheroid shapes, governed by the pressure resulting from competition between interfacial tension and tension in the network. In the first regime, the tissue remains compact, while in the second, a cavitation-like instability leads to the emergence of gaps at the tissue-network interface. Intriguingly, compression of the tissue promotes fluidization, while tension promotes cellular alignment and rigidification, with the mechanisms driving rigidification differing on either side of the instability.

Cell Behavior,Soft Condensed Matter,Tissues and Organs
Mechanical state transitions in the regulation of tissue form and function

Yanlan Mao,Sara A. Wickström

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41580-024-00719-x

IF: 113.915

2024-04-11

Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology

Abstract:From embryonic development, postnatal growth and adult homeostasis to reparative and disease states, cells and tissues undergo constant changes in genome activity, cell fate, proliferation, movement, metabolism and growth. Importantly, these biological state transitions are coupled to changes in the mechanical and material properties of cells and tissues, termed mechanical state transitions. These mechanical states share features with physical states of matter, liquids and solids. Tissues can switch between mechanical states by changing behavioural dynamics or connectivity between cells. Conversely, these changes in tissue mechanical properties are known to control cell and tissue function, most importantly the ability of cells to move or tissues to deform. Thus, tissue mechanical state transitions are implicated in transmitting information across biological length and time scales, especially during processes of early development, wound healing and diseases such as cancer. This Review will focus on the biological basis of tissue-scale mechanical state transitions, how they emerge from molecular and cellular interactions, and their roles in organismal development, homeostasis, regeneration and disease.

cell biology
A minimal-length approach unifies rigidity in under-constrained materials

Matthias Merkel,Karsten Baumgarten,Brian P. Tighe,M. Lisa Manning

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1815436116

2019-01-25

Abstract:We present a novel approach to understand geometric-incompatibility-induced rigidity in under-constrained materials, including sub-isostatic 2D spring networks and 2D and 3D vertex models for dense biological tissues. We show that in all these models a geometric criterion, represented by a minimal length $\bar\ell_\mathrm{min}$, determines the onset of prestresses and rigidity. This allows us to predict not only the correct scalings for the elastic material properties, but also the precise {\em magnitudes} for bulk modulus and shear modulus discontinuities at the rigidity transition as well as the magnitude of the Poynting effect. We also predict from first principles that the ratio of the excess shear modulus to the shear stress should be inversely proportional to the critical strain with a prefactor of three, and propose that this factor of three is a general hallmark of geometrically induced rigidity in under-constrained materials and could be used to distinguish this effect from nonlinear mechanics of single components in experiments. Lastly, our results may lay important foundations for ways to estimate $\bar\ell_\mathrm{min}$ from measurements of local geometric structure, and thus help develop methods to characterize large-scale mechanical properties from imaging data.

Soft Condensed Matter,Biological Physics,Tissues and Organs
Mechanobiological Stability of Biological Soft Tissues

Marcos Latorre,Jay D Humphrey

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmps.2018.12.013

Abstract:Like all other materials, biological soft tissues are subject to general laws of physics, including those governing mechanical equilibrium and stability. In addition, however, these tissues are able to respond actively to changes in their mechanical and chemical environment. There is, therefore, a pressing need to understand such processes theoretically. In this paper, we present a new rate-based constrained mixture formulation suitable for studying mechanobiological equilibrium and stability of soft tissues exposed to transient or sustained changes in material composition or applied loading. These concepts are illustrated for canonical problems in arterial mechanics, which distinguish possible stable versus unstable mechanobiological responses. Such analyses promise to yield insight into biological processes that govern both health and disease progression.
Colloquium: Mechanical formalisms for tissue dynamics

Sham Tlili,Cyprien Gay,Francois Graner,Philippe Marcq,François Molino,Pierre Saramito

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1309.7432

2015-09-29

Abstract:The understanding of morphogenesis in living organisms has been renewed by tremendous progressin experimental techniques that provide access to cell-scale, quantitative information both on theshapes of cells within tissues and on the genes being expressed. This information suggests that ourunderstanding of the respective contributions of gene expression and mechanics, and of their crucialentanglement, will soon leap forward. Biomechanics increasingly benefits from models, which assistthe design and interpretation of experiments, point out the main ingredients and assumptions, andultimately lead to predictions. The newly accessible local information thus calls for a reflectionon how to select suitable classes of mechanical models. We review both mechanical ingredientssuggested by the current knowledge of tissue behaviour, and modelling methods that can helpgenerate a rheological diagram or a constitutive equation. We distinguish cell scale ("intra-cell")and tissue scale ("inter-cell") contributions. We recall the mathematical framework developpedfor continuum materials and explain how to transform a constitutive equation into a set of partialdifferential equations amenable to numerical resolution. We show that when plastic behaviour isrelevant, the dissipation function formalism appears appropriate to generate constitutive equations;its variational nature facilitates numerical implementation, and we discuss adaptations needed in thecase of large deformations. The present article gathers theoretical methods that can readily enhancethe significance of the data to be extracted from recent or future high throughput biomechanicalexperiments.

Biological Physics,Soft Condensed Matter,Medical Physics,Cell Behavior
Single-Cell Mechanics: Structural Determinants and Functional Relevance

Marta Urbanska,Jochen Guck

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-biophys-030822-030629

2024-02-21

Annual Review of Biophysics

Abstract:The mechanical phenotype of a cell determines its ability to deform under force and is therefore relevant to cellular functions that require changes in cell shape, such as migration or circulation through the microvasculature. On the practical level, the mechanical phenotype can be used as a global readout of the cell's functional state, a marker for disease diagnostics, or an input for tissue modeling. We focus our review on the current knowledge of structural components that contribute to the determination of the cellular mechanical properties and highlight the physiological processes in which the mechanical phenotype of the cells is of critical relevance. The ongoing efforts to understand how to efficiently measure and control the mechanical properties of cells will define the progress in the field and drive mechanical phenotyping toward clinical applications. Expected final online publication date for the Annual Review of Biophysics, Volume 53 is May 2024. Please see http://www.annualreviews.org/page/journal/pubdates for revised estimates.

biophysics
Stability and roughness of interfaces in mechanically-regulated tissues

John J. Williamson,Guillaume Salbreux

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.121.238102

2018-11-30

Abstract:Cell division and death can be regulated by the mechanical forces within a tissue. We study the consequences for the stability and roughness of a propagating interface, by analysing a model of mechanically-regulated tissue growth in the regime of small driving forces. For an interface driven by homeostatic pressure imbalance or leader-cell motility, long and intermediate-wavelength instabilities arise, depending respectively on an effective viscosity of cell number change, and on substrate friction. A further mechanism depends on the strength of directed motility forces acting in the bulk. We analyse the fluctuations of a stable interface subjected to cell-level stochasticity, and find that mechanical feedback can help preserve reproducibility at the tissue scale. Our results elucidate mechanisms that could be important for orderly interface motion in developing tissues.

Biological Physics,Soft Condensed Matter
Rigidity Loss in Disordered Systems: Three Scenarios

Wouter G Ellenbroek,Varda F Hagh,Avishek Kumar,M F Thorpe,Martin van Hecke,Wouter G. Ellenbroek,Varda F. Hagh,M. F. Thorpe

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.114.135501

IF: 8.6

2015-04-01

Physical Review Letters

Abstract:We reveal significant qualitative differences in the rigidity transition of three types of disordered network materials: randomly diluted spring networks, jammed sphere packings, and stress-relieved networks that are diluted using a protocol that avoids the appearance of floppy regions. The marginal state of jammed and stress-relieved networks are globally isostatic, while marginal randomly diluted networks show both overconstrained and underconstrained regions. When a single bond is added to or removed from these isostatic systems, jammed networks become globally overconstrained or floppy, whereas the effect on stress-relieved networks is more local and limited. These differences are also reflected in the linear elastic properties and point to the highly effective and unusual role of global self-organization in jammed sphere packings.

physics, multidisciplinary
Optimizing properties on the critical rigidity manifold of underconstrained central-force networks

Tyler Hain,Chris Santangelo,M. Lisa Manning

2024-07-19

Abstract:Our goal is to develop a design framework for multifunctional mechanical metamaterials that can tune their rigidity while optimizing other desired properties. Towards this goal, we first demonstrate that underconstrained central force networks possess a critical rigidity manifold of codimension one in the space of their physical constraints. We describe how the geometry of this manifold generates a natural parameterization in terms of the states of self-stress, and then use this parameterization to numerically generate disordered network structures that are on the critical rigidity manifold and also optimize various objective functions, such as maximizing the bulk stiffness under dilation, or minimizing length variance to find networks that can be self-assembled from equal-length parts. This framework can be used to design mechanical metamaterials that can tune their rigidity and also exhibit other desired properties.

Soft Condensed Matter
Shape driven confluent rigidity transition in curved biological tissues

Evan Thomas,Sevan Hopyan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bpj.2023.10.001

2022-10-18

Abstract:Collective cell motions underlie structure formation during embryonic development. Tissues exhibit emergent multicellular characteristics such as jamming, rigidity transitions, and glassy dynamics, but there remain questions about how those tissue scale dynamics derive from local cell level properties. Specifically, there has been little consideration of the interplay between local tissue geometry and cellular properties influencing larger scale tissue behaviours. Here we consider a simple two dimensional computational vertex model for confluent tissue monolayers, which exhibits a rigidity phase transition controlled by the shape index (ratio of perimeter to square root area) of cells, on a spherical surface. We show that the critical point for the rigidity transition is a function of curvature such that more highly curved systems are more likely to be in a less rigid, more fluid, phase. A phase diagram we generate for the curvature and shape index constitutes a testable prediction from the model. The curvature dependence is interesting because it suggests a natural explanation for more dynamic tissue remodelling and facile growth in regions of higher surface curvature, without invoking the need for biochemical or other physical differences. This has potential ramifications for our understanding of morphogenesis of budding and branching structures.

Biological Physics,Soft Condensed Matter
Conformational Control of Mechanical Networks

Jason Z. Kim,Zhixin Lu,Steven H. Strogatz,Danielle S. Bassett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41567-019-0475-y

2018-05-03

Abstract:Understanding conformational change is crucial for programming and controlling the function of many mechanical systems such as allosteric enzymes and tunable metamaterials. Of particular interest is the relationship between the network topology or geometry and the specific motions observed under controlling perturbations. We study this relationship in mechanical networks of 2-D and 3-D Maxwell frames composed of point masses connected by rigid rods rotating freely about the masses. We first develop simple principles that yield all bipartite network topologies and geometries that give rise to an arbitrarily specified instantaneous and finitely deformable motion in the masses as the sole non-rigid body zero mode. We then extend these principles to characterize networks that simultaneously yield multiple specified zero modes, and create large networks by coupling individual modules. These principles are then used to characterize and design networks with useful material (negative Poisson ratio) and mechanical (targeted allosteric response) functions.

Computational Physics,Materials Science,Applied Physics
Mechanical Modeling and Analyses of Cytoskeleton and Extracellular Matrix

GONG Bo,LIN Ji,WANG Yanzhong,QIAN Jin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21656/1000-0887.420302

2021-01-01

Abstract:The cells and biological tissues need to adapt the complex physiological and mechanical environment in human body. They must withstand the mechanical loads from external environment, and equally important, they often actively produce forces to change their architecture and shape during physiological processes such as tissue growth and repair. The mechanical properties of cells are mainly determined by cytoskeleton, and the stiffness of biological tissues is greatly affected by extracellular matrix. Microscopically, cytoskeleton and extracellular matrix are intricate, heterogeneous 3D networks of crosslinked biopolymers. Early studies mainly focused on explaining the universal features such as the nonlinear response and strain stiffening of these biopolymer networks by constructing various network models. In recent years, with the simultaneous progress in experimental methods, theoretical models and computational techniques, more intriguing mechanical behaviors and underlying mechanisms of these living matters have been revealed. In this review, we online some of the major advances in modeling and analyzing cytoskeleton and extracellular matrix, including the dynamic crosslinking, active materials originated from mechanochemical coupling of biopolymers, plasticity/fracture of crosslinked networks, and self-adaption triggered by mechanical training. These modeling and analyses may help to quantify the complex behaviors of cells and tissues, deepen our understanding of the underlying mechanobiological mechanisms, and provide guidance for synthetic biological materials and tissue engineering.
Criticality and isostaticity in fiber networks

Chase P. Broedersz,Xiaoming Mao,T.C. Lubensky,F.C. MacKintosh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nphys2127

2010-11-30

Abstract:The rigidity of elastic networks depends sensitively on their internal connectivity and the nature of the interactions between constituents. Particles interacting via central forces undergo a zero-temperature rigidity-percolation transition near the isostatic threshold, where the constraints and internal degrees of freedom are equal in number. Fibrous networks, such as those that form the cellular cytoskeleton, become rigid at a lower threshold due to additional bending constraints. However, the degree to which bending governs network mechanics remains a subject of considerable debate. We study disordered fibrous networks with variable coordination number, both above and below the central-force isostatic point. This point controls a broad crossover from stretching- to bending-dominated elasticity. Strikingly, this crossover exhibits an anomalous power-law dependence of the shear modulus on both stretching and bending rigidities. At the central-force isostatic point---well above the rigidity threshold---we find divergent strain fluctuations together with a divergent correlation length $\xi$, implying a breakdown of continuum elasticity in this simple mechanical system on length scales less than $\xi$.

Soft Condensed Matter,Statistical Mechanics,Biological Physics
Design of Large Sequential Conformational Change in Mechanical Networks

Jason Z. Kim,Zhixin Lu,Danielle S. Bassett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1906.08400

2019-06-20

Soft Condensed Matter

Abstract:From the complex motions of robots to the oxygen binding of hemoglobin, the function of many mechanical systems depends on large, coordinated movements of their components. Such movements arise from a network of physical interactions in the form of links that transmit forces between constituent elements. However, the principled design of specific movements is made difficult by the number and nonlinearity of interactions. Here, we model mechanical systems as linkages of rigid bonds (edges) connected by joints (nodes), and formulate a simple but powerful framework for designing full nonlinear coordinated motions using concepts from dynamical systems theory. We begin with principles for designing finite and infinitesimal motions in small modules, and show that each module is a one-dimensional map between distances across pairs of nodes. Next, we represent the act of combining modules as an iteration of this map, and design networks whose geometries reflect the map's fixed points, limit cycles, and chaos. We use this representation to design different folding sequences from a deployable network and a soliton, to a branched network acting as a mechanical AND gate. Finally, we design large changes in curvature of the entire network, and construct physical networks from laser-cut acrylic, origami, and 3D printed material to demonstrate the framework's potential and versatility for designing the full conformational trajectory of morphing metamaterials and structures.

Rigidity in mechanical biological networks

A geometrically controlled rigidity transition in a model for confluent 3D tissues

Mechanics of biological networks: from the cell cytoskeleton to connective tissue

Energetic rigidity I: A unifying theory of mechanical stability

Rigidity of Epithelial Tissues as a Double Optimization Problem

The stiffness of living tissues and its implications for tissue engineering

Rigidity transitions in anisotropic networks happen in multiple steps

How does the extracellular matrix affect the rigidity of an embedded spheroid?

Mechanical state transitions in the regulation of tissue form and function

A minimal-length approach unifies rigidity in under-constrained materials

Mechanobiological Stability of Biological Soft Tissues

Colloquium: Mechanical formalisms for tissue dynamics

Single-Cell Mechanics: Structural Determinants and Functional Relevance

Stability and roughness of interfaces in mechanically-regulated tissues

Rigidity Loss in Disordered Systems: Three Scenarios

Optimizing properties on the critical rigidity manifold of underconstrained central-force networks

Shape driven confluent rigidity transition in curved biological tissues

Conformational Control of Mechanical Networks

Mechanical Modeling and Analyses of Cytoskeleton and Extracellular Matrix

Criticality and isostaticity in fiber networks

Design of Large Sequential Conformational Change in Mechanical Networks