No Reliable Gray Matter Changes in Essential Tremor

Rong Luo,PingLei Pan,Yun Xu,Ling Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10072-019-03933-0

2019-01-01

Neurological Sciences

Abstract:Background Voxel-based morphometry (VBM) has been used to study human brain gray matter (GM) alterations in essential tremor (ET) for over one decade. However, the literature revealed heterogeneous findings. Methods We therefore conducted a coordinate-based meta-analysis to synthesize the VBM studies to examine which brain regions show the most reliable GM alterations in patients with ET relative to healthy controls. Results A total of 16 original VBM studies, comprising 387 patients with ET and 355 healthy controls, were included in this meta-analysis. This quantitative meta-analysis revealed no evidence of robust and reliable alterations in regional brain GM structures in ET. Meta-regression analyses indicate that many moderators (e.g., MR field strength, statistical methodology, age, onset age, gender, illness severity, illness duration, and family history) account for some of the heterogeneity in GM across studies. Conclusions High heterogeneity in GM alterations across studies may reflect true heterogeneity in ET regarding the clinic, etiology, and pathology, as well as possibly the VBM methodological variations. Currently, this heterogeneity limits the use of VBM as a reliable tool to distinguish ET from healthy controls. In order to improve reproducibility of VBM results in ET, future research may benefit from increasing the sample size, comprehensively subtyping ET phenotypes, and using well-designed and standardized imaging acquisition and analytical protocols. Furthermore, data sharing should be considered as a high priority.