Study of $e^+e^- o gamma omega J/psi$ and Observation of $X(3872) o omega J/psi$

M Ablikim,M N Achasov,P Adlarson,S. Ahmed,M Albrecht,M Alekseev,A Amoroso,F F An,Q An,Y Bai,O Bakina,R Baldini Ferroli,I Balossino,Y Ban,K Begzsuren,J V Bennett,N Berger,M Bertani,D Bettoni,F Bianchi,J Biernat,J Bloms,I Boyko,R A Briere,H Cai,X Cai,A Calcaterra,G F Cao,N Cao,S A Cetin,J Chai,J F Chang,W L Chang,G Chelkov,D Y Chen,G Chen,H S Chen,J C Chen,M L Chen,S J Chen,Y B Chen,W Cheng,G Cibinetto,F Cossio,X F Cui,H L Dai,J P Dai,X C Dai,A Dbeyssi,D Dedovich,Z Y Deng,A Denig,I Denysenko,M Destefanis,F De Mori,Y Ding,C Dong,J Dong,L Y Dong,M Y Dong,Z L Dou,S X Du,J Z Fan,J Fang,S S Fang,Y Fang,R Farinelli,L Fava,F Feldbauer,G Felici,C Q Feng,M Fritsch,C D Fu,Y Fu,Q Gao,X L Gao,Y Gao,Y G Gao,Z Gao,B. Garillon,I Garzia,E M Gersabeck,A Gilman,K Goetzen,L Gong,W X Gong,W Gradl,M Greco,L M Gu,M H Gu,S Gu,Y T Gu,A Q Guo,L B Guo,R P Guo,Y P Guo,A Guskov,S Han,X Q Hao,F A Harris,K L He,F H Heinsius,T Held,Y K Heng,Y R Hou,Z L Hou,H M Hu,J F Hu,T Hu,Y Hu,G S Huang,J S Huang,X T Huang,X Z Huang,N Huesken,T Hussain,W Ikegami Andersson,W Imoehl,M Irshad,Q Ji,Q P Ji,X B Ji,X L Ji,H L Jiang,X S Jiang,X Y Jiang,J B Jiao,Z Jiao,D P Jin,S Jin,Y Jin,T Johansson,N Kalantar-Nayestanaki,X S Kang,R Kappert,M Kavatsyuk,B C Ke,I K Keshk,A Khoukaz,P. Kiese,R Kiuchi,R Kliemt,L Koch,O B Kolcu,B Kopf,M Kuemmel,M Kuessner,A Kupsc,M Kurth,M G Kurth,W Kühn,J S Lange,P. Larin,L Lavezzi,H Leithoff,T Lenz,C Li,Cheng Li,D M Li,F Li,F Y Li,G Li,H B Li,H J Li,J C Li,J W Li,Ke Li,L K Li,Lei Li,P L Li,P R Li,Q Y Li,W D Li,W G Li,X H Li,X L Li,X N Li,X Q Li,Z B Li,Z Y Li,H Liang,Y F Liang,Y T Liang,G R Liao,L Z Liao,J Libby,C X Lin,D X Lin,Y J Lin,B Liu,B J Liu,C X Liu,D Liu,D Y Liu,F H Liu,Fang Liu,Feng Liu,H B Liu,H M Liu,Huanhuan Liu,Huihui Liu,J B Liu,J Y Liu,K Y Liu,Ke Liu,L Y Liu,Q Liu,S B Liu,T Liu,X Liu,X Y Liu,Y B Liu,Z A Liu,Zhiqing Liu,Y. F Long,X C Lou,H J Lu,J D Lu,J G Lu,Y Lu,Y P Lu,C L Luo,M X Luo,P W Luo,T Luo,X L Luo,S Lusso,X R Lyu,F C Ma,H L Ma,L L. Ma,M M Ma,Q M Ma,X N Ma,X X Ma,X Y Ma,Y M Ma,F E Maas,M Maggiora,S Maldaner,S Malde,Q A Malik,A Mangoni,Y J Mao,Z P Mao,S Marcello,Z X Meng,J G Messchendorp,G Mezzadri,J Min,T J Min,R E Mitchell,X H Mo,Y J Mo,C Morales Morales,N Yu Muchnoi,H Muramatsu,A Mustafa,S Nakhoul,Y Nefedov,F Nerling,I B Nikolaev,Z Ning,S Nisar,S L Niu,S L Olsen,Q Ouyang,S Pacetti,Y Pan,M Papenbrock,P Patteri,M Pelizaeus,H P Peng,K Peters,J Pettersson,J L Ping,R G Ping,A Pitka,R Poling,V Prasad,M Qi,T Y Qi,S Qian,C F Qiao,N Qin,X P Qin,X S Qin,Z H Qin,J F Qiu,S Q Qu,K H Rashid,C F Redmer,M Richter,A Rivetti,V Rodin,M Rolo,G Rong,Ch Rosner,M Rump,A Sarantsev,M Savrié,K Schoenning,W Shan,X Y Shan,M Shao,C P Shen,P X Shen,X Y Shen,H Y Sheng,X Shi,X D Shi,J J Song,Q Q Song,X Y Song,S Sosio,C Sowa,S Spataro,F F. Sui,G X Sun,J F Sun,L Sun,S S Sun,X H Sun,Y J Sun,Y K Sun,Y Z Sun,Z J Sun,Z T Sun,Y T Tan,C J Tang,G Y Tang,X Tang,V Thoren,B Tsednee,I Uman,B Wang,B L Wang,C W Wang,D Y Wang,H H Wang,K Wang,L L Wang,L S Wang,M Wang,M Z Wang,Meng Wang,P L Wang,R M Wang,W P Wang,X Wang,X F Wang,X L Wang,Y Wang,Y F Wang,Z Wang,Z G Wang,Z Y Wang,Zongyuan Wang,T Weber,D H Wei,P Weidenkaff,H W Wen,S P Wen,U Wiedner,G Wilkinson,M Wolke,L H Wu,L J Wu,Z Wu,L Xia,Y Xia,S Y Xiao,Y J Xiao,Z J Xiao,Y G Xie,Y H Xie,T Y Xing,X A Xiong,Q L Xiu,G F Xu,L Xu,Q J Xu,W Xu,X P Xu,F Yan,L Yan,W B Yan,W C Yan,Y H Yan,H J Yang,H X Yang,L Yang,R X Yang,S L Yang,Y H Yang,Y X Yang,Yifan Yang,Z Q Yang,M Ye,M H Ye,J H Yin,Z Y You,B X Yu,C X Yu,J S Yu,C Z Yuan,X Q Yuan,Y Yuan,A Yuncu,A A Zafar,Y Zeng,B X Zhang,B Y Zhang,C C Zhang,D H Zhang,H H Zhang,H Y Zhang,J Zhang,J L Zhang,J Q Zhang,J W Zhang,J Y Zhang,J Z Zhang,K Zhang,L Zhang,S F Zhang,T J Zhang,X Y Zhang,Y Zhang,Y H Zhang,Y T Zhang,Yang Zhang,Yao Zhang,Yi Zhang,Yu Zhang,Z H Zhang,Z P Zhang,Z Y Zhang,G Zhao,J W Zhao,J Y Zhao,J Z Zhao,Lei Zhao,Ling Zhao,M G Zhao,Q Zhao,S J Zhao,T C Zhao,Y B Zhao,Z G Zhao,A Zhemchugov,B Zheng,J P Zheng,Y Zheng,Y H Zheng,B Zhong,L Zhou,L P Zhou,Q Zhou,X Zhou,X K Zhou,X R Zhou,Xiaoyu Zhou,Xu Zhou,A N Zhu,J Zhu,K Zhu,K J Zhu,S H Zhu,W J Zhu,X L Zhu,Y C Zhu,Y S Zhu,Z A Zhu,J Zhuang,B S Zou,J H Zou
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.122.232002
2019-01-01
Abstract:We study the $e^+e^-togammaomega J/psi$ process using $11.6 ~rm fb^{-1}$ $e^+ e^-$ annihilation data taken at center-of-mass energies from $sqrt{s}=4.008~rm GeV$ to $4.600~rm GeV$ with the BESIII detector at the BEPCII storage ring. The $X(3872)$ resonance is observed for the first time in the $omega J/psi$ system with a significance of more than $5sigma$. The relative decay ratio of $X(3872)toomega J/psi$ and $pi^+pi^- J/psi$ is measured to be $mathcal{R}=1.6^{+0.4}_{-0.3}pm0.2$, where the first error is statistical and the second systematic (the same hereafter). The $sqrt{s}$-dependent cross section of $e^+e^-togamma X(3872)$ is also measured and investigated, and it can be described by a single Breit-Wigner resonance, referred to as the $Y(4200)$, with a mass of $4200.6^{+7.9}_{-13.3}pm3.0~{rm MeV}/c^2$ and a width of $115^{+38}_{-26}pm12~{rm MeV}$. In addition, to describe the $omega J/psi$ mass distribution above $3.9~rm GeV/c^2$, we need at least one additional Breit-Wigner resonance, labeled as $X(3915)$, in the fit. The mass and width of the $X(3915)$ are measured to be $3926.4pm2.2pm1.2~rm MeV/c^2$ and $3.8pm7.5pm2.6~rm MeV$, or $3932.6pm8.7pm4.7~rm MeV/c^2$ and $59.7pm15.5pm3.7~rm MeV$, respectively, depending on the fit models. The resonant parameters of the $X(3915)$ agree with those of the $Y(3940)$ in $Bto Komega J/psi$ and of the $X(3915)$ in $gammagammatoomega J/psi$ by the Belle and BABAR experiments within errors.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?