Abstract:OBJECTIVE: Federal regulations in the United States require vehicles to meet occupant performance requirements with unbelted test dummies. Removing the test requirements with unbelted occupants might encourage the deployment of seat belt interlocks and allow restraint optimization to focus on belted occupants. The objective of this study is to compare the performance of restraint systems optimized for belted-only occupants with those optimized for both belted and unbelted occupants using computer simulations and field crash data analyses.METHODS: In this study, 2 validated finite element (FE) vehicle/occupant models (a midsize sedan and a midsize SUV) were selected. Restraint design optimizations under standardized crash conditions (U.S.-NCAP and FMVSS 208) with and without unbelted requirements were conducted using Hybrid III (HIII) small female and midsize male anthropomorphic test devices (ATDs) in both vehicles on both driver and right front passenger positions. A total of 10 to 12 design parameters were varied in each optimization using a combination of response surface method (RSM) and genetic algorithm. To evaluate the field performance of restraints optimized with and without unbelted requirements, 55 frontal crash conditions covering a greater variety of crash types than those in the standardized crashes were selected. A total of 1,760 FE simulations were conducted for the field performance evaluation. Frontal crashes in the NASS-CDS database from 2002 to 2012 were used to develop injury risk curves and to provide the baseline performance of current restraint system and estimate the injury risk change by removing the unbelted requirement.RESULTS: Unbelted requirements do not affect the optimal seat belt and airbag design parameters in 3 out of 4 vehicle/occupant position conditions, except for the SUV passenger side. Overall, compared to the optimal designs with unbelted requirements, optimal designs without unbelted requirements generated the same or lower total injury risks for belted occupants depending on statistical methods used for the analysis, but they could also increase the total injury risks for unbelted occupants.CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrated potential for reducing injury risks to belted occupants if the unbelted requirements are eliminated. Further investigations are necessary to confirm these findings.

Re-optimisation of Occupant Restraint System for Chinese Statures by Reducing Airbag Inflator Power

Optimisation study of occupant restraint system concerning variations in occupant size and crash severity in frontal collisions

Optimisation of Occupant Restraint Systems for Autonomous Vehicles in Reclined Postures

Advanced smart airbags: The solution for real-life safety?

Development and Optimization of a New Occupant Restraint System for Improving Mini Vehicle Safety

Multi-Parameter and Multi-Objective Optimization of Occupant Restraint System in Frontal Collision

Adaptive restraint design for a diverse population through machine learning

Numerical and experimental investigations on the behaviour of the sandwiched tube-type airbag

Optimization of Occupant Restraint System Using Machine Learning for THOR-M50 and Euro NCAP

Design of a Head and Neck Restraint System for Use in City Cars

A two degrees of freedom model–based optimization method for occupant restraint systems in vehicle crash

Optimal Restraint Conditions for the Sid-Iis Dummy with Different Objective Functions

Sensitivity Analysis and Interval Multi-Objective Optimization for an Occupant Restraint System Considering Craniocerebral Injury

3D Video Motion Analysis Study on Occupant Protection

Optimal Restraint for the Thoracic Compression of the SID-IIs Crash Dummy Using a Linear Spring-Mass Model

Optimization study of tail-lateral occupant injury and restraint system for an off-road vehicle ramp rollover

Optimizing frontal impact occupant protection systems for passengers seated in wheelchairs

Optimization design of side airbag based on side impact simulation

Elimination of rib stiffness difference for a Hybrid-III dummy in frontal crash test

Does unbelted safety requirement affect protection for belted occupants?

A Study on the Correlation Between Airbag Folding Patterns and the Injury of Out-of-Position Occupants