Looking for the Positives In Negative Interest Rates

Brian Reinbold,Yi Wen

2017-01-01

Abstract:Negative interest rates may seem ludicrous since why would an individual buy a government bond with a negative yield, but this is what a central bank would like you to think. The central bank’s goal is to incentivize agents to shift investments away from government bonds to something more productive economically, thus stimulating the economy.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Negative interest rates: why and how?

Jozef Kisel’ák,Philipp Hermann,Milan Stehlík

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/ms-2017-0040

2017-09-22

Mathematica Slovaca

Abstract:Abstract Interest rates (or nominal yields) can be negative, this is an unavoidable fact which has already been visible during the Great Depression (1929–39). Nowadays we can find negative rates easily by e.g. auditing. Several theoretical and practical ideas how to model and eventually overcome empirical negative rates can be suggested, however, they are far beyond a simple practical realization. In this paper we discuss the dynamical reasons why negative interest rates can happen in the second order differential dynamics and how they can influence the variance and expectation of the interest rate process. Such issues are highly practical, involving e.g. the banking sector and pension securities.

mathematics
On the Normality of Negative Interest Rates

Matheus R. Grasselli,Alexander Lipton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1808.07909

2018-08-24

Abstract:We argue that a negative interest rate policy (NIRP) can be an effect tool for macroeconomic stabilization. We first discuss how implementing negative rates on reserves held at a central bank does not pose any theoretical difficulty, with a reduction in rates operating in exactly the same way when rates are positive or negative, and show that this is compatible with an endogenous money point of view. We then propose a simplified stock-flow consistent macroeconomic model where rates are allowed to become arbitrarily negative and present simulation evidence for their stabilizing effects. In practice, the existence of physical cash imposes a lower bound for interest rates, which in our view is the main reason for the lack of effectiveness of negative interest rates in the countries that adopted them as part of their monetary policy. We conclude by discussing alternative ways to overcome this lower bound , in particular the use of central bank digital currencies.

General Economics,Mathematical Finance
Negative Interest Rate Policies: A Survey

Luis Brandão-Marques,Marco Casiraghi,Gaston Gelos,Güneş Kamber,Roland Meeks

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-economics-080323-042145

IF: 5.97

2024-05-01

Annual Review of Economics

Abstract:This article surveys studies on the impact of central bank negative interest rate policies (NIRP). It reviews recent research on the effects of NIRP on financial markets, banks, households, firms, and the macroeconomy. Overall, policy rate cuts when interest rates are negative propagated along the yield curve, with the first policy cut below zero contributing significantly to the fall in longer-term yields. Lending and deposit rates also decreased following the adoption of NIRP. Based on the experience so far, bank lending volumes rose, and bank profits did not significantly deteriorate, although there was considerable heterogeneity in the effects. The impact of NIRP on inflation and output appears to have been comparable to that of conventional interest rate cuts.

economics
Optimal Monetary Policy under Negative Interest Rate

Feng Dong,Yi Wen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.20955/wp.2017.019

2017-01-01

Abstract:In responding to the extremely weak global economy after the financial crisis in 2008, many industrial nations have been considering or have already implemented negative nominal interest rate policy. This situation raises two important questions for monetary theories: (i) Given the widely held doctrine of the zero lower bound on nominal interest rate, how is a negative interest rate (NIR) policy possible? (ii) Will NIR be effective in stimulating aggregate demand? (iii) Are there any new theoretical issues emerging under NIR policies? This article builds a model to show that (i) money injections can remain effective even when the nominal bank lending rate has reached zero or become negative; (ii) it is a good policy to keep the nominal interest rate as low as possible by purchasing government bonds with money; and (iii) the conventional wisdom on the notion of the liquidity trap and the Fisherian decomposition between the nominal and real interest rate can be invalid.
DIVISION Working Paper Series Optimal Monetary Policy under Negative Interest Rate

Feng Dong

2017-01-01

Abstract:In responding to the extremely weak global economy after the nancial crisis in 2008, many industrial nations have been considering or have already implemented negative nominal interest rate policy. This situation raises two important questions for monetary theories: (i) Given the widely held doctrine of the zero lower bound on nominal interest rate, how is a negative interest rate (NIR) policy possible? (ii) Will NIR be e¤ective in stimulating aggregate demand? (iii) Are there any new theoretical issues emerging under NIR policies? This article builds a model to show that (i) money injections can remain e¤ective even when the nominal bank lending rate has reached zero or become negative; (ii) it is a good policy to keep the nominal interest rate as low as possible by purchasing government bonds with money; and (iii) the conventional wisdom on the notion of the liquidity trap and the Fisherian decomposition between the nominal and real interest rate can be invalid.
How to handle negative interest rates in a CIR framework

Marco Di Francesco,Kevin Kamm

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40324-021-00267-w

2021-10-04

SeMA Journal

Abstract:Abstract In this paper, we propose a new model to address the problem of negative interest rates that preserves the analytical tractability of the original Cox–Ingersoll–Ross (CIR) model without introducing a shift to the market interest rates, because it is defined as the difference of two independent CIR processes. The strength of our model lies within the fact that it is very simple and can be calibrated to the market zero yield curve using an analytical formula. We run several numerical experiments at two different dates, once with a partially sub-zero interest rate and once with a fully negative interest rate. In both cases, we obtain good results in the sense that the model reproduces the market term structures very well. We then simulate the model using the Euler–Maruyama scheme and examine the mean, variance and distribution of the model. The latter agrees with the skewness and fat tail seen in the original CIR model. In addition, we compare the model’s zero coupon prices with market prices at different future points in time. Finally, we test the market consistency of the model by evaluating swaptions with different tenors and maturities.
Life Below Zero: Bank Lending Under Negative Policy Rates

Florian Heider,Farzad Saidi,Glenn Schepens

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2788204

2017-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We show that negative policy rates affect the supply of bank credit in a novel way. Banks are reluctant to pass on negative rates to depositors, which increases the funding cost of high-deposit banks, and reduces their net worth, relative to low-deposit banks. As a consequence, the introduction of negative policy rates by the European Central Bank in mid-2014 leads to more risk taking and less lending by euro-area banks with greater reliance on deposit funding. Our results suggest that negative rates are less accommodative, and could pose a risk to financial stability, if lending is done by high-deposit banks.
Central bank digital currency and the effectiveness of negative interest rate policy: A DSGE analysis

Baogui Xin,Kai Jiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ribaf.2023.101901

IF: 6.5

2023-02-11

Research in International Business and Finance

Abstract:Implementing a negative interest rate policy (NIRP) in the traditional fiat system is less effective than desired because of the zero lower bound (ZLB) constraint on interest rates and the cash barrier. Would this problem be solved if a new form of currency was introduced, i.e., central bank digital currency (CBDC), in the economy? To answer this question, we construct a dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) model to analyze the effectiveness of NIRP upon the introduction of CBDC. The results suggest that: (i) The CBDC can eliminate the ZLB constraint and stabilize the economic fluctuations caused by NIRP. (ii) The central bank can implement NIRP by directly adjusting the interest rate of digital currency to stimulate consumption, investment, and output and to accelerate macroeconomic recovery. (iii) Welfare analysis shows that the central bank can effectively choose different NIRP rules according to the economic objectives.

business, finance
Negative interest rate policy and banks' earnings management

Whelsy Boungou,Francis Osei-Tutu,Daniel Taylor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econlet.2024.111632

IF: 1.469

2024-03-12

Economics Letters

Abstract:Using bank-level data from 35 OECD countries over the period 2011-2018, we examine the impact of the introduction of negative interest rate policy (NIRP) on banks' earnings management. Overall, our findings underscore the unintended positive consequence of unconventional economic policy and austerity measures aimed at stimulating the economy on the earnings quality of banks.

economics
Monetary Policy in a Low Interest Rate Environment: Reversal Rate and Risk-Taking

Florian Heider,Agnese Leonello

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3934741

2021-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:This paper develops a simple analytical framework to study the impact of central bank policy-rate changes on banks’ credit supply and risk-taking incentives. Unobservable expost bank monitoring of loans creates an external-financing constraint, which determines bank leverage. Unobservable, costly ex-ante screening of borrowers determines the level of bank risk-taking. More risk-taking tightens the external-financing constraint. The policy rate affects the external-financing constraint because it affects both the return on outside investors’ alternative investments and loan rates. In a low rate environment, a policy-rate cut reduces bank funding costs less because of a zero lower bound (ZLB) on retail deposit rates. Bank risk-taking is a necessary but not sufficient for a policy-rate cut to become contractionary ("reversal"). Reversal can occur even though banks’ net-interest margins increase. Credit market competition plays an important role for the interplay of monetary policy and financing stability. When banks have market power, a policy-rate cut can increase lending and still lead to risk-taking. We use our analytical framework to discuss the literature on how monetary policy affects the credit supply of banks, with special emphasis on low and negative rates.
Bank lending policies and monetary policy: some lessons from the negative interest era

Oscar Arce,Miguel García-Posada,Sergio Mayordomo,Steven Ongena

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/epolic/eiae001

2024-01-10

Economic Policy

Abstract:Abstract What is the long-term impact of negative interest rates on bank lending? To answer this question, we construct a unique summary measure of negative rate exposure by individual banks based on exclusive survey data and banks’ balance sheets and couple it with the credit register of Spain and firms’ balance sheets to identify this impact on the supply of credit to firms. We find that only when deposit rates reached the zero lower bound did affected banks (relative to non-affected banks) decrease their supply, especially when undercapitalized and lending to risky firms. The adverse effects of the negative rates on banks’ intermediation capacity only took place after a protracted period of time.

economics
The Reversal Interest Rate

Joseph Abadi,Markus Brunnermeier,Yann Koby

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20190150

IF: 10.7

2023-08-01

American Economic Review

Abstract:The reversal interest rate is the rate at which accommodative monetary policy reverses and becomes contractionary for lending. We theoretically demonstrate its existence in a macroeconomic model featuring imperfectly competitive banks that face financial frictions. When interest rates are cut too low, further monetary stimulus cuts into banks’ profit margins, depressing their net worth and curtailing their credit supply. Similarly, when interest rates are low for too long, the persistent drag on bank profitability eventually outweighs banks’ initial capital gains, also stifling credit supply. We quantify the importance of this mechanism within a calibrated New Keynesian model. (JEL E12, E32, E43, E44, E52, G21, L25)

economics
Pricing American options under negative rates

Jherek Healy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21314/JCF.2021.004

2021-09-30

Abstract:This paper starts by defining the criteria where the early-exercise of an American option is never optimal, under positive, or negative rates. It follows with a short analysis of the various shapes of the exercise region under negative interest rates. It then presents a new integral equation, which establishes the option price, and the two early exercise boundaries, under negative rates. It shows how to solve this new equation, through modifications of the modern and efficient algorithm of Andersen and Lake, from the initial guess of the two boundaries to more subtle changes required in their fixed point method for stability. Finally, the performance and accuracy of the resulting algorithm is assessed against a cutting edge finite difference method implementation.

Pricing of Securities,Computational Finance
The Transmission of Negative Nominal Interest Rates in Finland

Simon Kwan,Mauricio Ulate,Ville Voutilainen,,,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.24148/wp2023-11

2023-04-20

Abstract:Despite the implementation of negative nominal interest rates by several advanced economies in the last decade and the many papers that have been written about this novel policy tool, there is still much we do not know about the effectiveness of this instrument. The pass-through of negative policy rates to loan rates is one of the main points of contention. In this paper, we analyze the pass-through of the ECB’s changes in the deposit facility rate to mortgage rates in Finland between 2005 and 2020. We use monthly data and three different empirical methodologies: correlational event studies, high-frequency identification, and exposure-measure regressions. We provide robust evidence that there continues to be pass-through of a cut in the policy rate to mortgage rates even when the policy rate is in negative territory, but that this pass-through is smaller than when the policy rate is in positive territory. The evidence in this paper contrasts with some previous studies and provides moments that can be useful to discipline theoretical negative-rates models.
The Deflationary Bias of the ZLB and the FED's Strategic Response

ADRIAN PENALVER,DANIELE SIENA

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jmcb.13140

IF: 1.963

2024-03-02

Journal of money credit and banking

Abstract:The paper shows, in a simple analytical framework, the existence of a deflationary bias in an economy with a low natural rate of interest, a zero lower bound (ZLB) constraint on nominal interest rates and a discretionary Central Bank (CB) with an inflation mandate. The presence of the ZLB prevents the CB from offsetting negative shocks to inflation whereas it can offset positive shocks. This asymmetry pushes average inflation below the target which in turn drags down inflation expectations and reinforces the likelihood of hitting the ZLB. We show that this deflationary bias is particularly relevant for a CB with a symmetric dual mandate (i.e., minimizing deviations from inflation and employment), especially when facing demand shocks. But a strict inflation targeter cannot escape the suboptimal deflationary equilibrium either. The deflationary bias can be mitigated by targeting "shortfalls" instead of "deviations" from maximum employment and/or using flexible average inflation targeting. However, changing monetary policy strategy risks inflation expectations becoming entrenched above the target if the natural interest rate increases.

economics,business, finance
BEN BERNANKE AND THE ZERO BOUND

Laurence Ball

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/coep.12103

IF: 1.212

2015-03-18

Contemporary Economic Policy

Abstract:From 2000 to 2003, when Ben Bernanke was a professor and then a Fed Governor, he wrote extensively about monetary policy at the zero bound on interest rates. He advocated aggressive stimulus policies, such as a money‐financed tax cut and an inflation target of 3%–4%. Yet, after U.S. interest rates hit zero in 2008, the Fed under Chairman Bernanke took more cautious actions. This paper asks when and why Bernanke changed his mind about zero‐bound policy. The answer, at one level, is that he was influenced by analysis from the Fed staff that was presented at the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting of June 2003. This answer raises another question: why did the staff's views influence Bernanke so strongly? I seek answers to this question in the social psychology literature on group decision‐making. (JEL E52, E58)

economics,public administration
Ultra-Low Interest Rates: Risk Measurement/Assessment and Macroprudential Political Economy

Rainer Masera

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3537508

2020-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:After recalling the quantitative relevance as of end-2019 of “new normal” ultra-low interest rates at world level, a brief discussion is offered of key areas of economic analysis and policy critically impacted by negative nominal interest rates. Specific reference is made to the following points. Risk modelling/measurement and the Basel risk-weighted capital framework. The operational viability of banks and insurance companies and the growth of leveraged loans. The liquidity trap revisited and the risk of illiquidity. Secular stagnation and the savings glut: the role of monetary policy. Political economy in the EA: a macro-prudential network perspective to prevent systemic risk. The case for infrastructure investment. On the basis of the arguments presented, it is argued, in the concluding remarks, that the costs of prolonged primary reliance on monetary expansion and sub-zero interest rates outweigh the benefits. A more balanced policy approach is outlined, with a view to improving the functioning of the Eurozone, enlarging the policy space, and reducing financial vulnerabilities.
Negative Interest Rates and Its Impact on GDP, FDI and Banks’ Financial Performance: The Cases of Switzerland and Sweden

Petr Wawrosz,Semen Traksel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ijfs11020069

2023-05-17

International Journal of Financial Studies

Abstract:The article deals with the issue of how negative interest rate policies, introduced in the second decade of the 21st century in some countries, affect certain macroeconomic indicators and bank performance. We concentrate specifically on Switzerland and Sweden. We use correlation analysis to reveal the relationship between interest rates and GDP, the level of foreign direct investment (FDI) and some indicators of banks’ performance. We found that negative interest rates (NIRs) are strongly correlated with the level of GDP in both Switzerland and Sweden but that they do not affect their FDI. The share of banks ́ deposits in GDP is also strongly correlated with NIR. Other indicators of bank performance do not show a strong correlation for both countries. Our evidence is consistent with NIR not being associated with undesirable effects concerning economic growth and bank performance in Switzerland and Sweden. The value of FDI depends on many factors—mainly on the attractiveness of a country for foreign investors in terms of its political and economic stability and by general conditions for business operation.
Central Bank Independence at Low Interest Rates

BENJAMÍN GARCÍA,ARSENIOS SKAPERDAS

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jmcb.13222

IF: 1.963

2024-10-26

Journal of money credit and banking

Abstract:We create a new measure of the political pressure faced by the Federal Reserve based on the analysis of transcripts of the Chairs' testimonies to Congress. We find that the use of nontraditional policies at low interest rates led to increased political criticism and that criticism predicts legislative actions that threaten central bank independence. We develop a model where the probability of the monetary authority's future loss of independence is increasing in the use of nontraditional instruments, leading to attenuated monetary responses and higher inflation volatility. This attenuation can be mitigated under an institutional framework with clearly defined targets where the central bank is evaluated by how efficiently it achieves its goals.

economics,business, finance
Expansionary Yet Different: Credit Supply and Real Effects of Negative Interest Rate Policy

Margherita Bottero,Camelia Minoiu,Jose-Luis Peydro,Andrea Polo,Andrea Presbitero,Enrico Sette

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3612936

2020-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We show that negative interest rate policy (NIRP) has expansionary effects on bank credit supply— and the real economy —through a portfolio rebalancing channel, and that, by shifting down and flattening the yield curve, NIRP differs from rate cuts just above the zero lower bound. For identification, we exploit ECB’s NIRP and matched administrative datasets— including the credit register— from Italy, severely hit by the Eurozone crisis. NIRP affects banks with higher ex-ante net short-term interbank positions or, more broadly, more liquid balance-sheets. NIRP-affected banks rebalance their portfolios from liquid assets to lending, especially to ex-ante riskier and smaller firms—without higher ex-post delinquencies—and cut loan rates (even to the same firm), inducing sizable firm-level real effects. By contrast, there is no evidence of a retail deposits channel associated with NIRP.

Looking for the Positives In Negative Interest Rates

Negative interest rates: why and how?

On the Normality of Negative Interest Rates

Negative Interest Rate Policies: A Survey

Optimal Monetary Policy under Negative Interest Rate

DIVISION Working Paper Series Optimal Monetary Policy under Negative Interest Rate

How to handle negative interest rates in a CIR framework

Life Below Zero: Bank Lending Under Negative Policy Rates

Central bank digital currency and the effectiveness of negative interest rate policy: A DSGE analysis

Negative interest rate policy and banks' earnings management

Monetary Policy in a Low Interest Rate Environment: Reversal Rate and Risk-Taking

Bank lending policies and monetary policy: some lessons from the negative interest era

The Reversal Interest Rate

Pricing American options under negative rates

The Transmission of Negative Nominal Interest Rates in Finland

The Deflationary Bias of the ZLB and the FED's Strategic Response

BEN BERNANKE AND THE ZERO BOUND

Ultra-Low Interest Rates: Risk Measurement/Assessment and Macroprudential Political Economy

Negative Interest Rates and Its Impact on GDP, FDI and Banks’ Financial Performance: The Cases of Switzerland and Sweden

Central Bank Independence at Low Interest Rates

Expansionary Yet Different: Credit Supply and Real Effects of Negative Interest Rate Policy