A Simple Game Theoretical Analysis for Incentivizing Multi-Modal Transportation in Freight Supply Chains
Zhuzhu Song,Wansheng Tang,Ruiqing Zhao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2019.10.048
IF: 6.4
2020-01-01
European Journal of Operational Research
Abstract:Multi-modal transportation, as a highly efficient approach, can economize many intermediate links in the supply chain and save social operating costs. However, at present, multi-modal transportation accounts for only a small portion of the total traffic volume, and there are few multi-modal carriers. To analyze the incentives of ocean shipping companies to provide multi-modal transportation, this paper considers a freight supply chain composed of two upstream ocean shipping companies and two downstream railway transportation companies. After depicting a Nash game between the two competing ocean shipping companies in terms of whether to integrate downstream railway transportation services to provide multi-modal transportation, we analyze the performance of the participants in sub-games for each integration strategy. The results indicate that regardless of competitor behavior, ocean shipping companies may have an incentive to provide multi-modal transportation. Although the two ocean shipping companies are unlikely to agree on the optimal strategy, the only effective equilibrium they can achieve is both providing multi-modal transportation. Moreover, in this equilibrium, the supply chain's profit, consumer utility and social welfare are likely to be maximized. In addition, although the provision of multi-modal transportation will attract more shippers to the market, whether more shippers can ultimately be retained depends on the integration efficiency and competitive intensity. (C) 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.