Abstract:Problem definition: In a supply network consisting of a buyer, a purchasing agent, and a supplier, the buyer can procure the component from the supplier directly and rely on the purchasing agent for complementary services (named direct sourcing (DS)) or authorize the purchasing agent to conduct both procurement and complementary services (named agent sourcing (AS)). When parties bargain pairwisely, how do their bargaining powers influence the equilibrium procurement outsourcing structure? Academic/practical relevance: Both outsourcing structures, DS and AS are commonly observed in practice, whereas the literature has rarely answered the questions that we ask. Methodology: We adopt the generalized Nash bargaining framework to model the negotiations among the parties and derive the corresponding equilibrium outcomes under both outsourcing structures by taking into consideration the existence of a component spot market. Results: When two parties negotiate directly, we define their direct negotiation coefficient as the ratio of their exogenous bilateral relative bargaining powers. If they negotiate indirectly through a third party, we define their indirect negotiation coefficient as the quotient of their respective direct negotiation coefficients with respect to the third party. We show that when parties negotiate over both wholesale prices and quantities, the buyer's preference for DS and AS solely depends on the comparison result of the buyer's direct negotiation coefficient versus the indirect one with respect to the supplier. When the quantity is determined by the buyer and parties negotiate over wholesale prices, the equilibrium outsourcing structure hinges critically upon the magnitude of the purchasing agent's relative bargaining power over the supplier. Interestingly, the preferences of the three parties for DS and AS may be aligned with each other. We also show that it is in the best interest of the buyer to negotiate prices only. Managerial implications: Our research identifies the endogenous bargaining powers among parties that dictate the equilibrium outsourcing structure. It indicates that the buyer needs to adjust procurement outsourcing decisions accordingly when the bargaining powers of the buyer's upstream partners are altered, especially when the buyer's bargaining power is sufficiently large: we analytically show that the buyer's preference is very sensitive to the relative bargaining powers of the purchasing agent and the supplier. This might help explain why Walmart switched from AS with Li & Fung to DS within just three years.

Aligning Purchasing Portfolio Management with Sourcing Negotiation Styles

Process Model and Operational Pattern of Strategic Purchasing

THINKING DIFFERENTLY ABOUT PURCHASING PORTFOLIOS: AN ASSESSMENT OF SUSTAINABLE SOURCING

Direct Sourcing or Agent Sourcing? Contract Negotiation in Procurement Outsourcing

An integrated approach for supplier selection and purchasing decisions

Chinese purchasing managers' preferences and trade-offs in supplier selection and performance evaluation

The Effect of Ethical Leadership on Purchasers’ Unethical Behavior in China: the Moderating Role of Ethical Ideology

The Effect of Supplier Development on Outsourcing Performance: the Mediating Roles of Opportunism and Flexibility

Buyer's Commitment Tactic in Supply Chain Multilateral Negotiation

Portfolio Analysis in Procurement Contract Management

A Portfolio Strategy Design for Human-Computer Negotiations in e-Retail

A Negotiation Optimization Strategy of Collaborative Procurement with Supply Chain Based on Multi-Agent System

A Model for Strategic Supplier Selection

Study on Product Quality Cooperative Control Based on Different Negotiating Strategies

Markovian Negotiation Strategies in Supply Chain Multilateral Negotiation

A Behavioral Study of Supply Manager Decision-Making: Factors Influencing Make Versus Buy Evaluation

Negotiating Wisely: Considerations Based on MCDM/MAUT.

Conflict Management Strategies and Their Relationships with Exchange Performance in Supply Chains

Practices and strategies for global sourcing and supply chain management: a Pareto analysis and MOORA a mixed method approach

Examining the dynamics of bargaining power in buyer-supplier negotiations: insights from a case study in the German automotive industry

Model for negotiating prices and due dates with suppliers in make-to-order supply chains