Abstract:Recent US studies such as Baby's First Years have again demonstrated that unconditional cash transfers and guaranteed income do not lead to significant improvements in the health, economic status, and well-being of individuals living in poverty. In this perspective article we review the emerging literature on this topic and offer explanations for the observed outcomes. We then apply the theory and empirical evidence on marginalization-related diminished returns (MDRs) also called minorities diminished returns (MDRs) to elucidate the weak or null effects of cash transfers in the lives of marginalized populations. According to the MDR theory, marginalization not only reduces access to resources but also reduces their utility. Individuals who experience long-term poverty and marginalization exhibit smaller than expected benefits from new resources, such as cash, in adulthood. This is due to the deeply entrenched structural barriers and systemic discrimination that persist throughout their lives. The existing literature suggests that socioeconomic changes in adulthood have limited impact on the health and well-being of populations that have been raised in poverty. This is because the advantages of increased socioeconomic status (SES) are often undermined by ongoing marginalization and limited access to supportive resources and opportunities. As a result, simply providing cash transfers is insufficient to create substantial and lasting improvements in the lives of those living in poverty. To address these challenges, we recommend a multifaceted approach that includes childhood poverty prevention, interventions aimed at reducing marginalization, and comprehensive multi-sector strategies. By focusing on early intervention and addressing the root causes of poverty and marginalization, we can create more effective and sustainable solutions to improve health and well-being among disadvantaged populations. This holistic approach recognizes the complexity of poverty and the necessity of addressing both immediate needs and long-term structural barriers to achieve meaningful change.

“Feeling Less Than a Second Class Citizen”: Examining the Emotional Consequences of Poverty in New York City

Reconstructing Poverty-Related Shame among Urban Seniors in China: an Exploration of Their Narrated Experiences and a Reflection on Anti-Poverty Interventions

Feeling ashamed - invasive and protective forms of social communication

Perceiving and Deflecting Everyday Poverty-Related Shame: Evidence from 35 Female Marriage Migrants in Rural China

The Stigmatization of Poverty as a Basis of the Class Prejudice and Its Psychological Consequences

From criticality to shame: Childhood memories of social class and how they matter to elementary school teachers and teaching

Chronic Shame: Emotional Navigation Through Segregation, Migration, and Ethnic Phobia

Subjective Experiences of Older Adults in Poverty in Urban China and the Role of Social Policy

Faces of Shame: Implications for Self-Esteem, Emotion Regulation, Aggression, and Well-Being

“I Have Always thought that, If I Am Poor, I’m Also Supposed to Study Poorly”

The Psychology of Poverty: Evidence from the Field

Lower Social Class Does Not (Always) Mean Greater Interdependence

Those who were born poor: A qualitative study of Philippine poverty.

Testing the associations between poverty stigma and mental health: The role of received stigma and perceived structural stigma

Subjective Social Status and Mental Health in Black Adolescents Living in Poverty

Perceived Poverty and Life Satisfaction in College Students with Impoverished Backgrounds: The Mediating Role of Self-Esteem

Handing Money to the Poor Is Never Enough: The Impact of Marginalization-Related Diminished Returns

Poverty and inequality in real-world schizophrenia: a national study

Othering and agency erosion of older adults living in extreme poverty in Bangladesh

Shame in social interaction: Descriptions of experiences of shame by participants with high or low levels of narcissistic traits

Emotional Compliance and Emotion as Resistance: Shame and Anger among the Long-Term Unemployed