Further Steps in Integrating the Platforms of WoS and Scopus: Historiography with HistCite™ and Main-Path Analysis

Loet Leydesdorff,Andreas Thor,Lutz Bornmann
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3145/epi.2017.jul.10
2017-01-01
Abstract:The program HistCite (TM) enables an analyst to identify significant works on a given topic using the citation links between them diachronically. However, using Scopus data for drawing historiograms with HistCite (TM) has hitherto been a problem. In the new version of the program CRExplorer, one can translate citation data from Scopus to WoS formats (or vice versa) and then import the data into HistCite (TM). In this brief communication, we demonstrate these options using the papers of Eugene Garfield (1925-2017) in Scopus for main-path analysis. The two historiograms are considerably different: unlike the WoS set, the networked connections between the time lines are sparse in the representation of the Scopus data; the secondary documents (e.g., editorials in Current Contents) not processed in Scopus, but included in WoS enrich the representation. Furthermore, HistCite (TM) has an option to export the citation network as a Pajek file that can be read by most network analysis and visualization programs. Garfield's texts are centered by him as a personality and entrepreneur in different domains more than intellectually, although there are a number of recurring themes. Our own main paths are shaped along a line along which components indicate longer-term projects.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?