Meijie Jingji Yu Zhongguo Jingji [media Economy and Chinese Economy]
Jia Dai
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17544750.2011.640541
IF: 3.698
2012-01-01
Chinese Journal of Communication
Abstract:splits among journalists, preventing this potential social class from rising. In Chapter 5, Wang turns to the main characteristics of journalistic labor, which evolve hand in hand with the process of commodification. He considers demographic changes such as age, gender, education, socioeconomic status, and working conditions. Moreover, changes in journalists’ autonomous consciousness, especially in terms of political ideology, are also examined. Overall, Wang makes an important theoretical contribution. Indeed, his theoretical reflections are probably stronger than his compilation and analysis of empirical evidence. Yet the book has some limitations. The author tries to use “labor” as the theme to integrate the whole volume. But readers may still see the book as somewhat fragmented. The concept of labor contains too many meanings. In the book, it sometimes refers to labor processes, while at other occasions it refers to labor relations, labor constraints, or labor commodification. Due to the lack of definitional clarity, the analysis seems ambiguous and unfocused, which adds to the difficulty of reading. At a theoretical level, the core concepts of Marxist labor research – such as alienation, deprivation, surplus value, formation of class – all appear in different parts of the book. But regrettably, they never become thematic enough for the book as a whole. This obscures the core content of the book and reduces its strength of critique, which remains purely theoretical and empirically fragmented. The book provokes serious thinking, which probably leads to more questions than answers. There are so many questions about labor that deserve future exploration: how is the class consciousness of journalist labor, and of knowledge labor more broadly speaking, developing under historical circumstances? What about the relationship between journalistic labor and the working classes of other information industry sectors in China, i.e., the so-called “bottom-level labor (diceng laogong)” and “peasant workers (nongminggong)”? Are labor control and alienation more serious in media organizations than in other sectors? Is there any difference between state-owned or party-owned capital, a peculiar factor of Chinese characteristics, and private capital in terms of their operational logic?