Abstract:Accurate identification of urban waterlogging areas and assessing waterlogging susceptibility are crucial for preventing and controlling hazards. Data-driven models are utilized to forecast waterlogging areas by establishing intricate relationships between explanatory variables and waterlogging states. This approach tackles the constraints of mechanistic models, which are frequently complex and unable to incorporate socio-economic factors. Previous research predominantly employed single-type data-driven models to predict waterlogging locations and evaluation of their effectiveness. There is a scarcity of comprehensive performance comparisons and uncertainty analyses of different types of models, as well as a lack of interpretability analysis. The chosen study area was the central area of Beijing, which is prone to waterlogging. Given the high manpower, time, and economic costs associated with collecting waterlogging information, the waterlogging point distribution map released by the Beijing Water Affairs Bureau was selected as labeled samples. Twelve factors affecting waterlogging susceptibility were chosen as explanatory variables to construct Random Forest (RF), Support Vector Machine with Radial Basis Function (SVM-RBF), Particle Swarm Optimization-Weakly Labeled Support Vector Machine (PSO-WELLSVM), and Maximum Entropy (MaxEnt). The utilization of diverse single evaluation indicators (such as F-score, Kappa, AUC, etc.) to assess the model performance may yield conflicting results. The Distance between Indices of Simulation and Observation (DISO) was chosen as a comprehensive measure to assess the model's performance in predicting waterlogging points. PSO-WELLSVM exhibited the highest performance with a DISOtest value of 0.63, outperforming MaxEnt (0.78), which excelled in identifying areas highly susceptible to waterlogging, including extremely high susceptibility zones. The SVM-RBF and RF models demonstrated suboptimal performance and exhibited overfitting. The examination of waterlogging susceptibility distribution maps predicted by the four models revealed significant spatial differences due to variations in computational principles and input parameter complexities. The integration of four WSAMs based on logistic regression has been shown to significantly decrease the uncertainty of a single data-driven model and identify the most flood-prone areas. To improve the interpretability of the data model, a geographical detector was incorporated to demonstrate the explanatory capacity of 12 variables and the process of waterlogging. Building Density (BD) exhibits the highest explanatory power in relation to explain waterlogging susceptibility (Q value = 0.202), followed by Distance to Road, Frequency of Heavy Rainstorms (FHR), DEM, etc. The interaction between BD and FHR results in a nonlinear increase in the explanatory power of waterlogging susceptibility. The presence of waterlogging susceptibility risk in the research area can be attributed to the interactions of multiple factors.

Assessment of Urban Flood Susceptibility Using Semi-Supervised Machine Learning Model

Assessing Surface Water Flood Risks in Urban Areas Using Machine Learning

Urban Flood Susceptibility Mapping Using Remote Sensing, Social Sensing and an Ensemble Machine Learning Model

Urban Flood Risk Assessment through the Integration of Natural and Human Resilience Based on Machine Learning Models

A comparative study on urban waterlogging susceptibility assessment based on multiple data-driven models

Real-Time Flood Disaster Prediction System by Applying Machine Learning Technique

Urban Pluvial Flood Susceptibility Mapping Based on a Novel Explainable Machine Learning Model with Synchronous Enhancement of Fitting Capability and Explainability

Support Vector Machine Model Based on GIS to Evaluation of Flood Risk

Preliminary Discussion on Flood Forecast Model Based on Support Vector Machine

Modeling flood susceptibility using data-driven approaches of naive Bayes tree, alternating decision tree, and random forest methods

Comprehensive evaluation of machine learning algorithms for flood susceptibility mapping in Wardha River sub-basin, India

Assessment of urban flood susceptibility based on a novel integrated machine learning method

Flood risk evaluation of the coastal city by the EWM-TOPSIS and machine learning hybrid method

Extracting historical flood locations from news media data by the named entity recognition (NER) model to assess urban flood susceptibility

Prediction of flood sensitivity based on Logistic Regression, eXtreme Gradient Boosting, and Random Forest modeling methods

Hybrid Models Incorporating Bivariate Statistics and Machine Learning Methods for Flash Flood Susceptibility Assessment Based on Remote Sensing Datasets

Analysis of Short-Term Heavy Rainfall-Based Urban Flood Disaster Risk Assessment Using Integrated Learning Approach

Evaluating Factors Affecting Flood Susceptibility in the Yangtze River Delta Using Machine Learning Methods

Urban waterlogging susceptibility assessment based on hybrid ensemble machine learning models: A case study in the metropolitan area in Beijing, China

Fast Simulation of Urban Waterlogging Based on Multi-Objective Machine Learning Model

A Positive-Unlabeled Learning Algorithm for Urban Flood Susceptibility Modeling