Abstract:Arsenic (As) and cadmium (Cd) accumulation in rice grains is a global food safety issue, and various methods and materials have been used to remove or reduce As and Cd in agricultural soils and rice grains. Despite the availability of synthesized materials capable of simultaneous As and Cd reduction from soil and rice grains, the contributions, efficiency, and main ingredients of the materials for As and Cd immobilization remain unclear. The present study first summarized the biogeochemistry of As and Cd in paddy soils and their transfer in the soil-food-human continuum. We also reviewed a series of reported inorganic and organic materials for simultaneous immobilization of As and Cd in paddy soils, and their reduction efficiency of As and Cd bioavailability were listed and compared. Based on the abovementioned materials, the study conducted a meta-analysis of 38 articles with 2565 observations to quantify the impacts of materials on simultaneous As and Cd reduction from soil and rice grains. Meta-analysis results showed that combining organic and inorganic amendments corresponded to effect sizes of −62.3% and −67.8% on As and Cd accumulation in rice grains, while the effect sizes on As and Cd reduction in paddy soils were −44.2% and −46.2%, respectively. Application of Fe based materials significantly (P < 0.05) reduced As (−54.2%) and Cd (−74.9%), accounting for the highest immobilization efficiency of As and Cd in rice grain among all the reviewed materials, outweighing S, Mn, P, Si, and Ca based materials. Moreover, precipitation, surface complexation, ion exchange, and electrostatic attraction mechanisms were involved in the co-immobilization tactics. The present study underlines the application of combined organic and inorganic amendments in simultaneous As and Cd immobilization. It also highlighted that employing Fe-incorporated biochar material may be a potential strategy for co-mitigating As and Cd pollution in paddy soils and accumulation in rice grains.

Simultaneous Attenuation of Phytoaccumulation of Cd and As in Soil Treated with Inorganic and Organic Amendments.

Remediation of As and Cd Contaminations by Composite Material Additives in Smelting Site Soil

Remediating Cd-Contaminated Soils Using Natural and Chitosan-Introduced Zeolite, Bentonite, and Activated Carbon

Fe-biochar for Simultaneous Stabilization of Chromium and Arsenic in Soil: Rational Design and Long-Term Performance

[Screening of Amendments for Simultaneous Cd and As Immobilization in Soil]

Simultaneous Alleviation of Cadmium and Arsenic Accumulation in Rice by Applying Zero-Valent Iron and Biochar to Contaminated Paddy Soils

Simultaneous Mitigation of Cd and As Availability in Soil-Rice Continuum Via the Addition of an Fe-based Desulfurization Material.

Effects of Combined Applications of S-nZVI and Organic Amendments on Cadmium and Arsenic Accumulation in Rice: Possible Mechanisms and Potential Impacts on Soil Health

Simultaneous Reduction of Arsenic and Cadmium Bioavailability in Agriculture Soil and Their Accumulation in Brassica Chinensis L. by Using Minerals.

Combined Amendment Improves Soil Health and Brown Rice Quality in Paddy Soils Moderately and Highly Co-contaminated with Cd and As

A Review of Amendments for Simultaneously Reducing Cd and As Availability in Paddy Soils and Rice Grain Based on Meta-Analysis

Comparison of Four Amendments for Arsenic and Cadmium Combined Contaminated Soil

Remediation of Cd, Pb and As Co-contaminated Paddy Soil by Applying Different Amendments

Combined Effect Of Ferrous Ion And Biochar On Cadmium And Arsenic Accumulation In Rice

In-situ Immobilization of Cadmium-Polluted Upland Soil: A Ten-Year Field Study

Effects of different soil amendments on the immobilization and remediation of cadmium and arsenic in soil

A review of amendments for simultaneously reducing Cd and As availability in paddy soils and rice grain based on meta-analysis.

[Simultaneous Immobilization of Arsenic, Lead, and Cadmium in Paddy Soils Using Two Iron-based Materials]

Mitigation of Rice Cadmium (cd) Accumulation by Joint Application of Organic Amendments and Selenium (se) in High-Cd-contaminated Soils.

Combined remediation effects of biochar, zeolite and humus on Cd-contaminated weakly alkaline soils in wheat farmland

Efficiency of Lime, Biochar, Fe Containing Biochar and Composite Amendments for Cd and Pb Immobilization in a Co-Contaminated Alluvial Soil.