Abstract:Dear Editor: We read with great interest your recent publication of the article by Markolf et al. In their study, they measured the distal fibular forces and displacements under different biomechanical circumstances and concluded that screw size and number of engaged tibial cortices had no significant effect on mechanical stability of the distal fibula. They performed a good study. However, there are some concerns regarding this study. First, in the introduction of their article, the authors stated that syndesmotic screw fixation provides the best anatomical reduction, shortens the healing period, and allows patients to resume weight-bearing more quickly. We don’t think this is a rigorous statement. A recent study from Naqvi et al showed that fixation with TightRope provides a more accurate method of syndesmotic stabilization compared with screw fixation. In their study, 21.7% of the ankles in the syndesmotic screw fixation group had malreduction, whereas none of the TightRope group showed malreduction. Besides, although there was no statistical significance, patients in the TightRope group bore weight much earlier. Second, in their testing, the authors used two screws to fix the syndesmosis after the anterior and posterior inferior tibiofibular ligaments and the interosseous ligament were sectioned, while the interosseous membrane was preserved. As is known, two-screw fixation was usually used to deal with severe syndesmotic injuries resulted from pronation-external rotation (Weber C) injuries, especially for Maisonneuve’s fractures. On the basis of the injury mechanism, the interosseous membrane was usually torn in a Weber C injury. However, in their syndesmotic injury model, the authors kept the interosseous membrane intact. In agreement with other authors, we think that the interosseous membrane could prevent the syndesmosis separating. To some extent, this might be one reason for their result that no significant medial-lateral displacement of the distal fibula was found in the authors’ testing. Third, we would like to know whether the length of the screws would affect the results. For different specimens, the fibular and tibial diameter and the width of the interosseous membrane might be different. Therefore, the screws with different sizes could have been utilized. In addition, the authors stated that the exact penetration depth of the tricortical screws into the tibia varied slightly and the tip of the tricortical screw penetrated to within 1.0 cm of the medial tibial cortex. We would like to know how they identified the penetration depth of the tricortical screws. We speculate that a shallow penetration might lead to a more posterior displacement of distal fibula, while a deep penetration might result in a less posterior displacement of the distal fibula.

Motion of the distal tibiofibular syndesmosis under different loading patterns: A biomechanical study.

Advances in biomechanical studies on syndesmosis

Syndesmosis Fixation Using Dual Screws with Tricortical and Quadricortical Purchase

Impact of syndesmotic injury on the biomechanical stability of ankle joint

Effect of Distal Tibiofibular Destabilization and Syndesmosis Compression on the Flexibility Kinematics of the Ankle Bones: An In Vitro Human Cadaveric Model

Three-dimensional Motions of Distal Syndesmosis During Walking.

Influence of syndesmotic injuries and posterior malleolar ankle fractures on fibula position in the ankle joint: a cadaveric study

PROGRESS IN DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT OF DISTAL TIBIOFIBULAR SYNDESMOSIS INJURY

Experimental Study of Subtalar and Ankle Joint in Hind Foot Motion

Novel Anatomical Reconstruction of Distal Tibiofibular Ligaments Restores Syndesmotic Biomechanics.

Templating of Syndesmotic Ankle Lesions by Use of 3D Analysis in Weightbearing and Nonweightbearing CT

The radiographic study of screw internal fixation for syndesmosis injuries

Syndesmosis Malposition Assessed on Weight-Bearing CT Is Common After Operative Fixation of Intra-articular Distal Tibia Plafond Fracture

Propagation of Syndesmotic Injuries During Forced External Rotation in Flexed Cadaveric Ankles

Operative Exploration and Reduction of Syndesmosis in Weber Type C Ankle Injury

Statistical shape model-based tibiofibular assessment of syndesmotic ankle lesions using weight-bearing CT

Standardized analysis of syndesmosis stability in ankle trauma with an innovative syndesmosis-test-tool: a biomechanical study

Computational evaluation of foot biomechanical response to low energy Lisfranc ligament injury

Intrinsic Kinematics of the Tibiotalar and Subtalar Joints During Human Walking Based on Dynamic Biplanar Fluoroscopy

Influence of unstable ankle fracture (type Weber C), osteosynthesis and syndesmotic transfixation on position of fibula in tibiofibular notch: a cadaveric study

Reliability of the Assessment of Fibular Torsion Relative to Tibia at Syndesmosis using CT Scans