The Brightest UV-selected Galaxies in Protoclusters at Z ∼ 4: Ancestors of Brightest Cluster Galaxies?

Kei Ito,Nobunari Kashikawa,Jun Toshikawa,Roderik Overzier,Masayuki Tanaka,Mariko Kubo,Takatoshi Shibuya,Shogo Ishikawa,Masafusa Onoue,Hisakazu Uchiyama,Yongming Liang,Ryo Higuchi,Crystal Martin,Chien-Hsiu Lee,Yutaka Komiyama,Song Huang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab1f0c
IF: 5.521
2019-01-01
The Astrophysical Journal
Abstract:We present the results of a survey of the brightest UV-selected galaxies in protoclusters. These proto-brightest cluster galaxy (proto-BCG) candidates are drawn from 179 overdense regions of g-dropout galaxies at z similar to 4 from the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program identified previously as good protocluster candidates. This study is the first to extend the systematic study of the progenitors of BCGs from z similar to 2 to z similar to 4. We carefully remove possible contaminants from foreground galaxies and, for each structure, select the brightest galaxy that is at least 1 mag brighter than the fifth-brightest galaxy. We select 63 proto-BCG candidates and compare their properties with those of galaxies in the field and those of other galaxies in overdense structures. The proto-BCG candidates and their surrounding galaxies have different rest-UV color (i - z) distributions to field galaxies and other galaxies in protoclusters that do not host proto-BCGs. In addition, galaxies surrounding proto-BCGs are brighter than those in protoclusters without proto-BCGs. The image stacking analysis reveals that the average effective radius of proto-BCGs is similar to 28% larger than that of field galaxies. The i - z color differences suggest that proto-BCGs and their surrounding galaxies are dustier than other galaxies at z similar to 4. These results suggest that specific environmental effects or assembly biases have already emerged in some protoclusters as early as z similar to 4, and we suggest that proto-BCGs have different star formation histories than other galaxies in the same epoch.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?