Abstract:To project possible future climate change, it is important to understand Earth system response to CO2 removal, a potential key method to limit global warming. Previous studies examined some aspects of Earth system response to different scenarios of CO2 removal, but lacked a systematic analysis of the carbon cycle and climate system response in a consistent modeling framework. We expanded previous studies by using an Earth system model to examine the response of land and ocean carbon cycle, as well as a set of climate variables to idealized scenarios of atmospheric CO2 removal with different removal rates. In the scenarios considered, atmospheric CO2 increases at a rate of 1% per year to four times of its preindustrial level, and then decreases at a rate of 0.5%, 1%, and 2% per year to the preindustrial level. Simulation results show that a reduction of atmospheric CO2 induces CO2 release from both the ocean and terrestrial biosphere, and to keep atmospheric CO2 at a lower level requires the removal of anthropogenic CO2 not only from the atmosphere, but from the ocean and land carbon reservoirs as well. The response of many variables of the Earth system, including temperature, ocean heat content, sea level, deep ocean acidity, and permafrost area and carbon, lags the decrease in atmospheric CO2 ranging from a few years to many centuries. A few centuries after atmospheric CO2 returns to the preindustrial level, sea level is still substantially higher than the preindustrial level, and permafrost continues losing CO2 to the atmosphere. Our study demonstrates that to offset previous positive CO2 emissions by atmospheric CO2 removal does not mean to offset climate consequence of positive CO2 emissions. Rapid and deep reduction in CO2 emissions is key to prevent and limit increasing risks from further warming. Our study provides new insights into the carbon cycle and climate system response to CO2 removal, which would help to assess future climate change and the associated impacts.

The global impacts of US climate policy: a model simulation using GCAM-TU and MAGICC

The Impacts of U.S. Withdrawal from the Paris Agreement on the Carbon Emission Space and Mitigation Cost of China, EU, and Japan under the Constraints of the Global Carbon Emission Space

Effects of the US Withdrawal from Paris Agreement on the Carbon Emission Space and Cost of China and India

The gap report of global climate change mitigation, finance, and governance after the United States declared its withdrawal from the Paris Agreement

U.S. Withdrawal from the Paris Agreement: Reasons, Impacts and China's Response

Modeling of Energy Transformation Pathways under Current Policies, NDCs and Enhanced NDCs to Achieve 2-Degree Target

US Energy-Related Greenhouse Gas Emissions in the Absence of Federal Climate Policy

High-ambition climate action in all sectors can achieve a 65% greenhouse gas emissions reduction in the United States by 2035

Implications of Near-Term Mitigation on China's Long-Term Energy Transitions for Aligning with the Paris Goals

Key uncertainties behind global projections of direct air capture deployment

Global and Regional Climate Responses to National-Committed Emission Reductions under the Paris Agreement

Simulated Carbon Cycle and Earth System Response to Atmospheric CO2 Removal

Impacts and Benefits of State and International Carbon Market Systems to Achieve Emissions Reduction Goals

Modelling Low Carbon Transition and Economic Impacts under SSPs and RCPs Based on GTIMES

Expanding International GHG Emissions Trading: the Role of Chinese and U.S. Participation

Climate Warming Mitigation from Nationally Determined Contributions

Uncertainty of temperature rise under nationally determined contributions and carbon neutral policies

A U.S.‒China Coal Power Transition and the Global 1.5 °C Pathway

An integrated assessment for achieving the 2C target pathway in China by 2030

Climate Change Policies of the Trump Administration and China's Response

Comparison and analysis of mitigation ambitions of Parties' updated Nationally Determined Contributions