Abstract:In everyday life, we mainly solve problems with a conscious solution search (non-insight). However, sometimes a perplexing problem is resolved by a quantum leap in understanding. This phenomenon is known as the Aha! experience (insight). Although insight has a distinct phenomenological and behavioral signature, its driving mechanism remains debated. Weisberg (2015) proposed an integrated theory of insight arguing that insight, like non-insight, mainly depends on conscious, cognitive operations with restructuring as a distinguishing feature of insight. However, only if those operations lead to an impasse, insight is achieved through unconscious processes. We assessed some of the premises of this theory by asking participants (N = 42) to solve 70 word puzzles (CRAT) that can either be solved with insight or non-insight. For each puzzle, participants indicated word puzzle difficulty, solution confidence, solution suddenness, and the experiences of impasse and restructuring. As expected, participants reported higher suddenness of and confidence in insight solutions than non-insightful ones. Surprisingly, we could not corroborate the otherwise consistently reported higher solution accuracy and faster solution speed for insight. Crucially, as suggested by the integrated theory of insight, impasse was not a prerequisite for insight to occur. Although restructuring, indeed, preceded insight solutions more often, it seemed a more general problem-solving skill also applied for non-insight solutions. Moreover, early on, participants reported an increased experience of problem difficulty for puzzles later solved with insight. This ability to report on the solution search of insight demonstrates that, as proposed by the theory, insight involves conscious, cognitive operations.

Defining Insight: A Study Examining Implicit Theories of Insight Experience

Everyday Experience Study:A Unique and Heuristic Research Method

A Research on Insight and Insight Problems

Unpacking Impasse-Related Experience During Insight.

In Search of the 'aha!' Experience: Elucidating the Emotionality of Insight Problem-Solving.

The Aha! moment: Is insight a different form of problem solving?

How to investigate insight: A proposal

What Do We Mean When We Say "Insight"? A Formal Synthesis of Existing Theory

Toward an integrated theory of insight in problem solving

Approaching The Distinction Between Intuition And Insight

Deconstructing the self and reshaping perceptions: An intensive whole-brain 7T MRI case study of the stages of insight during advanced investigative insight meditation

A Review on the Research in the Cognitive Mechanism About Insight

Testing Two Cognitive Theories of Insight

New Advances in the Neural Correlates of Insight: A Decade in Review of the Insightful Brain

Relationships Between Multiple Dimensions of Insight and Neurocognition, Metacognition, and Social Cognition: A Meta-Analysis.

Markers of Insight

Elucidating the nature of linguistic processing in insight

Discovering and developing the “Insight” by opportunity-oriented user research

Tracking the Neurodynamics of Insight: A Meta-Analysis of Neuroimaging Studies

Insight and Affect in the History of Science

Finding the Aha! Moment of Search: A Preliminary Examination of Insight Learning During Search