U-series Disequilibria in Subduction Zone Lavas: Inherited from Subducted Slabs or Produced by Mantle In-Growth Melting?

Fang Huang,Juan Xu,Julin Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemgeo.2016.07.005

IF: 3.9

2016-01-01

Chemical Geology

Abstract:U-series disequilibria of subduction zone lavas have been used to provide temporal constraints on flux transfer in convergent margins. There are debates on whether the disequilibria are inherited from the source modified by slab materials (fluids or sediments) or produced by in-growth melting of the mantle. After filtering out the effect of crustal modification on U-series data, (Ra-226)/(Th-230) is not positively correlated with Sr/Th and Ba/Th in arc basalts with SiO2 <52 wt. This invalidates the key evidence for addition of slab-fluids to the mantle producing Ra-226 excess in subduction zone lavas. Sediment melts with a zircon-free residue may have Pa-231 excess, but it is not consistent with the overwhelming Zr-Hf depletions in subduction zone lavas, which instead require a zircon-saturated residue during sediment melting.With appropriate parameters applied, in-growth melting in the mantle followed by modification in the crust can provide a self-consistent explanation of the U-series disequilibria and the relationships with other geochemical signatures in most subduction zone lavas except the few Tonga-Kermadec lavas with slight Pa-231 deficit. On the basis of melting experiments of hydrous peridotites, we further propose that most mantle-derived melts and thus U-series disequilibria should be mainly produced by melting in the hot zone of the mantle wedge, as controlled by thermal structure of the convergent margins. In order to produce enough short-lived nuclides, the timescales of mass transfer and magmatism in the subduction zone should at least range from a few to a few hundred millennia. Future studies on more lavas, numerical modelling, and partition coefficients of U-series nuclides will help for better application of U-series disequilibria into subduction zone magmatism. (C) 2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.