Executive function characteristics in patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder and patients with schizophrenia
YAN Jun,MENG Gen-Hua,LI Gang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-6729.2012.01.003
2012-01-01
Abstract:Objectives: To compare the characteristics of executive function in patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder(OCD) and patients with schizophrenia(SCH).Methods: It was a cross-sectional study.Twenty-nine outpatients with obsessive-compulsive disorder(OCD),30 outpatients with schizophrenia(SCH),and 30 age-and education-matched normal adults were involved in the study.The diagnosis was made according to the Chinese Classification and Diagnostic Criteria for Mental Disorders,Third Edition(CCMD-3).All subjects finished a series of neuropsychological tests,including the Wisconsin card sorting test(WCST),Trail-making test(TMT),Tower of Hanoi(TH),and Word fluency test(WFT).Results: In WCST,the patients with OCD showed shorter operation time than ones with SCH [(6.8±2.7) vs.(9.8±5.6),P<0.05],but nearly as same as the normal controls [(6.2±2.5),P>0.05].The patients with OCD completed more categories than the ones with SCH [(3.0±2.4) vs.(2.9±2.1),P<0.05],but had no difference with normal controls [(3.2±2.0),P>0.05].The patients with OCD had fewer errors than the ones with SCH [(56.56±24.74) vs.(62.88±22.50),P<0.05],but had no difference with normal controls [(46.37±23.17),P>0.05].In the cards number required for completing the first category of WCST,the patients with OCD needed more cards than the other two groups [(50.52±43.66)vs.(48.80±38.68),(27.31±26.93),P<0.05].In TMT,the patients with OCD had fewer operation times and errors than the ones with SCH [(82.78±33.33),(1.04±2.37) vs.(141.16±84.02),(3.28±4.55);P<0.05],but had no difference with normal control [(83.37±46.64),(1.58±2.90),P>0.05].In TH test,the patients with OCD had no difference with those with SCH in the same actions and errors [(44.6±12.8),(0.8±0.9) vs.(49.0±21.2),(2.0±3.9);P>0.05],but more than normal controls [(38.7±13.9),(0.28±0.59),P<0.05].Conclusion: It suggests that the patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder may have better executive function than those with schizophrenia in general,while may have worse concept understanding.