The Long-Term Outlook for Salmon Returns to Alaska
M. Adkison,B. Finney
Abstract:With the exception of some western Alaska stocks, Alaska’s salmon populations are numerically healthy. However, even fi sheries on abundant stocks are suffering economically due to sharp declines in the value of the catch. The abundance of Alaskan salmon stocks has fl uctuated greatly, both in modern times and prehistorically. These fl uctuations are thought to be caused by multi-decadal changes in environmental conditions over large areas that affect many other species as well as salmon. Forecasts of salmon returns are not very reliable, and the potential for signifi cant improvement in their accuracy is low in the short term. A viable fi shing industry must be able to adapt to dramatic, persistent, and unanticipated changes in harvest levels. Nonetheless, Alaska’s salmon stocks should continue to produce healthy harvests for the foreseeable future, barring signifi cant damage to their habitat either via local activities or global warming. Authors: MILO ADKISON is with the Juneau Center, School of Fisheries and Ocean Sciences, University of Alaska Fairbanks, 11120 Glacier Highway, Juneau, Alaska 99801. Email: Milo.Adkison@uaf.edu. BRUCE FINNEY is with the Institute of Marine Science, School of Fisheries and Ocean Sciences, University of Alaska Fairbanks, P.O. Box 757220, Fairbanks, Alaska 99801. Acknowledgments: Comments by Irene Gregory-Eaves and four anonymous reviewers improved this manuscript. Catch data up to 1970 are from Byerly et al. (1999), after 1970 from tables on ADF&G’s website at <http://www.cf.adfg.state.ak.us/geninfo/fi nfi sh/ salmon/catchval/history/1970-99s.htm>, accessed 7/3/2003. Catch value was obtained from the same location, and adjusted to 2002 dollar equivalents using the consumer price index from the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis at <http://minneapolisfed.org/ research/data/us/calc/hist1913.cfm>, accessed 7/3/2003. Catch and escapement data for Bristol Bay sockeye and for Southeast Alaska pink salmon were obtained from Lowell Fair (ADF&G Commercial Fisheries, Anchorage Alaska, personal communication) and Martina Kallenberger (ADF&G Commercial Fisheries, Douglas, Alaska, personal communication), respectively. We are grateful to Mike Plotnick and Herman Savikko of ADF&G for additional assistance assembling the data used in our analyses. This paper was funded by the Understanding Alaska program, a special series of research studies examining Alaska economic development issues. The studies are being sponsored by the University of Alaska Foundation and carried out by the Institute of Social and Economic Research at the University of Alaska Anchorage. CURRENT STATUS Alaskan salmon returns are generally strong, with recent average statewide catches higher than in most previous decades (Figure 1). The major exception to the general pattern of healthy Pacifi c salmon Oncorhynchus spp. stocks is in western Alaska. This region’s runs have been dismal for almost a decade, often dropping so low that no commercial fi shing is permitted (Figure 2) and even subsistence fi sheries are restricted. Nonetheless, in most regions of the state the perception that salmon runs are failing is not true (Baker et al. 1996; Halupka et al. 2000; Van Alen 2000). Dramatic decreases in the prices paid for salmon due to the development of a large farmed salmon industry plus a weak Japanese economy have resulted in a steep drop in the value of catches (Figure 3) and severe hardship in most of the state’s fi sheries. In some areas, this decrease in prices is exacerbated by a reduction from recent record harvests. For example, Bristol Bay’s sockeye salmon O. nerka runs have fallen from their peak levels in recent decades of sometimes more than 60 million fi sh to just 16 million in 2002 (Figure 4). This remains at about the average seen in the 1960s and early 1970s, when runs of up to 60 million every fi ve years were interspersed with much lower runs (only 3.3 million in 1973). The largest share of the reduction is the failure of the Kvichak River drainage, formerly the region’s largest producer, to contribute appreciable runs during 6 of the last 7 years. Spawners in this system have not even been replacing themselves, in contrast to those in other drainages, including the adjacent Naknek River. Most other regions in Alaska are suffering economically despite having biologically healthy stocks of the commercially important species. One example is the pink salmon O. gorbuscha fi shery in Southeast Alaska. A near-record harvest in 1989 was followed by record-breaking harvests in 1991, 1996, and 1999, while the 2001 harvest was the second largest ever seen (Figure 5). Nonetheless, the value of the catch has been declining despite the increase in the number of fi sh caught (Figure 5).