Abstract:Misunderstandings of preferences are ubiquitous in various types of conflicts, and such misperceptions often involve uncertainty due to the limited cognitive abilities and information asymmetry of decision-makers. This research proposes a novel hypergame analysis approach based on the graph model for conflict resolution to address challenging disputes involving unknown misunderstandings of preferences. Specifically, a first-level hypergame model with two decision-makers is intentionally developed in this study to handle the uncertainty of preference misunderstandings in conflicts. The logical definitions of stabilities in the first-level hypergame are put forward to portray various decision-making behaviors of stakeholders when facing the vagueness of preference misperceptions, and efficiently determine possible resolutions. Algebraic representations of stabilities are also designed for the first time to enhance the computational efficiency of hypergame analyses and facilitate the development of decision support systems. Furthermore, more general definitions of individual and overall equilibria and their algebraic representations are purposefully proposed within the first-level hypergame model. This allows the decision-makers involved in a conflict to hold stable under different solution concepts. Finally, this novel approach is applied to an environmental dispute to demonstrate its practicality in addressing real-world conflicts with uncertain misperceptions of preferences. The case study shows that the uncertainty of preference misunderstandings can affect the optimal strategy selections of decision-makers and result in changes to the equilibria or outcomes of conflicts.

Method of Multistage Military Conflict Decision-Making in Uncertainty Environments

Multi-UAV Counter-Game Model Based on Uncertain Information

Robust Tactical Decision Making for Deep Uncertainty Battlefield Environment

Multiagent Multiobjective Decision Making and Game for Saving Public Resources

On Nash–Stackelberg–Nash games under decision-dependent uncertainties: Model and equilibrium

First-level hypergame for investigating two decision-maker conflicts with unknown misperceptions of preferences within the framework of GMCR

Multi-stage and Multi-Object Decision Making Model under Uncertainty

Multi-agent Task Assignment Based on the Situation Field and Game Theory

A Robust Decision Making Framework for Optimal Strategy Selection in Warfare under Model Uncertainty

Multi-attribute Decision-Making in Wargames Leveraging the Entropy-Weight Method in Conjunction with Deep Reinforcement Learning

Modeling of Military Decision-Making Based on Multi-Agent Influence Diagrams and Games

A Decision Support Framework for Security Resource Allocation under Ambiguity.

Decision-making Method for the Optimal Coordination of Fire and Electronic Warfare Based on Integrative Effectiveness

Robust Optimization based Air Combat Game Decision-making of Multi-UAV with Uncertain Information

Study on air formation to ground attack-defends decision making in fuzzy condition

Solving Multiobjective Game in Multiconflict Situation Based on Adaptive Differential Evolution Algorithm with Simulated Annealing

An approach to warfare command decision making with uncertainty based on set pair analysis

Optimal Decision-Making under Uncertainties

Multidisciplinary Flexible Design and Decision Based on Mixed Game

Study and Simulation of Multi-level Decision-making in Multi-group Air to Ground Attack-defends Campaign

Air combat decision-making of multiple UCAVs based on constraint strategy games