Abstract:In the recent decade, the amount of software runtime logs has increased rapidly and spawned a line of automated log analysis research using machine learning or data mining algorithms. In the typical workflow of log analysis, log parsing, which aims to transform unstructured or semistructured logs into structured logs, is crucial to various downstream algorithms. While the state-of-the-art (SOTA) parsers achieve extremely high accuracy, recent research shows that these parsers are far from being useful under stricter evaluation metrics. Thus, researchers and practitioners are unclear about the current state of log parsing research and what might be important to explore in the future. To this end, we conduct an empirical study to revisit log parsing by running extensive experiments of SOTA parsers on 16 widely used log datasets under five evaluation metrics with different preprocessing settings. Our results show that the performance of log parsers varies significantly under different evaluation metrics. In addition, preprocessing plays an important role in the evaluation. In particular, preprocessing with common regular expressions can cause a 0.38 performance difference in group accuracy, highlighting the importance of reporting preprocessing details in parsing research. We also generalize the word-level regular expressions in preprocessing and try to use them to parse the whole logs, which leads to surprisingly decent accuracy. These results imply that formulating log parsing as a word-level classification task is a feasible future direction. Moreover, we find out that the most widely used dataset (i.e., LogHub) contains labeling errors. To address this issue, we make an extensive manual effort to fix the errors in the log dataset, providing a revised ground truth for future log parsing research. On the revised log dataset, our simple parser (word-level regular expression-based) achieves 0.97 precision-template accuracy on the Spark dataset and an average recall-template accuracy of 0.93 on 16 datasets, which outperforms all existing parsers.

Researches on Large Scale Corpus-Based Syntactic Pattern Matching

Document Parsing Unveiled: Techniques, Challenges, and Prospects for Structured Information Extraction

Build a Large-Scale Syntactically Annotated Chinese Corpus

DAT-MT Accelerated Graph Fusion Dependency Parsing Model for Small Samples in Professional Fields

A Survey of Semantic Parsing Techniques

Exploiting Heterogeneous Treebanks for Parsing.

Chinese Dependency Parsing Based on Treebank

Paraphrase and Parallel Treebank for the Comparison of French and Chinese Syntax

Cross-domain Chinese Sentence Pattern Parsing

Quantitative Research on Chinese Sentences Structure Based on Pattern Grammar

A New Robust and Domain-Oriented Algorithm of Text Parsing

A Large-Scale Evaluation for Log Parsing Techniques: How Far Are We?

Exploiting limited data for parsing

Research on Deep Processing Technologies for Large-Scale Corpora

Learning Programmatic Idioms for Scalable Semantic Parsing

Statistical Decision-Tree Models for Parsing

Revisiting Log Parsing: The Present, the Future, and the Uncertainties

Large-scale Automatic Extraction of Chinese Compound Lexical Cohesion Pairs

Using expression parsing and algebraic operations to generate test sequences.

A Statistical Parsing Framework for Sentiment Classification

Corpus Annotation for Parser Evaluation