Abstract:This paper considers two competing supply chains that face cost uncertainty, each consisting of one supplier and one retailer. To address the uncertain cost information, we propose a decision rule based on confidence levels to measure the goals of the supply chain participants. We provide the new concept of the belief‐degree cost of a supply chain that embodies the decision maker's ability to comprehensively address information uncertainty and control the risk caused by information uncertainty. We find that regardless of which of the three games it is in – integrated, hybrid, or decentralized – a chain should order more and thereby gain more profit when its cost uncertainty increases or the competing chain's cost uncertainty decreases. The chain with a low or sufficiently low belief‐degree cost gains a competitive advantage on both quantity and profit. A chain's competitiveness can be enhanced by either decreasing its confidence level or increasing its rival's confidence level. Furthermore, we demonstrate that supply chain integration is the dominant strategy for given confidence levels. Nevertheless, a prisoner's dilemma occurs when the differences in the belief‐degree costs of the two supply chains are not significant and the competitive intensity is high. In addition, the magnitudes of the confidence levels can be changed to avoid or cause a prisoner's dilemma. Finally, under different confidence levels, the Stackelberg model for competing hybrid or decentralized supply chains is extended to the bargaining model, and the impact of bargaining power on supply chain competition is analyzed.

The Relationship Between Production Capacity and Competitive Advantage under Demand Uncertainty

Strategic choice of flexible production technology using game theory approach

Competitive capacity and price decisions for two build-to-order manufacturers facing time-dependent demands

Supply chain coordination via capacity options with uncertain demand and supply

Consumption Flexibility, Product Configuration, and Market Competition

Decision Bias in Capacity Allocation Games with Uncertain Demand

An Empirical Research on the Relationship between Organizational Flexibility and Sustainable Competitive Advantage on the Perspective of Environmental Uncertainty

Value of operational flexibility in co-production systems with yield and demand uncertainty

Outsourcing strategy and production disruption of supply chain with demand and capacity allocation uncertainties

Robust Optimization of Project Portfolio Selection under Information Uncertainty

Impact of cost uncertainty on supply chain competition under different confidence levels

Capacity optimization and competition with cyclical and lead-time-dependent demands

A Real-Options-based Analysis for Supply Chain Decisions

Supply Chain Games Model with Spot Market

Impact of Capacity Flexibility on Service Product Line Design

Cooperative Advertising in Supply Chain under Demand Uncertainty

Sourcing Competition under Cost Uncertainty and Information Asymmetry

Timing and green decisions for competitive manufacturers under demand uncertainty and risk aversion

CAPACITY COMMITMENT AND PRICING FOR SUBSTITUTABLE PRODUCTS UNDER COMPETITION

Supplier Behavior in Capacity Investment Competition: an Experimental Study

Effects of Quick Response and Market Uncertainty on Product Quality and Firm Profitability