Abstract:This study investigates whether financial analysts correctly weight cash flows, accruals and components of accruals in forecasting future earnings. This examination is in the spirit of Sloan (1996) who documents evidence that investors do not correctly distinguish between the cash flow and accrual components of earnings. We find that analysts do distinguish between accruals and cash flows although they generally underweight the information in both accruals and cash flows. More importantly, we find that analysts do not distinguish between discretionary and non-discretionary accruals even though discretionary accruals are less persistent than non-discretionary accruals. Our findings complement and extend the findings in recent studies on analyst forecast inefficiency with respect to the information in accrual and cash flow components of earnings using alternative research designs [Teoh and Wong (1998), Bradshaw, Richardson and Sloan (2000), Barth and Hutton (2000)]. Analysts are considered to play an important role as information intermediaries in educating investors about the future prospects of firms. They are trained in analyzing financial data and have industry expertise as well as detailed firm-specific knowledge through contacts with managers. Thus, one would expect analysts to correctly incorporate the information in earnings components specifically discretionary versus non-discretionary accruals. Our evidence complements evidence in recent studies that raises questions about the ability of analysts, on-average, to correctly incorporate the information in accruals and cash flows in forecasting future earnings. This in turn implies that other outsiders are also likely to find it difficult to undo earnings management via discretionary accruals and therefore provides a rationale for the existence of earnings management.

Does Earnings Preannouncement Information Impose Effects on the Forecast Behavior of Financial Analysts?

The Effects of Investor Responses to Meeting Consensus Forecasts

Research on Financial Restatement's Effect on Analyst Forecast

Management Earnings Forecasts and Analyst Forecasts: Evidence from Mandatory Disclosure System

The Market Reaction of Earnings Forecasts

A Study on the Effectiveness of Chinese Security Analysts' Earnings Forecasting Behavior

Empirical Research Of The Earnings Persistence Influence On Analyst'S Forecast

Analysts' Incentives and Systematic Forecast Bias

Earnings Components,Persistence Difference and Analysts＇ Earnings Forecasting——Empirical Analysis Based on Chinese A-Listed Companies

Earnings Quality,Institutional Environment,and Analyst Forecasts

The Associations Between Performance Changes of Listed Companies and Analysts’Forecast

Does Environmental Regulation Affect Analyst Forecast Bias? Evidence from China’s Low-Carbon Pilot Policy

Empirical Research on Price Impact of Analyst Earnings Forecast

Does Accounting Conservatism Affect Analysts'Earnings Forecast?——Evidence from Chinese Stock Market

Will the Media Coverage Affect Analysts’ Earnings Forecast Dispersion-Based on the Perspective of Information“Noise”

Investor Attention,Earnings Announcement Effect and Announcement Timing of Management

Do Analysts' Forecasts Fully Reflect the Information in Accruals?

Disclosure Quality and Earnings Forecast

Can Analysts’ Focus on Innovation-Related Information Improve the Accuracy of Forecasts? Chinese Full Text

A Study on How the Earning Forecast Error in Prospectus Affects the Initial Returns——Evidence from China's A-shares IPO Market from 1993 to 2009

Audit Quality and Properties of Analyst Earnings Forecasts