Abstract:Cities are the future. Cities have already created equivalent environmental conditions that are predicted to occur globally in the future, particularly urban warming is decades ahead of the projected global warming. Can we use cities as a surrogate for forecasting phenological responses to future climate warming? We conclude that phenological responses to spatial temperature rise in urban settings cannot substitute for those to temporal temperature rise in their natural counterparts. However, urban environments do provide a real‐world condition and more converged status to understand vegetation phenology response under future warming. Given that already‐observed temperature increase within cities far exceeds the projected global temperature rise by the end of the century, urban environments often offer a unique opportunity for studying ecosystem response to future warming. However, the validity of thermal gradients in space serving as a substitute for those in time is rarely tested. Here, we investigated vegetation phenology dynamics in China's 343 cities and empirically test whether phenological responses to spatial temperature rise in urban settings can substitute for those to temporal temperature rise in their natural counterparts based on satellite‐derived vegetation phenology and land surface temperature from 2003 to 2018. We found prevalent advancing spring phenology with "high confidence" and delaying autumn phenology with "medium confidence" under the context of widespread urban warming. Furthermore, we showed that space cannot substitute for time in predicting phenological shifts under climate warming at the national scale and for most cities. The thresholds of ~11°C mean annual temperature and ~600 mm annual precipitation differentiated the magnitude of phenological sensitivity to temperature across space and through time. Below those thresholds, there existed stronger advanced spring phenology and delayed autumn phenology across the spatial urbanization gradients than through time, and vice versa. Despite the complex and diverse relationships between phenological sensitivities across space and through time, we found that the directions of the temperature changes across spatial gradients were converged (i.e., mostly increased), but divergent through temporal gradients (i.e., increased or decreased without a predominant direction). Similarly, vegetation phenology changes more uniformly over space than through time. These results suggested that the urban environments provide a real‐world condition to understand vegetation phenology response under future warming.

Remotely Sensed Assessment of Urbanization Effects on Vegetation Phenology in China'S 32 Major Cities

Spatial heterogeneity of vegetation phenology caused by urbanization in China based on remote sensing

Urbanization Imprint on Land Surface Phenology: the Urban–rural Gradient Analysis for Chinese Cities

Response of Vegetation Photosynthetic Phenology to Urbanization in Dongting Lake Basin, China

The Impact of Urbanization on Spatial–Temporal Variation in Vegetation Phenology: A Case Study of the Yangtze River Delta, China

Urbanization Effects on the Spatial Patterns of Spring Vegetation Phenology Depend on the Climatic Background

A Stronger Advance of Urban Spring Vegetation Phenology Narrows Vegetation Productivity Difference Between Urban Settings and Natural Environments.

Investigation Of Urbanization Effects On Land Surface Phenology In Northeast China During 2001-2015

The divergent response of vegetation phenology to urbanization: A case study of Beijing city, China

Impacts of Urbanization on Vegetation Phenology over the Past Three Decades in Shanghai, China

Investigation of Urbanization Effects on Land Surface Phenology in Northeast China during 2001&ndash;2015

Responses of Vegetation Phenology to Urbanization in Plateau Mountains in Yunnan, China

Contemporary Urban Expansion in China and its diverse effects

Quantification of Urban Heat Island-Induced Contribution to Advance in Spring Phenology: A Case Study in Hangzhou, China.

Urban environments provide new perspectives for forecasting vegetation phenology responses under climate warming

Study on the Spatial and Temporal Distribution of Urban Vegetation Phenology by Local Climate Zone and Urban–Rural Gradient Approach

Remote sensing monitoring of the spatiotemporal dynamics of urban forest phenology and its response to climate and urbanization

Responses of autumn vegetation phenology to climate change and urbanization at northern middle and high latitudes

Urbanization and Climate Change Jointly Shift Land Surface Phenology in the Northern Mid-Latitude Large Cities

Urbanization Effects on Climatic Changes in 24 Particular Timings of the Seasonal Cycle in the Middle and Lower Reaches of the Yellow River

The Extent of Shifts in Vegetation Phenology Between Rural and Urban Areas Within a Human‐dominated Region