Can Chinese medical teams in Africa become more effective? The example of Mali

Aissata Mahamadou Sidibe,Therese Hesketh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(18)32662-X

IF: 202.731

2018-01-01

The Lancet

Abstract:Abstract Background China has been sending medical teams to Africa since 1963. Chinese Medical Teams (CMT) are currently working in 42 African countries, constituting a large component of Chinese health aid. Mali has been receiving teams on a continuous basis since 1968. From 2011 the team in Mali has been based in the Mali Hospital in Bamako. This hospital was built with Chinese Government aid. The aim of this study was to observe how the CMT functioned, how their role was perceived, and to assess their utility for the hospital and its patients. Methods The study was carried out from January to March 2018. In-depth interviews were carried out with 12 Malian doctors and 12 nurses, all the members of the CMT (except support staff), as well as four key stakeholders and ten patients. Interviews explored views about the role of the Chinese team in the hospital, the pros and cons of the collaboration, and suggestions for improvement. CMT members were also asked about their motivation to work in Mali and how they managed the lifestyle. All interviews were carried out in private areas within the hospital. We recorded ethnographic observations of the hospital with a focus on relationships between Malian and Chinese staff, and general standards of care. Findings At the time of the study the CMT had 25 members, 18 doctors and technicians, plus support staff (cooks, translators), all living in the hospital grounds. Most of the CMT members interviewed identified similar problems, which included: lack of agreed objectives for the team members (in particular their roles as teachers or members of staff), the language barrier between Malian and Chinese staff, difficulty attracting team members, lack of representation of the CMT on the hospital management committee, and very limited social engagement between Chinese and Malian staff. However, the Malian doctors and key stakeholders viewed the CMT as a very positive presence, improving overall clinical standards and ensuring the hospitalu0027s reputation as among the best public hospitals in the country. Interpretation Our findings indicate that there needs to be a formal evaluation of the CMT programme in Mali and in other countries in Africa, to maximise utility and meet contemporary needs. This is especially relevant as the Chinese Government embarks on including global health as part of the Belt and Road initiative. Funding Global Health Centre of Zhejiang University.