Abstract:With regard to measuring nitrous oxide (N 2 O) emissions from biological sources, there are three most widely adopted methods that use gas chromatograph with an electron capture detector (GC–ECD). They use: (a) nitrogen (N 2 ) as the carrier gas (DN); (b) ascarite as a carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) trap with DN (DN-Ascarite); and (c) a mixture gas of argon and methane as the carrier (AM). Additional methods that use either a mixture of argon and methane (or of CO 2 and N 2 ) as a make-up gas with the carrier nitrogen or soda lime (or ascarite) as a CO 2 trap with the carrier helium have also been adopted in a few studies. To test the hypothesis that the use of DN sometimes considerably biases measurements of N 2 O emissions from plants, soils or soil–plant systems, experiments were conducted involving DN, AM and DN-Ascarite. When using DN, a significant relationship appeared between CO 2 concentrations and the apparent N 2 O concentrations in air samples. The use of DN led to significantly overestimated N 2 O emissions from detached fresh plants in static chamber enclosures. Meanwhile, comparably lower emissions were found when using either the DN-Ascarite or AM methods. When an N 2 O flux (from a soil or a soil–plant system), measured by DN in combination with sampling from the enclosure of a static opaque chamber, was greater than 200 μg N m −2 h −1 , no significant difference was found between DN and DN-Ascarite. When the DN-measured fluxes were within the ranges of <−30, −30–0, 0–30, 30–100 and 100–200 μg N m −2 h −1 , significant differences that amounted to −72, −22, 5, 38 and 64 μg N m −2 h −1 , respectively, appeared in comparison to DN-Ascarite. As a result, the DN measurements in rice–wheat and vegetable fields overestimated both annual total N 2 O emissions (by 7–62%, p < 0.05) and direct emission factors for applied nitrogen (by 6–65%). These results suggest the necessity of reassessing the available data determined from DN measurements before they are applied to inventory estimation. Further studies are required to explore appropriate approaches for the necessary reassessment. Our results also imply that the DN method should not be adopted for measuring N 2 O emissions from weak sources (e.g., with intensities less than 200 μg N m −2 h −1 ). In addition, we especially do not recommend the use of DN to simultaneously measure N 2 O and CO 2 with the same ECD.

Comparison of flux gradient and chamber techniques to measure soil N 2 O emissions

Comparison of flux gradient and chamber techniques to measure soil N<sub>2</sub>O emissions

Comparison of Slant Open-Path Flux Gradient and Static Closed Chamber Techniques to Measure Soil N2O Emissions

Gaseous Emissions from an Intensive Vegetable Farm Measured with Slant-Path FTIR Technique

Use of open-path FTIR and inverse dispersion technique to quantify gaseous nitrogen loss from an intensive vegetable production site

On-farm Assessment of Nitrogen Fertilizer Application to Corn on Nitrous Oxide Emissions

Quantification of N 2 O fluxes from soil–plant systems may be biased by the applied gas chromatograph methodology

Interactive comment on “ Comparison of flux gradient and chamber techniques to measure soil N 2 O emissions ” by Mei

Measurement and mitigation of nitrous oxide emissions from a high nitrogen input vegetable system

Methodological Comparison between a Novel Automatic Sampling System for Gas Chromatography versus Photoacoustic Spectroscopy for Measuring Greenhouse Gas Emissions under Field Conditions

Applicability of a gas analyzer with dual quantum cascade lasers for simultaneous measurements of N2O, CH4 and CO2 fluxes from cropland using the eddy covariance technique

A Dual Dynamic Chamber System Based on IBBCEAS for Measuring Fluxes of Nitrous Acid in Agricultural Fields in the North China Plain

The influence of tillage and fertilizer on the flux and source of nitrous oxide with reference to atmospheric variation using laser spectroscopy

Performance of open-path lasers and FTIR spectroscopic systems

Diel and Seasonal Nitrous Oxide Fluxes Determined by Floating Chamber and Gas Transfer Equation Methods in Agricultural Irrigation Watersheds in Southeast China

Effects Of N Fertilizer Application On Soil N2o Emissions And Ch4 Uptake: A Two-Year Study In An Apple Orchard In Eastern China

Towards a standard non-steady-state chamber methodology for measuring soil N2O emissions

Performance of Open-Path Lasers and Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopic Systems in Agriculture Emissions Research

Attempt to correct grassland N2O fluxes biased by the DN-based opaque static chamber measurement

Influence of deployment time and surface wind speed on the accuracy of measurements of greenhouse gas fluxes using a closed chamber method under low surface wind speed.

Seasonal Variations in N 2 and N 2 O Emissions from a Wheat–maize Cropping System