Abstract:Three major concerns drove the U.S. into initiating the trade war, and they are (a) the concern that China’s chronically large trade surplus was depressing job creation in the U.S. (b) the concern that China was using illegal and unfair methods to acquire U.S. technology at an effectively discounted price; and (c) the concern that China seeks to weaken U.S. national security and its international standing. On the dispute over China’s exchange rate and trade imbalance, the first conclusion is that it was marked by analytical confusion over the meaning of the term ‘equilibrium exchange rate’. The second conclusion is that China’s trade imbalance reflects the economic conditions in both China and U.S., and that the efficient and fair solution of the problem requires policy changes in both countries. On the industrial policy dispute, the first conclusion is that the issue of forced technology transfer is largely a dispute about China using its market power to benefit itself at the expense of its trade partners. The second conclusion is that China’s use of market power can last only until the other large countries could unite and retaliate as a group. The inevitability of retaliation means that China should replace the joint-venture (JV) mechanism for technological diffusion with other ways to strengthen its technological capability. On the U.S. concern about whether China trade weakens its national security, the first conclusion is that the notion of national security that is commonly adopted in the U.S. trade policy debate is ignorant about the primary determinants of U.S. capability in innovation. By focusing instead mainly on how to hold down China technologically, the long-run outcome will be a technologically weaker U.S. and hence, a more vulnerable U.S. The second conclusion is that the U.S. must identify a clear, short list of critical technologies and critical infrastructure for the recently reformed Committee for Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) to cover, and update this list constantly. Otherwise, the broad and changing nature of notions about national security would allow the bureaucratically driven phenomenon of mission-creep to steadily expand the coverage of the CFIUS process, thereby steadily rendering CFIUS to be operationally capricious. Our principal policy suggestion to China is that, because China’s economy in 2018 is very different from that in 1978 (e.g. many parts of China now look like Singapore and China is Africa’s biggest donor), there should be more reciprocity in China’s trade and investment relations with the advanced economies despite China’s status as a developing economy under WTO rules. Our principal policy suggestion to President Trump is to stop equating strategic competition with economic competition. Strategic competition is normally a zero-sum game. While fair economic competition is usually a zero-sum game in the short run, it generally creates a win-win outcome in the long run.

China–US Trade Disputes in 2018: an Overview

Overview of China–US economic disputes in 2018

The Sino-US Trade Conflicts and US Economic Interests in China

The 2018 US-China trade conflict after forty years of special protection

China's Trade Relations with the United States in Perspective

The Dimensions of the US-China Trade War

U.S.–China economic tensions: origins and global implications

The economic impact of the US-China trade dispute

Understanding the U.S.-China Trade War

China’s Policy Response to the China US Trade War: An Initial Assessment

US-China Trade War and the Future of US-Sino Relations

From Economic Cooperation to Strategic Competition: Understanding the US-China Trade Disputes through the Transformed Relations

Interpreting US-China Trade War Background, Negotiations and Consequences

Towards Economic Decoupling? Mapping Chinese Discourse on the China–US Trade War

Trade Conflict Between the U.S. and China: What Are the Impacts on the Chinese Economy?

Analysis on the Political Factors in Sino-US Economic and Trade Relation

The Impact of China/US Trade Friction on China's Electronic Product Exports

Analysis of the Causes and Countermeasures of the Escalation of Sino-US Trade Friction

Developments in US Trade Policy Amid the Shifting Dynamics of World Trade

China–US Economic and Trade Relations: Trump and Beyond

A skeletal review of the Sino-U.S. “trade war”: contentious issues, trade multilateralism and policy recommendations