Abstract:We examine the dynamics of informational efficiency in a market with asymmetrically informed, boundedly rational traders who adaptively learn optimal strategies using simple multiarmed bandit (MAB) algorithms. The strategies available to the traders have two dimensions: on the one hand, the traders must endogenously choose whether to acquire a costly information signal, on the other, they must determine how aggressively they trade by choosing the share of their wealth to be invested in the risky asset. Our study contributes to two strands of literature: the literature comparing the effects of competitive and strategic behavior on asset price efficiency under costly information as well as the actively growing literature on algorithmic tacit collusion and pseudo-collusion in financial markets. We find that for certain market environments (with low information costs) our model reproduces the results of Kyle [1989] in that the ability of traders to trade strategically leads to worse price efficiency compared to the purely competitive case. For other environments (with high information costs), on the other hand, our results show that a market with strategically acting traders can be more efficient than a purely competitive one. Furthermore, we obtain novel results on the ability of independently learning traders to coordinate on a pseudo-collusive behavior, leading to non-competitive pricing. Contrary to some recent contributions (see e.g. [Cartea et al. 2022]), we find that the pseudo-collusive behavior in our model is robust to a large number of agents, demonstrating that even in the setting of financial markets with a large number of independently learning traders non-competitive pricing and pseudo-collusive behavior can frequently arise.

Price Informativeness and Adaptive Trading

Competitive Trading and Endogenous Learning of Asymmetrically Informed Investors

Adaptive Expectations, Confirmatory Bias, and Informational Efficiency

A structural analysis of price dynamics for a heterogeneous asset-pricing model with market marker

Trading Frequency and Information Efficiency: Theory and Evidence from US and Chinese Markets

Transparency and market efficiency: A study of adaptive learning with asymmetric information

Evolutionary Game Model of Trading Strategies and Price Formation

Impact of information cost and switching of trading strategies in an artificial stock market

A model of adaptive, market behavior generating positive returns, volatility and system risk

Structural estimation of behavioral heterogeneity

Price Informativeness and Investment Sensitivity to Stock Price

Market efficiency, informational asymmetry and pseudo-collusion of adaptively learning agents

Optimal trading and competition with information in the price impact model

On the limits of informationally efficient stock markets: New insights from a chartist-fundamentalist model

Stralegic Interaction between Informed and Uninformed Traders

Strategic Trading when Some Investors Receive Partly Information

Uninformed Traders' Strategic Trading Model And Equilibrium Pricing

Ambiguity and asset prices with incompletely informed trading

Unstable Price Dynamics as a Result of Information Absorption in Speculative Markets

An empirical heterogeneous trading strategy model in the Shanghai stock market of China

Strategic Trading Under Condition Of Heterogeneous Information