Abstract:Abstract. Remote sensing of cloud effective particle size with passive sensors like the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) is an important tool for cloud microphysical studies. As a measure of the radiatively relevant droplet size, effective radius can be retrieved with different combinations of visible through shortwave and midwave infrared channels. In practice, retrieved effective radii from these combinations can be quite different. This difference is perhaps indicative of different penetration depths and path lengths for the spectral reflectances used. In addition, operational liquid water cloud retrievals are based on the assumption of a relatively narrow distribution of droplet sizes; the role of larger precipitation particles in these distributions is neglected. Therefore, possible explanations for the discrepancy in some MODIS spectral size retrievals could include 3-D radiative transport effects, including sub-pixel cloud inhomogeneity, and/or the impact of drizzle formation. For three cloud cases the possible factors of influence are isolated and investigated in detail by the use of simulated cloud scenes and synthetic satellite data: marine boundary layer cloud scenes from large eddy simulations (LES) with detailed microphysics are combined with Monte Carlo radiative transfer calculations that explicitly account for the detailed droplet size distributions as well as 3-D radiative transfer to simulate MODIS observations. The operational MODIS optical thickness and effective radius retrieval algorithm is applied to these and the results are compared to the given LES microphysics. We investigate two types of marine cloud situations each with and without drizzle from LES simulations: (1) a typical daytime stratocumulus deck at two times in the diurnal cycle and (2) one scene with scattered cumulus. Only small impact of drizzle formation on the retrieved domain average and on the differences between the three effective radius retrievals is noticed for both cloud scene types for different reasons. For our, presumably typical, overcast stratocumulus scenes with an optical thickness of 8 to 9 and rain rates at cloud bottom up to 0.05 mm/h clear drizzle impact on the retrievals can be excluded. The cumulus scene does not show much drizzle sensitivity either despite extended drizzle areas being directly visible from above (locally >1 mm/h), which is mainly due to technical characteristics of the standard retrieval approach. 3-D effects, on the other hand, produce large discrepancies between the 1.6 and 2.1 μm channel observations compared to 3.7 μm retrievals in the latter case. A general sensitivity of MODIS particle size data to drizzle formation is not corroborated by our case studies.

Under What Conditions Can We Trust Retrieved Cloud Drop Concentrations in Broken Marine Stratocumulus?

How Cloud Droplet Number Concentration Impacts Liquid Water Path and Precipitation in Marine Stratocumulus Clouds—A Satellite-Based Analysis Using Explainable Machine Learning

Aircraft Evaluation of MODIS Cloud Drop Number Concentration Retrievals

Application of Deep Convective Cloud Albedo Observation to Satellite-Based Study of the Terrestrial Atmosphere: Monitoring the Stability of Spaceborne Measurements and Assessing Absorption Anomaly.

Satellite Retrieval of Cloud Condensation Nuclei Concentrations in Marine Stratocumulus by Using Clouds As CCN Chambers

Microphysical and Radiative Properties of Boundary Layer Stratiform Clouds Deduced from Ground‐based Measurements

Evaluation of four ground-based retrievals of cloud droplet number concentration in marine stratocumulus with aircraft in situ measurements

Robust Susceptibility of Cloud Cover and Radiative Effects to Biases in Retrieved Droplet Concentrations

Frequency and causes of failed MODIS cloud property retrievals for liquid phase clouds over global oceans

Deriving cloud droplet number concentration from surface-based remote sensors with an emphasis on lidar measurements

Study of Global Cloud Droplet Number Concentration with A-Train Satellites

Validation of satellite-retrieved CCN based on a cruise campaign over the polluted Northwestern Pacific ocean

Evaluation of Cloud Microphysical Properties Derived From MODIS and Himawari‐8 Using In Situ Aircraft Measurements Over the Southern Ocean

An Efficient Method for Microphysical Property Retrievals in Vertically Inhomogeneous Marine Water Clouds Using MODIS-CloudSat Measurements

Testing remote sensing on artificial observations: impact of drizzle and 3-D cloud structure on effective radius retrievals

Satellite‐Based Estimation of Cloud Top Radiative Cooling Rate for Marine Stratocumulus

Importance of Vertical Velocity Variations in the Cloud Droplet Nucleation Process of Marine Stratus Clouds

Relating Satellite-Observed Cloud Properties from MODIS to Meteorological Conditions for Marine Boundary Layer Clouds

A Comparison of MODIS-Derived Cloud Fraction with Surface Observations at Five SURFRAD Sites

Bias in MODIS cloud drop effective radius for oceanic water clouds as deduced from optical thickness variability across scattering angles