Abstract:Purpose - The purpose of this paper is to investigate how accountants interpret verbal uncertainty expressions with a focus on numeric-to-verbal translation.Design/methodology/approach - Accounting for loss contingencies (SFAS 5) were chosen as a setting to study this research question. The approach used was a behavioral experiment where participants choose probability phrases for 11 numeric probabilities for two default conditions.Findings - The results indicate a clear pattern, where thresholds for accrual and disclosure decisions can be easily identified in the numeric-to-verbal translation. Also, the base rate appears to affect the assessment of the uncertainty related to potential default, but does not affect mapping of numeric values to verbal terms.Research limitations/implications - The use of 11 probabilities does not cover all regions of the [0, 1] probability line and may leave regions of the probability interval not mapping to any SFAS 5 phrase. Also, this study uses upper-level undergraduate accounting students, whose judgments are similar to novice auditors but may differ from experienced auditors.Practical implications - The evidence suggests that unlike verbal-to-numeric translation, which is unstable and context dependent, numeric-to-verbal translation is quite consistent among individuals, and is unlikely to be affected by the contextual information. The results complement prior findings in auditors' judgment, and suggest that interpreting uncertainty expressions can be improved if auditors are encouraged to use numeric-to-verbal translation when they apply accounting and auditing standards in forming an opinion on the financial report.Originality/value - This is the first paper to examine the mapping of numeric probabilities to verbal probability terms.

An Experimental Investigation of Dimensional Precision in Uncertainty Disclosures Related to Revenue Recognition

The Joint Effects of Management Incentive and Information Precision on Perceived Reliability in Fair Value Estimates

Individual Investors' Perceptions of Risk Associated with Internal Control Deficiency Information Disclosure:An Experimental Study

The Value of Being Precise

The Effects of Ambiguity on Loss Contingency Evaluation by Auditors and Investors

The Appeal of Vague Financial Forecasts

On The Appeal Of Vague Financial Forecasts

Information disclosure quality: correlation versus precision

Endogenous Information Disclosure and Corporate Governance

Experimental Evidence for Risk Warning Information,Integrity of Management and the Investors' Decision

Numeric‐to‐verbal Translation of Probability Expressions in SFAS 5

The Role of Internal Control Disclosure in Financial Reporting Precision and the Quality of Audited Financial Reports

The Joint Effect of Presentation Format and Disclosure Balance on Investors’ Reactions to Sensitivity Disclosures of Hedging Instruments

Exploring Ambiguity and Familiarity Effects in the “earnings Game” Between Managers and Investors

Managerial incentives and management forecast precision

The Effects of Asymmetric Disclosure on Price Informativeness and Firm Performance

Accounting Treatment of Inherent Versus Incentive Uncertainties and the Capital Structure of the Firm

Do Investors React Differently to Range and Point Management Earnings Forecasts?

The Uneven Returns of Transparency in Voluntary Nonfinancial Disclosures

Differential Ability to Recognize Emerging Developments and Corporate Performance Under Uncertainty

Operational Uncertainty and Managerial Incentives in Information Production